Axo Profile picture
Aug 16, 2022 22 tweets 9 min read Read on X
Why Total-Value-Locked is a nonsense metric that will make you poor.

- Thread Time 🧵-

#cardano #ada $ada #CardanoVasil
1/ Intro

This month, 2 Solana developer brothers admitted to pretending to be 11 different devs, who jointly created Dapps that accounted for $7.5bn in value.

The catch? It was all fake. Every single dollar was counted SEVERAL times over.

coindesk.com/layer2/2022/08…
2/ Identity Crisis

This event made many investors wonder whether commonly used investing metrics are manipulable. Chief among them is Total-Value-Locked (TVL), which many investors thought was the key to finding valuable protocols in the DeFi space

Does TVL have any value?
3/ TVL

This metric is meant to represent the Total Value Locked in a protocol that cannot be easily liquidated or moved due to lockup conditions. The higher this metric, the more trust, network effects and positive momentum there is for a project... Or so the theory goes.
4/ Valuating Digital Assets

Tech corps are difficult to price, as growth is nonlinear and direct costs are more or less fixed (Twitter has similar infrastructure costs servicing 1m people vs 1bn). Same happens with crypto, thus investors create new metrics for estimating value.
5/ Gaming the System

As we learned during the Dotcom era, the issue is that when startups see investors using a certain valuation metric, they restructure their business to inflate their own metric.

Thus the number not only becomes unusable, but dangerous and misleading.
6/ The Dangers of TVL

TVL is an attempt to measure popularity and community commitment. But since the same dollars can be ‘folded’ into themselves, and count as more $, it gives a skewed picture of how much adoption there is. TVL might even end up being a sign of inefficiency.
7/ High TVL = Inefficiency

Imagine you have a protocol that has $1bn in daily trading volume, but a TVL of $100bn. That is not efficient, as it implies that 99% of the capital is underutilized. High TVL, without high trading volume, might just imply bloat, NOT desirability.
8/ TVL Was Mainly For DEXs

In traditional DEXs, where you lock your assets in a jointly-owned smart contract, you need large liquidity. Otherwise, minor withdrawals of any token cause massive slippage - difference between the expected and final execution price.
9/ Next-Generation DEXs

In the future, when liquidity will be modeled efficiently, and users don’t need to pool their assets, the goal will be the opposite - a low TVL that serves a volume far higher than itself. This will be the era of hyper-efficient DeFi.
10/ Why TVL Got Popular

DEXs were the first large-scale smart contract projects, so their operational standards framed our understanding of the rest of the DeFi industry. That said, these early assumptions have become increasingly outdated and incentivize unhealthy protocols.
11/ Going to the LUNA

A perfect example is LUNA where a high initial TVL increased its coin value, allowing its treasury to purchase more BTC, increasing its TVL and then token value. Every TVL increase weakened the protocol, as people wondered how this was at all sustainable
12/ ADA & TVL

ADA is often mocked for its low TVL, supposedly making it a poor investment. Yet this utilitarian assessment completely ignores user experience.

Are you going to place your money somewhere where it's LOCKED for months, or instantly available?
13/ Suitcase Logic

If you put $1m into a $5 suitcase, the bag is only worth $1m + $5 until you take the million dollars

If you want the suitcase to increase in value, then you must increase people's demand for the bag, not just hope some millionaire places their net worth there
14/ Kidnapped Value

We should not have a valuation metric based on Stockholm Syndrome, where a protocol is only valuable in direct proportion to how much value it can kidnap from its users.

Not only is this capital inefficient, but misaligns the desires of users and developers.
15/ Blockchains Survive Via Community

As most crypto projects are open source, projects live and die by community adoption and network effects gained from their widespread use. Any honest metric should take into account value created for their users, not just locked value.
16/ What Even is Locked?

Due to the fact that TVL isn’t based on sound principles, and grew organically, everyone has a different definition. Sites will arbitrarily decide not to include certain “locked value” but others do. We should standardize what “locking value” even means.
17/ Proposed Solution

TVL is an outdated and AMM-specific metric. We need metrics that measure intrinsic value. Only by measuring the intrinsic value we can estimate what the suitcase is really worth.
18/ Useful Metrics

For instance, trading platforms should have low slippage, deep liquidity (especially around the spread aka the current price), and high transaction volume (being popular).
19/ Shadows and Dust

The chief factor that we ought to consider is the utility that a protocol provides and how effectively it does so - all else is secondary and manipulable. It’s not to say that we should never consider financial metrics, but the map is not the territory.
20/ Conclusion

TVL is a metric we invented to measure value in an evolving industry. However, as we saw in the case of the Solana brothers, TVL has failed to account for the complexity of crypto - it's nonsense!

It's time to put TVL in a drawer and lock it there for good.
If you enjoyed this thread, please like, retweet, and subscribe to
@CardanoMaladex 🧵

Make sure to check out our ongoing #TradFiTales series too:

blog.maladex.com/tradfi-tales-c…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Axo

Axo Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @axotrade

Jul 4
The Axo Guide series will serve as a weekly preview of our upcoming multimedia Axo resource, starting with Receipts. 🧾

In this thread, we'll cover:

🔹 What Receipts are
🔹 Why we need them
🔹 How to burn them
🔹 Best practices

🧵 1/7Image
Receipts are NFTs that contain information about a particular trading strategy on Axo, including a visual representation.

Every strategy creates 2 identical NFTs. One lives in the strategy and the other in your wallet. Only the NFT holder can interact with the strategy.🔐

🧵2/7 Image
Axo's programmable swaps are submitted to the blockchain via Receipts (commit phase). ⛓️

In a future thread, we will cover the anatomy of programmable swaps.

Receipts are perfectly parallelizable and contain strategy information like price, time, and trade history.

🧵3/7
Read 7 tweets
May 16, 2023
How to make sense of memecoins.

- Thread Time 🧵-

#Cardano Image
1/ Intro

Memecoin fever has gripped Cardano, and it has a lot of people confused. How is it possible that in the midst of the iciest of bear markets, there is still enough dry powder to create a speculative mania?

Today we will be discussing the economics of memecoins.
2/ On the Origin of Memecoins

Memes are units of culture, they’re small packets of information that contain a basic idea that is interesting enough to get passed on and evolve through each generation it exists in.

Memecoins, on the other hand, are tokenized viral ideas.
Read 16 tweets
May 4, 2023
Active vs passive investing:

Why monkeys might be better investors than degens.

- Thread Time 🧵-

#Cardano Image
1/ Intro

In investing, there are two main camps:

- Active: Where you make regular decisions to address your investing needs
- Passive: Where you fund a specific strategy & keep doing so indefinitely

Both have their benefits and weaknesses, which we will explore in this thread.
2/ Active Investing

When the average person thinks about investing, they think of active investing - of an investor finding some secret pattern in the data and striking it rich because of it. Unfortunately, the reality is more complicated than that.
Read 15 tweets
Apr 19, 2023
DeFi will defy expectations - why on-chain identities are essential for mass adoption of #Cardano.

- Thread Time 🧵- Image
1/ Intro

Now that the angry dust is clearing from the contingent staking debate, perhaps it's worth discussing why on-chain identity verification can be very important to mass adoption.

It's not without its tradeoffs, but it is needed if we want to fully bloom to our potential
2/ Adoption

If you want to attract the enormous liquidity of financial institutions, you need to allow for TradFi to work in DeFi by allowing legacy operational procedures to work on-chain.

In other words, users need to have freedom to decide how and when transactions execute. Image
Read 16 tweets
Mar 28, 2023
Building a portfolio that survives the bear market.

- Thread Time 🧵-

#axotrade #defi #cardano #ada #cardanocommunity $ada
1/ Intro

Bears are vicious creatures, you blink for a second, and they can rip away any gains you had with a single swipe.

In this thread, we'll discuss the three genres of assets and how to build a portfolio that can not only survive the bear market but thrive.
2/ Asset Genres

Whether you're talking about stocks, real estate, commodities, etc., they all broadly fall into three broad archetypes that denote their behavior within a complex system:

- Fragile
- Robust
- Antifragile
Read 13 tweets
Mar 9, 2023
How to tackle Cardano's governance.

- Thread Time 🧵-

#axotrade #cardano #cardanocommunity #ada $ada #defi
1/ Intro

Cardano is entering the age of Voltaire, the age of community governance.

This is going to be a critical development period, which will, in no small part, determine the future of the blockchain.

In this thread, we'll discuss the pitfalls and solutions to governance.
2/ 1st Principles

The problem that governance seeks to solve is what is termed in finance as the "principal-agent problem" (PAP), as in when stakeholders nominate someone to represent them, but they're unsure if the agent will act in the stakeholder's best interests or their own
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(