Erik Zimerman Profile picture
Feb 3 19 tweets 6 min read
Following up on the Kreminna forest front. I believe it is critical for #Russian forces to seal off the length of the forest belt along the Siverskyi river. To do to this southern forest flank precisely what they were not able to do to the western flank of the Izium forest belt
a few months back (and as discussed in the quoted previous post). So this is what we are talking about, a combination of complex river system (Siverskyi Donets) or alluvial plain with natural dense forests, and a wider managed forestry plantation. Russia has been able to hold
Dobrova (which was key), and edges of the forest south of Kreminna. Torske and Zarichne are held by UA forces easily supplied from a build up in Lyman. However, with Dibrova in RU hands, UA forces are using river crossings in the south from the Siversk front to greatly multiply
the length of threatened front against RU and it supply lines as it tries to push west towards Torske. The forest allows an approach right up to the city of Kreminna, the critical supply rail and road hub. While RU is doing its best to hold the front from the north as it should
(see previous post), I believe the key to this particular section lies in the south, cutting off the access of UA forces across the Siverskyi Donets river. The length of forest belt with exposed flanks then becomes untannable, & UA forces must once again withdraw or face
encirclement as Russian foces advance on Siversk in the south, and on Torske (then Yampil) in the north. The pressure on Kreminna would immediately be lessened. The idea is simple. Bilohorivka is very strongly defended by UA forces utilizing its high ground. RU forces however, by
design or happenchance of the combat, have access to the plain south of the river deep towards Siversk. There has been quite a few indications that this is the case. RU forces therefore, while keeping pressure on Bilohorivka from the east and southeast, should advance and seize
Serebrianka and/or Hryhorivka, thus cutting off and encircling troops at Bilohorivkal. It would be quite interesting that the town whose seizure sealed the Lysychansk-Severodonetsk cauldron (as I discussed many times previous to its occurrence ie ), could
now be the town, once again in UA hands, itself in the next cauldron. Rather than head to the wal, it is Serebriank and Hryhorivka that are the easier targets to encircle Bilohorivka. The capture of either is likely to ensure the capture of all 3 towns along the river, cutting
off the flank & supply of the forest belt threatening Kreminna. From here RU forces could advance on the high ground north of Siversk (as other forces advance north along the ridges from the south), turn back on the rear of strong UA positions holding the eastern Siversk front,
and cut off access to the forest belt from across the Donets. From here the battle for Yampil and Torske would be much easier and the logistical hub of Kremiina and its surroundings stabizlied. Ukraine, aware of this, ought to pour many resources on all 3 towns on the south bank
of the river to prevent this and put much of its offensive resources across the forest onto the Kreminna roads (as well as along the entire northern front). It's ability to advance on strongly held RU lines is nearly non existent, and it cannot stop strong RU advances but only
slow them and yet it remains committed to doing these two almost exclusively. That and of course endless sideshows of life wasting special forces missions. On a daily basis we see UA DRGs and special units attempting missions of little sense, no chance of success and potentially
high PR value. Interestingly the one time UA built up strength to attack RU's achilles heel, rather than use all its strength to contest every meter of ground, it did quite well. Much harder to replicate now but it could still try. The starkness of this reality is not felt by
most people because according to mainstream coverage Ukraine has almost consistently always been winning. The reality is virtually the exact reverse situation, and this is why the advance on the Khakrhov front was quite a feat (I will hopefully get to write on that soon as well).
In any event, Zelensky's regime having failed to be astute enough to prevent a war it likely cannot win (and in fact brought it about), is not being anywhere near astute enough to brave the odds and win. This does not mean however, that with the economic might of the west behind
it, Russia could afford to be any less so. So by my way or any other way, we shall see if the Kreminna forest belt is secured, while the advance on Siversk and encirclment of Bakhmut is achieved. Then shall we see a humbled regime ready to make peace, or will the Slovansk line
be next? Will the media carry the war forward going on about this or that magical weapon that will turn the tide...? The bayraktar, the nlaw, the HIMARs, now I believe its a few leporard 2 tanks coming in months. I will enjoy writing about it all, but in the meantime some of the
last fierce european men, cousins if not brothers by birth, brave the snowy steppe and battle each other to death.

#RussiaUkraineWar #Ukraine #UkraineRussiaWar

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Erik Zimerman

Erik Zimerman Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ZimermanErik

Feb 3
We now get to discuss the #Kreminna front finally. In light red (DPA map)we see very roughly future likely #Russian lines of advance around #Bakhmut & #Siversk. Hope to discuss those again in detail but for now let us assume these involve an operational encirclement of Bakhmut
(followed by a total one) and an advance on Siversk by hitting the strong eastern UA line from the rear, and advancing northwards along the high ground. This would push the front to the final Donbass line of defense, the formidable Kostyanivka - Slovansk line. The menacing
creature to the Russian effort is the often ignored Kreminna front, especially its thick forest belt. It is here where UA forces can leverage their preference for forest cover and assault the less densely defended northern/Kharkhov front, where they made such large gains a few
Read 17 tweets
Feb 2
#Russian sources have released this striking video purported to be of an S-300 AA battery being destroyed around Kreminna (a front I wish to update about shortly). I however have geolocated it to Lisa Stinka
aout 70km from the Kreminna front line. The S-300 is a very powerful proven anti air system. If the video is indeed new, the relative ease in which the RU UAV is flying over enemy territory to direct a strike on a S-300 (can't verify that but it does look like it) battery deep
behind enemy lines is further proof of the growing confidence and proficiency of of RU forces in the air. #Ukraine started out the war with up to 100 S-300 systems, though most were likely in a bad state of disrepair and many have been destroyed. However, a core group of working
Read 12 tweets
Feb 1
Part II

The second reason for the partial failure of the first RU attack was I believe, not attacking the coal mine to the NE first. Let me summarize. #Russian forces including Marines from the Baltic Fleet surged out of Pavlivka and Mykil's'ke and converged on the residential
sector that was still UA held. Before fully securing the area (there were reports of local firefights with pockets of UA troops trapped behind RU lines persisted for about 1.5 days) RU troops surged northwards towards #Vuhledar. They secured most of the eastern dacha area &
reached the outskirts of Vuhledar itself. There were reports of fighting in the eastern sector around the pumping station. It seems RU forces gained a foothold in the town. I believe they wanted to proceed to surround it rather than press the assault further (second image).
Read 14 tweets
Feb 1
Very interesting battle happening at Vuhledar (Ugledar). The #Russians have recently clearly improved their field maneuverability and have been showing a greater preference for envelopment, and encirclement over frontal artillery grind. This has also significantly reduced their
daily shell consumption. In any event, #Vuhledar is an unusual town in this war. The town lies in a very flat (even for Ukraine) part of the country. However, this coal "boom" town is filled with high density buildings, the type that we have seen make capture by RU very difficult
& preferred defense areas for UA forces, especially in winter. The small but dense town is highly strategic for several reasons. Among them is that this fortress town is what protects the UA bulge threatening a key railway. Much has been made of the Crimea - Donetsk land bridge
Read 13 tweets
Jan 12
Lots of folks excited today about the classified documents found at #Biden's think tank, so let us chime in.

Firstly, the response ought not to be that the FBI should raid Biden's home as well (for this), but that #Trump's should not have.
The right ought to be against the politicization of law enforcement and prosecution, as opposed to favoring its use against the left.

The right should want to return to a freer and more constitutional state, rather than a banana republic and police state where those in power
currently put those out of power in prison, as is the case in much of the world.

If the point is to show the double standard of the media, and the alarming & ruthless bias against conservatives which permeate the government bureaucracies, including the DOJ, then by all means.
Read 23 tweets
Jan 11
Grain Part III

During the 1971 India-Pakistan war, India gained naval superiority and blockaded the coast of East-Pakistan (now Bangladesh). During the decade long "Tanker War", Iran blockaded Iraq in 1986 when they captured the Al-Faw peninsula. This allowed them to blockade
all shipping in and out of the Shatt al-Arab, the confluence of the famous Tigris and Eupharates rivers that empties into the Persian Gulf. Iraq became virtually landlocked and required access to the sea through Kuwait and Jordan. By 1988, Iraq had pushed the rapidly collapsing
Iranians back and regained access (though still somewhat restricted) to the sea.

Since then, the US has used ever more frequent exclusion zones, including "Anti-Terror" Zones, "Defensive Sea Bubbles" which move along with her forces, and more. In fact, for the US, Naval blockade
Read 26 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(