Working as a counsellor and drawing on personal experience as someone who’s immunocompromised, I’m ever conscious of the growing gulf between private and public experiences in this pandemic.
Survivorship Bias refers our mental short cut that focuses us on stories of success, not failure. This distorts our world view and also impacts our capacity to assess risk in a pandemic where public health has been dumped in favour of ‘personal responsibility’. #COVID19
It comes from a famous example from World War Two when the military tried to assess the damage on returning planes in order to protect future ones and initially decided the planes’ extremities like wings etc were most vulnerable. #CovidIsntOver
They failed to consider their survivorship bias until Mathematician Abraham Wald pointed out that returning planes had survived gunfire and it was the ones that did not return eg those that were hit in the body and therefore this area that needed reinforcement. #CovidIsNotOver
Everyday in my counselling work, I hear multiple Australian stories of illness, disability, trauma, grief and loss both directly caused by and compounded by the #COVID19 pandemic. I also hear these stories increasingly from family and friends. I am aware these stories impact me.
Like millions of us, I also increasingly navigate the world
via social media. #CovidIsNotOver
I’m increasingly aware of the ever growing disconnect between real life and the superficially edited and manicured version of life on social media. #CovidIsNotOver
Many of us therefore withdraw from these spaces or learn not to share much of our lives. We thankfully also find and retreat to safe spaces which but this means the chasm widens. #CovidIsNotOver
Our political leaders and media reinforce and mirror these distortions and the delusion that #COVID19 is over and thus the survivorship bias snowballs.
This our growing awareness of this survivorship bias challenges us all to push back against othering and exclusion, to take risks in being the ones to educate, inform, include and share our warts and all experiences of our lives during the #COVID19 pandemic. #CovidIsNotOver
1. 2 psychological theories, Kahneman’s ‘Thinking Fast and Slow’ and Solomon et al’s ‘Terror Management Theory’ on why humans are vulnerable to thinking errors and how these combined with mortal terror, impede a rational response to global threats such as the #Covid19 pandemic.
2.Kahneman in ‘Thinking Fast and Slow’ (2011) described two systems of human thought guiding behaviour- System 1: An unconscious, automatic, fast thinking system based on the limbic system and System 2: A slower, rational thinking response led by the neocortex #COVID19 /25
3.Kahneman argues that as a species, we view ourselves as distinct from animals due to our capacity to use system 2 to think, plan and act rationally, however in reality we rely more heavily on system 1, often to our own detriment. #CovidIsntOver
/25
Understanding the experiences of those of us still wearing face masks in the West. 1/17
John A Powell writes: “When societies experience big and rapid change, a frequent response is for people to narrowly define who qualifies as a full member of society – a process I call “Othering”. 2/17
The rapid changes brought about by the Covid 19 Pandemic now in its 4th year, has resulted in face mask wearers in the west, now being represented as ‘the other’. 3/17
Like wearing clothes, seat belts, bicycle helmets etc mask wearing can initially be a bit uncomfortable and inconvenient, requiring extra costs and efforts.
As a practice over time, with public health education and government support, mask wearing becomes habitual.
2/16
Mask wearing is hardest psychologically because Western media, primarily Murdoch and big business, have politicised and weaponised masks, exploiting millions of years of mammalian conditioning that makes non-conformity with the herd, dangerous.
3/16