Explains how the word final in Article 110 (3) does not mean the certification is beyond judicial review and shows how there is a long line of precedent.
The first one he will develop now is back to PMLA. And the consent form. The absurdity of giving consent in the form when you are mandated by law to link failing which your account is inoperable!
Wonders if consent should receive....
APD says how His Lordship may not face it but others have to show their id card while entering airport. Using it for something like is different.
But to say one cannot
Then moves to the next argument on consent. How consent has been understood under jurisprudence as consensus ad idem since 1872 contract Act.
Including a senate proceedings that appear to echo all data aggregation and data surveillance issues at play in this case.
DYC J wonders what is the compelling state interest anyway for pvt players to ask for aadhaar! Section 7 is understandable. APD agrees. Says ....
Goes into the absurdity of Tirupati requiring aadhaar for darshan!
(Me thinks: Amazed that TTD does not have a twitter handle).
Manifest arbitrariness. Destroys existing identities. Constitutional rights such as right to food...
Also Regulation 29. Refers to absolute shocking reference to Children aadhaar numbers being deactivated automatically at 5 years.
SikriJ says he understands the same after Justice Nariman judgment in Triple Talaq case and Puttaswamy judgment.
Court rises for lunch.