Phil Booth Profile picture
Mind 'for hire'; critical friend to just causes. Formerly and currently @NO2ID; still also @medConfidential

Jul 15, 2020, 5 tweets

Simon touches on a key point in his first item.

As with #falsifiability in #science, in #practice '#ethics' only work in the context of a #profession or #community *from which one can be #excluded*.

Those wishing to be #trusted as #ethical must stop issuing '#principles' and...

..setting up #EthicsBoards like @Google's or private courts like @Facebook's @OversightBoard (both demonstrating how poorly #BigTech grasps basic concepts like #justice, let alone #ethics, and how both - as #sovereign powers - have utterly misconceived #community) and start to...

...genuinely #professionalise.

Not in the shitty, self-serving, #cartel-like fashion of many companies & industry bodies in tech, advertising - and yes, DP & privacy - but in broader, deeper, more #connected ways that *could* deliver the #trustworthy #institutions of the future.

If #BigTech wants access, e.g. to our health data (it does) then as a sector and as a #discipline, it needs to get as serious as the #MedicalProfession.

Until the spoilt #BoyKings of #SiliconValley - and, frankly, everyone working for them - accept it's THEIR #responsibility...

...to engender, police and sustain the #ethical behaviour of THEIR industry - and for the #public, not just them or their hand-picked few, to decide whether they're doing a good enough job to be #trusted - we ain't going to get anywhere good, any time soon.

/rant off

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling