Phil Booth Profile picture
Mind 'for hire'; critical friend to just causes. Formerly and currently @NO2ID; still also @medConfidential

Aug 13, 2020, 5 tweets

So not so much a #ContactTracing app as a feature-creeping Christmas tree?

One thing about tech that's successful is that it is ultimately successful because it performs the core function it (cl)aims to provide well.

#efficacious#effectiveness

In case you're wondering, "Detection rate" refers to detecting other #phones with the app installed, not the #virus:



The #FalseNegative rate is the amount of times the app incorrectly reports a contact as 'non-infectious' when in fact it is / could be...

...and the #FalsePositive rate is how often the app incorrectly reports a contact as 'infectious' when it's not, i.e. a #FalseAlarm.

Basically, what these #ErrorRates tell us is that #Bluetooth ranging is HARD!

Would you trust a #SmokeAlarm that went off wrongly nearly half...

...of the time? And which had nearly a 1in 3 chance of NOT going off when there really was a fire?

Maybe this time @NHSX will publish detailed #performance statistics - 'cos frankly, without them, it'll be hard to believe the #ContactTracing part of this app ain't a crapshoot...

Meanwhile, it's good to see that (as before) the new #DPIA for the #nhsxCovid19app has been published:
gov.uk/government/pub… and that the repositories are up on github.com/nhsx

Regardless of performance, this is the standard of #transparency ALL #COVID19 projects need.

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling