This thread with it's totally wrong Harry Kane analogy got us thinking.

Brexit, football and the Premier League. We found surprisingly little written, given how many "immigrants" it attracts.

So here's 10 football impacts of Brexit you might not know.

1. Premier League Clubs Hate Brexit.

All 20 of them came out against Brexit in 2016. The reasons were all similar and boiled down not to economics but attitude.

The Premier League is us at our best. Brits working with non Brits to make everyone better.

Brexit takes us back.
2. Transfer Market
There's a concern that the whole transfer process will break for the UK, or become more complicated.
We know that could happen just because of today's complexity of hiring non EU players.

The result is we lose out to clubs In the EU but gain nothing globally.
3. No youth pipeline
The Premier League currently gets away with transferring 16 year old players within the EU.
While this is already controversial for some, others think its a good thing to build clubs' futures.

Either way it seems this will come to an end with brexit.
4. Not just the players
Arguably the transformation of British football into the world's best league is as much down to the coaches and managers.

Whatever complexities we impose on the players of course also happen to the coaches. Maybe we never needed those foreigners?
5. Hurts us more than them
The massive drop in pound is already making it harder for our clubs to compete for players in Europe.

We like to say Brexit hurts them as much as us. In this case we are the world's best. And we are an importer of talent. So yes. It hurts us much more.
6.Takes away control
We dont know which immigration system we will use after Brexit. But we can see what happens if we apply non EU criteria to EU players.

Goal.com list N'Golo Kante and Riyad Mahrez as examples of players who couldn't move here under non EU rules
7. We swing both ways
Most people think the transfer of players to Europe has been a good thing, bringing different experiences back to our game.

Brexit makes our players look complicated and hard to handle, with the inevitable result of more of them losing out to EU clubs
8. The English are Back
Some people think Brexit will help the English game (and presumably Scotland, Wales. NI) by creating more opportunities for local talent.

I guess that all depends whether you think that's a good step for the game or a return to the past.
9. More than football
An obscure ruling by the ECJ is the basis for many changes above.

It sanctioned players moving at the end of contract without transfer fees. This ruling was then extended to other sports. With brexit both go.
So, a good thing for British sport? You decide.
10. Homegrown shows the way
Whatever brexit brings with it the Homegrown rule debate showed it will be disruptive and costly

Clubs forced to sell EU players at the wrong time to comply with Brexit quotas can only be bad short term even if you think it's good for long term talent
Thanks for reading. It's interesting. If Brexit were football, people would pour over this and argue about it for years.

They'd make slow careful decisions.

They would not say fook off Europe no deal. Is our country less important than football? We already know the answer.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Hilary Abernathay #FBPDataEvidenceTruth

Hilary Abernathay #FBPDataEvidenceTruth Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @atatimelikethis

Mar 23, 2023
An excellent summary of the cost of living in Germany vs in the UK.

This has very little to do with the EU. It's about corruption in politics.

One country invests in the long term future of its citizens

The other gives out backhanders, crony contracts and dodgy deals to donors
One thing @skedeschi doesn't cover is a comparison of the two political systems.

Like the UK, Germany is a collection of smaller states working together under a United Federation.

But unlike the UK, each state is fairly represented. In the UK, England gets a 90% block vote.
Lke the UK, Germans value both their local representatives and the ability to choose between various policies offered by political parties.

And both countries have roughly 600 MPs, albeit Germany makes this work with a much larger population

But there the similarities end
Read 50 tweets
Jun 27, 2022
You might conclude there are no data on lab lib overt/covert pacts.

You wonder. Has no one analysed whether to compete?

TLDR you'd be right to ask. And maybe then surprised. The bigger issue is that 75% of #Johnson's seats are due to a huge mess-up on this in 2019
Data follow⬇️
Ok first #TivertonandHoniton #Wakefield

Was it worth lab and lib striking local "non-compete" agreements?

Absolutely.

LSE analysis shows⬇️📈vote share can shift ~5-30% just by not competing. Or this week maybe a darn lot more.

blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpol…
Someone may want to argue lib dems do slightly better.

They do.
But that's because they start far smaller
AND it's easier for marginal voters to settle on centrist.

Also that effect is minor vs the boost labour gets from LD where they need it.

But one more thing...
Read 8 tweets
Jun 27, 2022
Since everyone is talking Criminal Justice today, for obvious reasons, some thoughts below.

Every time Patel plays Gesture Politics, changes sentences, botches laws, adds grounds for appeal, she knows she's making a broken system worse.

Proof of insincerity and/or incompetence?
How does Criminal Justice end up like this?

This man ⬇️ is a victim of another Home Office miscarriage of justice.

His pursuit by Patel is political. And the cost is massive amounts of Court and Barrister time.

Now recall, he is just one of thousands.

I doubt you're a fan of the Government's Rwanda Policy.

But imagine you were. Most likely you wouldn't want it in court, failing to work. You'd want to avoid last minute appeals.

Yet Patel creates exactly those problems. This is how to avoid them ⬇️

Read 6 tweets
May 10, 2022
Whatever faces the UK, it's complex. To prosper we will need these:

Careful, long term thinking
Objectivity in difficult tradeoffs
Honesty, shrewd negotiation
Deep analysis and preparation
Dedicated ruthless planning

Meanwhile it's #Bodger #Johnson's Queens Speech.

Chances? ❌
This dichotomy is just weird:

Take #Brexit.

Imagine, if you can; your passion for extracting the UK from the EU was unpersuaded by any argument to the contrary.

OK.

But did you think doing it was so simple that Slapdash-cover-the-cracks Bodger was the guy to run it?
Out of the blue, we faced a Global #COVID19 Pandemic.

OK,caught a little short with the No 10 leadership. It happens.

But maybe reconsider when you found out he dodged all the scientific briefings at the start to write a book?

You wanted to #Bodger your way through?
Read 8 tweets
Jan 27, 2022
The High Court has found the #HomeOffice guilty of illegal mugging of Asylum Seekers.

It is NOT illegal to flee danger, but the HO wrongly said it was, deciding to steal possessions from victims. That IS illegal.

No one knows where this 2020 policy originated. Some ideas ⬇️ ImageImageImageImage
@pritipatel has constantly and deliberately (unless she's just stupid) lied about the legality of those who flee danger to come to our country.

She also characterised the victims of violence as economic migrants - a number her HO data says is vanishingly small.⬇️ ImageImage
Today is #HolocaustMemorialDay

Lest any of us forget, this was an event, the result of a policy of hate directed toward a marginalised community unable to defend itself by lying positions wishing to rabble rouse and distract a disenchanted set of deceived voters.

Familiar?
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(