Thread by @PratushSayan

गली गली में शोर है उद्धव ठाकरे की सरकार चोर है।

Bihar Counsel Maninder Singh in Supreme Court: Bihar police's FIR is the only FIR in the case. There is a complete lapse of investigation on part of Mumbai police.
#SushantMurderQuestion
#SusanthSinghRajput
#SushantSinghRajpoot

Maninder Singh: The allegation is against political class in Maharashtra which has stopped even the registering of and FIR. A senior officer of Bihar police was put in detention.
#ArrestRheaChakroborty
#JusticeForSushantSinghRajput

Maninder Singh for Bihar police:56 people were examined by Mumbai police. Final report of post mortem came on June 25.Maharashtra didn't register any FIR even though it examined so many people..verdicts state post mortem date is the last date for police to rely on Section174,CrPC

Bihar Counsel Maninder Singh: After final post mortem report either proceedings are closed under 174 CIPC or FIR is registered. How many out of 56 people were examined after June 25 when the final post mortem was in?

#SusanthSinghRajput
#ArrestRheaChakroborty

Maninder Singh cites Section 178 CIPC to say that at the stage of investigation his power of territorial jurisdiction cannot be challenged.

#SusanthSinghRajput #SushantSinghRajputDeathCase
#ArrestRheaChakroborty

Senior Advocate Maninder Singh: It is settled law that cause of action in a criminal case is where crime occurs, but without conducting such an investigation how can such an order be passed?

#SusanthSinghRajput

Senior Advocate Maninder Singh: Similar transfer plea was earlier dismissed too. We have to undertake investigation and then get into territoriality.
#SusanthSinghRajput
#ArrestRheaChakroborty
#ArrestRheaChakrabortyandfamily

Bihar Counsel Maninder Singh: What is an investigation under Section 174 that State of Maharashtra is carrying on much after June 25 since when final post mortem reports were in. What is this facade?

#SupremeCourt #SusanthSinghRajput

Bihar counsel Singh: Nothing is pending before Maharashtra. All investigation by them is now without jurisdiction. FIR says illegal siphoning of money is there. An investigation needs to be carried out in this regard.

#SusanthSinghRajput #ArrestRhea #SupremeCourt

Maninder Singh: FIR in Bihar was registered on basis of legality because some authority has to investigate and not social media. We had to do "doodh ka doodh Paani ka paani." There was no investigation that was being done. Nitish Kumar did not intervene here at all.
#Susanth

Dr Singhvi: I have four points. Absolute lack of jurisdiction by Bihar police. Very weird and remarkable basis of claiming jurisdiction by Bihar needs to be shown. This case shows how federalism is being subverted.
#SusanthSinghRajput #SupremeCourt
#ArrestRheaChakroborty

Dr Singhvi: We also need to see scope of jurisdiction of a single judge where transfer of case to CBI is being sought. You have our sealed envelope regarding status of investigation..

SG Mehta: Next time don't question me on this. I just want to embarrass Dr Singhvi as a friend

Zist of all of the Singhvi's argument: We on behalf of Maharashtra don't want fair investigation, we don't want justice for #SusanthSinghRajput

Singhvu: I'm here in #SupremeCourt on behalf of Congress Party to save #BabyPenguine, so let me divert the whole issue to jurisdiction

Singhvi in most derogatory manner drags Bihar election un the matter if Justice for #SusanthSinghRajput: There is no complaint to Maharashtra police till now. Not a single one ...if somebody wants to stretch it then what can we do?

Shameless Singhvi in #SupremeCourt : We all know that why the State where there is an election Soon (Bihar) is doing like this. After the election you will not hear of this case.

#SusanthSinghRajput #JusticeForSushantSinghRajput

Singhvi:The word federalism appears nowhere in the Constitution.But still,it's held to be a part of the basic structure doctrine in the SR Bommai case

In India Union law is supreme but Singhvi for Maha govt want to invoke the word 'federalism' to save #BabyPenguinAdityathackeray

Singhvi: Section 177 CRPC arises from the time of the offence. Its basic premise is that all crime is local zero FIR point •.. is the most hallowed principle and the advisory issued was in light of Lalita Kumari judgment.

#BabyPenguinAdityathackeray #SushantDeathMystery

Sr. Adv Vikas Singh: Lawyers saying that CrPC is murdered but no one has read CrPC. In the Asaram Bapu case,the girl was travelling from Rajasthan to UP. Then FIR was registered in Delhi which states that nothing happened in Delhi & thus being sent to UP.. that's zero FIR
#SC

Senior Advocate Vikas Singh: If there is a criminal breach of trust then as a father the entire proceed needs to be sent to me. Section 406 also includes Courts subordinate to a High Court.

#SusanthSinghRajput #SupremeCourt #SushantCoverup #RepublicForSushant

Vikas Singh: Father & sister of #SushantSinghRajput were alienated. Father repeatedly wanted to talk to Sushant but #Rhea did not reply. She had already distanced the sister. Look at the mark on his neck its a belt mark not a rope! If he was murdered it needs to be investigated.

Senior Adv Vikas Singh: The Lalita Kumari ruling says preliminary enquiry needs to be concluded within 7 days. Inquest proceedings cannot go beyond the receipt of final postmortem report.

#SushantSinghRajpoot #SusanthSinghRajput #SupremeCourt #RepublicForSushant #ArrestRheaNow

Senior Adv Vikas Singh (for Sushant's father): I am from Patna and without my son, l have no one to light my funeral pyre. This itself shows that Patna has jurisdiction..

#SusanthSinghRajput #SusanthSinghRajpoot #SupremeCourt
#JusticeForSushantSinghRajput #RepublicForSushant

Senior Adv Vikas Singh (for Susanth's father): No one has seen my son hanging. When my daughter reached, Sushant was lying on the bed. This needs investigation. As soon as mourning is over, he registered the FIR in Patna.

#JusticeForSushantSinghRajput #SusanthSinghRajput

Senior Adv Vikas Singh: #VinayTiwari was forcibly quarantined on August 2 and an order was passed on August 3 stating that there will be no exception for home quarantine for someone coming from outside the state.This was the nature of cover-up
#SushantSinghRajpoot #RheaArrestNext

Senior Advocate Vikas Singh: Please ensure that when CBI goes to Maharashtra this home quarantine does not apply to them again.

#SushantSinghRajpoot #SusanthSinghRajput #ArrestRheaChakroborty #JusticeForSushantSinghRajput #RepublicForSushant

SG Mehta(for CBI):CBI has already taken a decision that it would accede to the request of BiharGovernment.The Mumbai Police says it began investigation under Section 175CrPC but that can only be under Sections 154 & 156 of the CRPC.Investigation has to be truth eliciting oriented

SG Mehta:The exercise that Mumbai police is undergoing is without an FIR. No report of the inquest has been filed before the district or sub divisional magistrate. A basic report on apparent causes of death showing bruises, marks, wounds, or fractures should be before Magistrate.

SG Tushar Mehta: Now what is an investigation? We need to see who is the petitioner. Is she an accused or not involved at all. Here there is no case pending in Mumbai ... when police files a report or chargesheet under section 173 a Magistrate orders arrest of those involved.

SG Mehta: You get information under Section 174 CRPC. You register FIR under Section 154 CRPC. Then statements recorded are under Section 160 or 161 CIPC. (Reads a Vivian Bose, J., verdict to explain what investigation is)
#SusanthSinghRajput #RepublicForSushant #SupremeCourt

SG Mehta: Investigation only as per CrPC is going on in Bihar as there is no such Investigation in Mumbai. Even Enforcement Directorate is investigating the case. What Dr Singhvi has submitted in sealed envelope is not a part of case diary
#SushantSinghRajput #RepublicForSushant

Senior Adv Divan: We are in an application under Section 406 CIPC. After hearing all, it emerges that justice is on individual cases. Everything in this case happened in Mumbai. If everything is in Mumbai, then FIR needs to be transferred. Justice is a very subtle virtue
#Susanth

Senior Adv Divan: It is a very charged situation. I hope there will be protection for the petitioner in the case which has been extremely politicized. I will place a short note with judgments by tomorrow.

#SusanthSinghRajput #SupremeCourt #JusticeforSSR #RepublicForSushant

Divan: when we cite news report after news report and where FIR is registered at the behest of Bihar CM then court needs to look at the ends of justice. We should not give a license and certificate to a situation where FIR can be registered in remote area away from Mumbai. #SC

#Breaking:Senior Adv Maninder Singh directly blame #BabyPenguinAdityathackeray in SC Regarding the BiharCM playing a role, there is also mention of Maharashtra CM's son &his involvement in the case There is a huge political clout pressuring police not to register an FIR
@ippatel

SG Mehta: Mumbai police and Bihar police have made a strong case for central agency probe.

Dr Singhvi: The eagerness of the CBI tells its own story.

#SusanthSinghRajput
#SusanthSinghRajpoot #JusticeforSushantSingRajput #JusticeforSSR #RepublicForSushant #SupremeCourt

Senior Adv Maninder Singh: Bihar police has the jurisdiction in the case.

Senior Adv Vikas Singh: Shiv Sena is infamous for its brutality on Biharis

#SusanthSinghRajput
#SusanthSinghRajpoot #JusticeforSushantSingRajput #JusticeforSSR #RepublicForSushant #SupremeCourt

Single judge bench reserves order on the transfer petition. Parties to file a two page written submission (note) each by tomorrow

#SupremeCourt #SusanthSinghRajput #SusanthSinghRajpoot #JusticeforSSR #JusticeforSushantSingRajput #RepublicForSushant #ArrestRheaChakraborty

@threadreaderapp please unroll

*Error*- 'Zist' should be read as 'Gist'.