When the #Artsakh treaty between #Azerbaijan, #Armenia and #Russia was released, I stumbled over the second point, which mentioned that AM will hand over two small exclaves to AZ.

[pictures is Verin Voskepar (am) / Yuxari Askipara (az)] Image
As I never heard about the fate of Verin Voskepar and Barkhudarly again, I did open the ceasefire agreement and silently, this tiny detail disappeared. @meduza_en reported it about, much earlier, too:
meduza.io/en/feature/202…
In a way, this makes sense, as providing access to exclaves seems extremely difficult between two countries that are still in a cold war and that have no diplomatic relations to each other, let alone border crossings.
On the other hand, Bakhurdarly, Verin Voskipar, Kari (all de jure AZ and de facto AM) and Artsvashen (de jure AM and de facto AZ) are the only territories in which undisputedly one country is occupying territory of the other and violating it's territorial integrity.
(note: undisputed is to be emphasized here. AZ claims that AM occupies #Artsakh, too - but AM makes no formal claim to that territory)
So it always puzzled me how #Azerbaijan, who use territorial integrity as a national doctrine, never offered (to my knowledge) to restore Armenias territorial integrity by returning Artsvashen - or doing a formal land swap with other exclaves.
Of course, this is a minor problem compared to #Artsakh, by size and population alone.
But it is a problem. The IDPs from Artvashen, e.g., protested in 2019: arminfo.info/full_news.php?…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sascha Düerkop

Sascha Düerkop Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SaschaDueerkop

24 Nov
- "Jogi's Jungs" -
#Bierhoff, #Löw, #Keller - alle waren sich nach dem 0:6 bei #ESPGER einig, dass die #Nationalmannschaft "jung" ist und das daher mal passieren kann.

Tatsächlich ist es ein Kader, der älter als alle Turnierkader von Löw, mit Ausnahme von 2008 und 2018, ist.
Tatsächlich könnte man eher behaupten, dass er Kader eher zu alt ist. Denn Titel (2014, 2017) hat Löw nur mit jüngeren Kadern gewonnen.
Die ("alten") Kader von 2008 und 2018 waren, in meiner Wahrnehmung, die schwächsten.
Das zweite Argument was die gesamte #DFB-Führung ständig wiederholt ist, dass der Kader so unerfahren ist.
Das stimmt tatsächlich. Er hat etwa so wenig Länderspiele wie der WM-Kader von 2010. Nur der CONFED-Cup-Kader 2017 hatte in Summe weniger Länderspiele.
Read 8 tweets
23 Nov
Danke, @JennyGnther. Einfach danke.

Du sagst, die Folge ist für mich, aber eigentlich ist die natürlich für die vielen #Armenier, auch in Deutschland, die es verdient haben, dass wir nicht wegschauen, auch wenn unsere Regierung es tut.

Danke, dass du dem Thema Raum gibst! 🙏
Ich habe das Gespräch mit @textautomat nun komplett gehört und ich habe, wie öfter in den letzten Wochen, Tränen in den Augen.

"Wenn der Russe nicht kommt, kommt der Türke" fasst es für mich treffend zusammen, weil es eigentlich heißt "wenn der Russe nicht kommt, kommt der Tod"
Es geht nicht um Türken oder um Aserbaidschaner. Es geht um das, was am Ende für die Armenier folgt. Die Vernichtung.

Es ist eine Schande, dass Europa und Deutschland Staaten in die Arme Russlands treiben, während sie zu Recht davor warnen, wie gefährlich russischer Einfluss ist
Read 5 tweets
20 Nov
- THREAD -
Kanach Zham, the oldest and smaller church of #Shushi, #Artsakh. It's history, propaganda and the recent destruction by #Azerbaijan.

It was built in 1818 to replace a former wooden church (Kharabaghtsots) that stood at the same place.
Photo: Postcard from 19th century Image
It survived the 1920 destruction of the #Armenia|n part of #Shushi almost untouched - which is the reason that it today is the oldest church in the city. Here is a picture taken after the 1920 razing of the Armenian parts of town. Image
As it was typical for the time and region, it was built with a dome and a tower. Here is a close-up picture of the church before it's last restauration.

The dome used to be painted green, hence the name "Kanach Zham", which means "Green church" Image
Read 25 tweets
10 Nov
THREAD

What is missing in the #Artsakh ceasefire agreement is any tiny bit of humanity towards or hope for #Armenia|ns. All humanitarian parts of the UN resolutions and the Madrid Principles have been left out on purposed (as #Aliyev smilingly announced).
(sorry being negative!)
UN res. 822 (2) urges both parties to immediately resume negotiations fopr the resolution of the conflict within the #OSCE Minsk Group.

The now signed deal makes no mention of this. #Artsakh's future won't be determined by the OSCE anymore, but AZ, RU, AM and TR. Bad news!
UN res. 822 (3) called for unimpedent access of international humanitarian relief and adherence with humanitarian law.

This was left out, too. #Azerbaijan and #Russia will now decide if humanitarian relief is allowed or hum law will be adhered to. Bad news, too.
Read 10 tweets
10 Nov
There was clearly no alternative for #Artsakh and #Armenia to signing the deal. As #Shushi fell, constant shelling of #Stepanakert would have followed and a complete loss would have followed. It was the only chance to safe some lives, at least.

Yet, that treaty is horrible:
Most of the lost territory was sparsely populated (Agdam, Kalbajar and Lachin Rayons of #Azerbaijan). They were always kept as buffers, mostly. Losing them surely weakens #Aartsakh, but at the same time was always calculated for.
What hurts the most will be the loss of #Dadivank, #Tigranakert and #Shushi. Basically, all historical and culturally important places of #Artsakh are now in the parts taken by #Azerbaijan.
There is a serious fear for cultural genocide: theguardian.com/artanddesign/2…
Read 12 tweets
8 Nov
I've reached out to all my friends in #Artsakh over the last few hours. They confirm heavy fighting throughout the night in and around #Shushi, as well as on the outskirts of #Stepanakert.
The battle for Shushi either way will be a decisive one...
Journalists and thousands of civilians have been evacuated from #Stepanakert overnight and in the morning. Of my 20+ friends in #Artsakh, only one remains on the ground. #Shusha is almost deserted by now, obviously.
The reason is simple: #Shushi isn't 'just' a historical and cultural centre of large symbolic value. It's also the decisive location for the war. "Whoever controls Shushi controls #Artsakh" is a well-known saying locally.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!