Tom Swann Profile picture
12 Apr, 29 tweets, 14 min read
Settling in to livetweet #4Corners right now, thread below
.@m_brisso asks "Why is the government so insistent on ignoring the dissenters" - that is, almost everyone - "and pushing ahead" with gas subsidies ?
Nev Power, hand picked by the PM, "to solve problems".

A few minutes in, and we are already getting red lines connecting profile pictures in an influence diagram.
Andrew Liveris, specially picked to advise on recovery, said he "tingled with pride" about being picked by Trump in a senior advisory role. #auspol #4Corners
Why was the NCCC obsessed with gas? @barobertson111 says if you chose builders to advise on recovery, they will talk about a house based recovery
Was gas fired recovery pre determined in choice of advisors? Liveris says "I don't know". Angus Taylor refuses to say no #auspol #4corners
.@zoewhitton warns that fossil fuel subsidies risk increasing retaliatory tariffs across the economy #auspol #4Corners
#4Corners overstates the role of gas in manufacturing. Most gas uses little or no gas. See report with @MarkOgge here: australiainstitute.org.au/post/gas-for-e…

#auspol #4corners
End of cheap gas came when gas companies decided to ruthlessly exploit the export market. #4corners #auspol
Tony Wood, former gas executive and energy lead at Grattan, says gas prices will not come down. #auspol #4corners
Angus Taylor refuses to give a promise on gas prices. Kind of like vaccines? #auspol #4Corner
Santos CEO now says $7-8 . GJ is a sustainable gas price on the east coast. Plus pipeline costs, that is an expensive form of energy #auspol #4corners
Even the GAS LOBBY says that the gas recovery for manufacturing is bollocks. Even the flacks for selling the gas. #4corners #auspol
Most manufacturers use little or no gas. More gas is burnt by the gas industry just to export the gas, to cool it to put it on boats, than is burnt in the ENTIRE manufacturing industry.

#auspol #4Corners
Andrew Liveris "wouldn't even bother reading what Grattan puts out". #4Corners #auspol
Santos doesn't just sponsor football. Sometimes, it even sponsors the police. theguardian.com/australia-news…
Santos previously told analysts that half the point of exporting gas was to push domestic prices up. #auspol #4Corners
Why are they pushing ahead with subsidising gas? "Donations... yeah it's pretty simple." @barobertson111

#auspol #4Corners
(BTW, the political donations fossil fuel companies make in Australia are pathetically small, given the control they have over policy #auspol #4Corners)
LOL Angus Taylor says he gives access to all stakeholders. I personally have been forced to wait half a year just to have a response to an FOI request to his office. #auspol #4Corners
Now we move to the states, which are now acting almost as if the recalcitrant federal government is irrelevant #4Corners #auspol
.@Matt_KeanMP making economically rational statements that seem radical because of the parlous state of national debate.

Why should taxpayers be paying for infrastructure we might not need?

Good question!
Kerry Schott, head of the government's energy security board, says she does not know why the government keeps pushing ahead with the need for a 1000 MW gas power plant. Refuses to comment on alleged pressure to resign #auspol #4Corners
Head of the Energy Security Board, and head of AEMO, both allegedly pressured by Taylor and his people, to change their expert advice on this.

Taylor refuses to explain why he did this.

#auspol #4Corners
Taylor actually doesn't have any choice but leave to vote, but he should have come back to finish the interview. #4Corners #auspol
"Technology is moving way faster than politics" - @m_brisso

From the audience at home, a big "yay!"

#4Corners #auspol
Also said at the home audience "god we are lucky we have states" "fuck yeah - climate, covid, "
Decisions we make now will determine how we fare in the massive, historically rapid transition under way. #auspol #4Corners
Worth distinguishing here, export vs domestic. All the state ambition is on the latter, and zero on the former. Despite the fact that fossil export states cannot meet their own domestic targets while increasing or maintaining high emission production of fossils for export

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tom Swann

Tom Swann Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Tom_Swann

14 Oct 20
APPEA webinar with panel representing "the whole value chain" - starting with the Minister. Image
Minister repeating standard tropes - gas firming renewables, domestic consumption, 'sensible market outcomes'.
Minister says "we have a very clear plan on the electricity side, we don't have that on the gas side".

The AEMO ISP says we need less gas, not more.
Read 17 tweets
22 Sep 20
So pleased to at the #NPC listening to Minister Angus Taylor.

And great to share a table with good friends at APPEA.
Minister Taylor talking up Australian emissions which, to reiterate, are not coming down because we have no climate policy. Meanwhile Australia is the world's third largest fossil fuel exporter.
Read 29 tweets
20 Sep 20
random stack of cds for the car from the broken hill salvos, including best of the jacksons and whoa

period between "i want you back" and MJ as king of pop includes a huge range of epic tunes.

7m from ballad to funk freakout. 1974!
i didn't realise this was with the jacksons. 1978! MJ composed. year before Off The Wall - which i also didn't realise was his /fifth/ solo album
the jacksons also got right into weird quasi spiritual stuff. this song, by the way, is a certified banger, and this film clip is amazing, although the narrative FX are too loud
Read 4 tweets
20 Sep 20
Andrew Liveris, of "subsidise gas for plastics and chemicals" infamy, is a director of the Saudi Arabian oil company. New FOI docs show his work for NCC was secretly backed by a lobbying firm that was working for the Saudi govt. theguardian.com/australia-news…
Liveris is also on the board of Worley Parsons, Australia's largest oil and gas services company. The head of the lobbying firm, Dragoman, was also registered as a lobbyist for Worley.
The head of Dragoman, Tom Harley, used to chair the Menzies Institute, the main Liberal Party think tank.

Liveris also has a position at Dragoman.
Read 6 tweets
10 Sep 20
Weapons of Gas Destruction - a major new report from me @TheAusInstitute out today.

Australia has a huge amount of gas in the pipeline and in the ground. If it gets burnt, we're all in big trouble.

A thread on some findings. Report here: tai.org.au/content/weapon… Image
Australia is the world's largest LNG exporter and one of the largest fossil gas producers in the world.

Australia caused most of the LNG growth over the last decade and more than any other country over the last 20 years. Image
Australia has rapidly increased its share of world gas production, even faster than it has increased its proven reserves. We've had our foot right down on the gas. Image
Read 22 tweets
8 Sep 20
Energy Department admits the 'Tech Roadmap' is full of literal thought bubbles based on 'expert judgement' and not based on analysis.

Favourable treatment of gas vs renewables ensured by assumptions that ignore best modelling.
reneweconomy.com.au/federal-govern…
'expert judgement' with no analysis is a fancy way of saying they made it up.

No wonder they ignored my requests for the underlying assumptions and then fought against my FOI
The Tech Roadmap is essentially a series of these graphs. No numbers, no explanation of how they came up with it. That's a terrible basis for climate policy. Image
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!