BlackRock Brazil head pontificating about 'gold' European ESG standard is rich when you know a little bit about EU's Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulations
for starters, BlackRock lobbied heavily to weaken European sustainable finance agendas, from its opposition to double materiality (not just climate risks, but climate impact of carbon finance) to its 'consultancy' for the European Commission
we ended up with SFDR - Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation - that basically allows private finance to use whatever ESG metrics they want for disclosure of climate risks for their portfolios
BUT capturing the Commission is not that easy, and double materiality stayed - so if you want to market sustainable assets in Europe, you need to PAI:
to outline the Principle Adverse Impacts of that assets on sustainability
as @adam_tooze once said, devil is in the technocratic detail - we need to understand better PAIs to see how these deal w greenwashing.
but their very existence confirms Commission doesnt buy 'European ESG Gold standard' narrative that BlackRock is now peddling in Global South
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
15 months ago, in conversation with @MESandbu I warned that EU's Green Deal, with its Green Third Way approach to nudging the market in the right direction, threatened to end up into subsidised greewashing
miss the days of rigorous neoliberalism, when the guys didnt play language games and celebrated the market instead of disguising it in some faux Keynesian/interventionist clothing
take the derisking state:
one litmus test for this faux Keynesian revival of the state is to ask financial capitalists now speaking the language of just transitions if they would co-finance a local Ugandan green bus company.
a two state solution from the Biden Administration:
- green investment state for the US
- derisking state for the Global South - derisking development assets for financial capital, not for local populations
I blame the vacuousness of the neoliberal imagination - once the script of 'structural reform' doesn't serve any more, what do you do? Infrastructure. All roads lead to nowhere in financial capitalism.
remember, Mark Carney's 'tragedy of the horizons' speech identified two main risks of climate crisis:
- physical risks (climate events)
- transition risks - from green policies to accelerate transition to low-carbon
Ben is of course right - #WallStreetConsensus is a development paradigm invented for the Global South, but could easily travel up North to satisfy the portfolio glut's hunger for infrastructure assets.
'give us infrastructure assets!' clamour institutional investors, who wont tell you that partnerships with private finance means the de facto privatization of infrastructure - you have to pay for it to access it, otherwise where are those handsome cash flows gonna come from?
and a visual guide to how the Biden Infrastructure Plan according to BlackRock would look like, with a nod to @KatharinaPistor