Thread by @barandbench

Delhi Court will today hear bail application by Navneet Kalra in oxygen concentrator black marketing case.

Hearing before Metropolitan Magistrate Vasundhara Azad.

Kalra is presently in judicial custody.

@DelhiPolice

#NavneetKalra #OxygenConcentrator #COVID19

Hearing begins.

I'll hear the submissions: Court

#NavneetKalra

Court asks IO to share the case diary.

We can come to your office .. : APP Atul Srivastava

Court asks IO to share case diary on her personal ID.

I don't see any issue if it is emailed to personal ID : Court

#NavneetKalra

If it is seen, the other party will get the opportunity to see it : Srivastava

It can be shown. It is a document they can't ask for. They will have the right .. you can see it, not refer to it : Srivastava

Srivastava also seeks Police custody of Navneet Kalra.

#NavneetKalra

Srivastava says he would satisfy the Court that there are fresh grounds for police custody.

#NavneetKalra

Dharmendra Mishra says he is the complainant.

You have no locus: Srivastava

#NavneetKalra

Police is not sharing (HC order).. I request to read sec 307, 299 explanation. They are deliberately not bringing sec 302..: Mishra

I oppose this counsel: Srivastava

#NavneetKalra

You show me have you purchased! No: Srivastava

It is a crime... : Dharmendra Mishra

Court fixes matter for 11:30 am.

#NavneetKalra

11:30 for? : Srivastava

For appearance of counsel : Court

#NavneetKalra

Court asks Srivastava for PC remand application.

#NavneetKalra

Matter to be taken up next at 11:30 am.

#NavneetKalra

Court assembles. Hearing resumes.

#navneetkalraaressted

Adv. Vineet Malhotra says copy of remand application not supplied to him.

APP Shrivastava request that time be given till 2 pm.

Asks court to post case in afternoon.

#navneetkalraaressted

Court says it will sit 11.45 and hear out matter.

Shrivastava says IO is at Chanakyapuri while he is in Ghaziabad and his physical presence is needed.

Court asks why physical presence needed.

APP Shrivastava says every time the matter is taken up at 2 pm.

He says needs to go to IO's place and sit with him to assist the court. Give me travel time to reach Chanakyapuri at IO's place.

#navneetkalraaressted

I don't understand why you want to go there when everything is online. You can get files online, consult online.

Shrivastava insists; court eventually says it will keep matter at 1 pm.

Shrivastava agrees.

#navneetkalraaressted

Complainant Dharmendra Mishra intervenes, says APP helping accused. Objects to personal remarks made by APP.

Court asks Mishra not to interfere.

Matter to be taken up at 1 pm.

#navneetkalraaressted

Hearing resumes.

#navneetkalra

Addl. Public Prosecutor Atul Shrivastav commences arguments.

Shrivastav narrating the facts.

#navneetkalra

APP says Delhi High Court did not grant interim relief.

#navneetkalra

APP says accused has to be confronted with details from mobile phone, bank account details and money trail.

#navneetkalra

Right from the very beginning we have been asking for PC remand to confront the accused with mobile details: APP

Some of the WhatsApp screenshots are available with us asking for refunds because the concentrators supplied were not working: APP

#navneetkalraaressted

Navneet Kalra speaks from jail. Asks for permission to speak. Court asks him to wait

#navneetkalraaressted

Classic got it from Matrix who gave it to Kalra. We have to confront Classic person. He was earlier Covid positive but is now negative: APP

#navneetkalraaressted

APP saying after use of concentrator, change of oxygen is only 11 percent.

AIIMS doctors also said the Oxygen concentrators supplied by him are useless, says APP.

#navneetkalraaressted

Advocate Vineet Malhotra for Kalra says Kalra has cooperated and will cooperate in future.

#navneetkalraaressted

When State prosecutes someone, it is not supposed to be adverserial: Malhotra

#navneetkalraaressted

Malhotra says concentrators belong to Matrix.y premises were used to keep the concentrators.

I had also got some 700 of them which I had given to friends etc: Malhotra

The State of expected to be fair. Bank account details I had given to police even before my arrest: Malhotra

#navneetkalra

Malhotra points out how bills etc have not been segregated. Points out order passed by duty magistrate in this regard

#navneetkalraaressted

They say these concentrators don't work. When they recovered it, 450 of them, they gave to Covid centres: Malhotra

Same concentrators 250 of them were procured by Salman Khan. Very same: Malhotra

#navneetkalraaressted

He has been made a scapegoat unnecessarily: Malhotra

#navneetkalra

Same machines have been sold by Matrix to SpiceJet airline: Malhotra

#navneetkalra

The machines delivered what it represented as regards oxygen capacity: Malhotra

#navneetkalra #OxygenConcentrator

Court asks Kalra if he has something to say.

Kalra says he is an optician.

Police has also got concentrators from me. I am not manufacturer or importer of these machines. I have so many messages saying machines bought from me saved lives: Kalra chokes up

I also replaced machines in three or four cases when it was pointed out that they were defective: Kalra

#navneetkalra #OxygenConcentrator

Persons who have imported are holy angels. Person who bought one percent is implicated: Malhotra.

#navneetkalra

APP interrupts, says others wil also be prosecuted. One was Covid positive: APP

Kalra interrupts, says why is APP Shrivastav not speaking about positive messages on Kalra's phone and is instead focusing only on old messages: Kalra

Plea for police remand dismissed by court.

In my considered opinion, no police remand is warranted: Judge

Plea for police remand of Navneet Kalra dismissed by Delhi court.

#navneetkalraaressted #navneetkalra #OxygenConcentrator

Navneet Kalra's bail application to be heard at 2 pm on May 25, Tuesday.

#navneetkalraaressted #OxygenConcentrator

Delhi court dismisses plea for police remand of Navneet Kalra

#navneetkalra #OxygenConcentrator

barandbench.com/news/litigatio…

Police have also got Oxygen Concentrators from me:" Navneet Kalra chokes up in court

#NavneetKalra #OxygenConcentrator

barandbench.com/news/litigatio…