Context Matters Most, a short story:

Meet Bob, a Product Manager at Acme Inc.

After 2½ years of being a PM on his current team, he is excited to take on a new challenge as PM in a different org at Acme.

Here’s what his manager had to say about Bob's work thus far as a PM:
Fast-forward 6 months. Things are not going so well for Bob on his new team.

Here’s what his new manager has to say about Bob's work over these 6 months:
Same person, same behaviors, different contexts, very different outcomes.
What could Bob have done to avoid this situation on the new team?
Frankly, Bob could not have avoided this situation on his own. As a first-time PM on the Notifications team, he was very successful because he (unwittingly) did what strong PMs are supposed to do: manage based on the context of the team & the product.
Bob’s “be at the center-of-everything” style was *exactly* what the Notifications team needed. But no one bothered to coach Bob that this is not the only operating style of successful PMs. Not knowing any better, Bob replicated & doubled down on his default style on the Ads team.
Now, the Ads team was already very empowered & independent. The same micromanagement that the Notifications team found very useful, the Ads engineers & designers found stifling. Naturally then, Bob was left confused about what really went wrong. Was it him or was it his new team?
Here's the reality:
You can get good at product management by becoming an expert in one style. But if you want to be great at it and create much greater career optionality for yourself, you need to be a lot more adaptive.
Don’t be dogmatic about the “one right way”.

There may actually be a “one right way” of doing things on a given team, but show me 10 different teams & companies, and I will show you 11 different “right ways”.
Back to Bob though, being a newish PM with experience on only one team, he really stood no chance here without his original manager on the Notifications team and his new manager on the Ads team coaching him on the difference in contexts and the need for him to be more adaptive.
Sadly, many PM leaders are themselves unaware that context should inform a PM’s approach more than generic best practices. Often, PM leaders are themselves trying to repeat the formulas that previously worked for *them* at Google / Facebook / other megacorp, with limited success.
Which brings me to the 2 most important takeaways of this thread:

1) Context matters most

2) It is a product leader’s vital responsibility to be a skilled reader of current context & an effective coach on how to best operate within that context
A good product leader can tell when it makes sense to ditch defaults vs. when it makes sense to double-down on them.
So look for this skill if you are looking to hire a product leader (as a founder/CEO) or looking to work with one (as a PM).
As for what happened to Bob, I like to imagine that after a rocky first 6 months, he got a new manager who was highly skilled in contextual coaching, and so Bob was able to adapt his style to focus on the high leverage stuff himself & empower his team members much more.

THE END.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Shreyas Doshi

Shreyas Doshi Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @shreyas

1 Jun
🗓️Recap of May 2021 content:

Black Turtleneck Fallacy
Valuing time
Product clarity exercise
Instinct matters in product
Success + Tranquility
Recognizing happiness
Simple stuff
Transactional managers
% confidence
Writer's block for PMs
A tragedy of many orgs
and more..

Thread👇🏾
When allocating their time, most people just seek a positive ROI. To achieve much greater outcomes in lesser time, you should instead seek to minimize Opportunity Cost. Probably the most valuable thing I will ever say, especially for senior product folks.
Read 26 tweets
30 May
A thread of product management frameworks:

(this might be useful if you are a product manager, product leader, or founder)
Before we jump in:

Frameworks will not fix all your problems.

Used right, they should help you
1) better understand your context
2) create structure for problems
3) communicate ideas & solutions

I often use these frameworks in my product work, sometimes without realizing it.
1/
3X framework (Kent Beck)

A product can be in one of 3 stages
1. Explore
2. Expand
3. Extract

For product leaders this is the most vital framework to understand because almost every important decision should account for the stage your product is in.

medium.com/@kentbeck_7670…
Read 46 tweets
16 May
An approach to run working sessions

-Pre-read

-Set clear goals & agenda upfront

-Alternate betwn Quiet Time & Discussion Time twice/thrice in 1 hr

-People work on their own in Quiet Time (talking forbidden)

-Share the work in Discussion Time

-Repeat

If you use this for the right things, you'll accomplish a lot more than constant talking for 1 hr

Another thing:
Much of the business world's processes are highly optimized for extroverts. This approach creates a more balanced structure for introverts & extroverts to contribute.
Below is a concrete example of this working session approach, for pre-mortems. The @coda_hq template linked in this tweet provides the end-to-end structure for you to run such a working session.
Read 4 tweets
10 May
Why do many modern teams & companies fail to achieve the clarity, progress, and results they so badly seek?

5 cognitive biases of modern organizations, a thread:
1/ Band-aids for Bullet Holes

Organizations tend to prefer sticking band-aids on serious bullet holes.

They do this due to 3 reasons:

- irrational optimism that the band-aid will work

- inability to diagnose the actual problem

- avoidance of the pain from fixing said problem
e.g.

Most Execution problems are really
1) Strategy problems, or
2) Interpersonal problems, or
3) Culture problems

Good leaders execute well because they understand this. They fix the root problem.

Bad leaders & their teams struggle because they are always applying band-aids.
Read 21 tweets
1 May
🗓️Recap of April 2021 content

Includes:
- A template for pre-mortems
- How product creativity dies
- False Positive Products
- Being more strategic
- B2B strategy primer
- Personal growth inhibitors
- Work stress
- Curated lists
- Internal roles
- Using logic
& much more....

👇🏾
A template that you can copy to run an effective (and fun) pre-mortem with your team for your upcoming launch (created via a collab with @coda_hq)
The hardest part of product creativity is not the ideation. It is the negotiation necessary to get the folks who are fixated on logic & math to appreciate the value of product creativity.
Read 23 tweets
23 Apr
Product leader anti-patterns (and resulting problems)👇🏾
First, a quick recap:

3 types of product leaders
The Operator
The Craftsperson
The Visionary

Think of them as hats rather than types, if you wish.

Product leaders can (and do) wear multiple hats.

But most usually have a primary or preferred hat.

Ref:
Note: There is no "one right" type or hat. Context matters most here.

It's useful to know these anti-patterns so we can spot them in ourselves, in the leaders we might hire or manage, in the leaders we might work for.

Can't fix what we don't see.

With that, the anti-patterns👇🏾
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(