NEW DATA available now on the CANADIAN EXCESS MORTALITY TRACKER

Courtesy of new data drop from @StatCan_eng July 12

French translation of the @RSCTheAcademies report comes out tomorrow.

Link to Tracker in French in tweet below.

covid19resources.ca/public/excess-…
@WilsonKM2 you'll be glad to see some numbers for Atlantic/Northern Can have come down since last update--for regions with low numbers these numbers may tilt back and forth a bit. Numbers are increasing everywhere else. Still less than 95% of reporting completed after Dec 5.
Slowest reporting in this group is in NS, as well as territories (I provide data for reporting completion with today's update), so global estimate for Atlantic and Northern Canada will be more accurate than individual estimates for a while still.

SK, MB, BC lead pack in delays.
In some regions I'm also finding more COVID-19 deaths reported to the CVSSD than numbers reported by the provinces, so I expect our reported C19 numbers will keep going up as specific cause of death reporting catches up. Not a huge difference (yet).
However, given that multiple provinces, especially BC, SK and MB, have not completed >=95% of cause of death reporting after Feb 1, 2020 (yes, 2020), it could be a long wait to find out if this accounts for large difference in excess mortality and reported COVID-19 deaths.
New info added in today's update:

1) Dates of 90%, 95% and 99% completion of specific cause of death reporting (as you can see from looking at QC data, we need this to be 99% complete--at very least 95%) to form reliable conclusions.
2) Numbers of outstanding deaths in each region for which specific cause of death reporting is incomplete (total 41,815 for Can since Feb 1, 2020) (Table 1)

3) Table 2: toxic drug-death adjusted excess mortality up to Dec 5, 2020 (latest date when interpretation is reliable)
4) Fig. 1: Age-stratified excess mortality and reported COVID-19 deaths by region, to May 8, 2021 (periods of uncertainty/incomplete data for each region indicated)

5) Fig. 2: Regional comparisons (total, per 100K pop, age-adjusted per 100K pop)
Thanks to @COVID_19_Canada for hosting, @BensunCFong for posting and @StatCan_eng for sharing data publicly so all Canadians can access them.
P.S. I'll add some key take home bullets to the Tracker pages in the next week or so, once I catch up from being away.

P.P.S. Still haven't done a thread summarizing the report. It might not be possible till Sunday or later, once I get my nose above water.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tara Moriarty

Tara Moriarty Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MoriartyLab

16 Jul
Note that Canadian data are not included in this major publication.

This is because Canada's death reporting is so slow that it wasn't possible to meaningfully analyze it until recently.

We are an outlier amongst the countries shown below.

That should concern Canadians deeply
Here is a copy of the English version of the @RSCTheAcademies report on excess all-cause mortality in Canada during the #COVID19 epidemic (francais au dessous).

rsc-src.ca/en/covid-19-po…
Read 14 tweets
10 Apr
Apr 9

1 of every 45 #Canadians with #COVID19 has died since Feb 2020

1 in 73 BC
1 in 79 AB
1 in 79 SK
1 in 37 MB
1 in 51 ON
1 in 30 QC

1 of every 5 Cdns w/ C19 in long-term care & retirement homes has died

LAST 28 DAYS: 812 deaths, 1,183 LTC/RH cases, 303 LTC/RH deaths
Apr 9

-#COVID19 is in top 4 largest mortality events in #Canadian history

-Last 28 days: 812 Canadians died of C19

-If every week is like this week, 868 Canadians may die in next 28 days
Apr 9

#COVID19 #Canada

CASE FATALITY RATES

Wave 1 (to Aug 17)
Wave 2 (to Feb 18)
Wave 3 (Feb 19 to date)
Read 21 tweets
6 Apr
Update on excess death story:

So far, journalists @ericandrewgee of @globeandmail @arthurwhiteLP of @leaderpost have on record confirmation that ON and SK do NOT include probable #COVID19 deaths in reported C19 deaths.

This is counter to guidance of @GovCanHealth and @WHO.
By contrast, QC DOES report probable
C19 deaths in their reported numbers.

This goes at least some of the way toward explaining why excess deaths in ON and SK are greater than reported C19 deaths from March-Nov 14, 2020, and why this is not true in QC.
Today's @ericandrewgee story is below. @arthurwhiteLP story is going to press now.

Looking foward to hearing how BC, AB, MB report C19 deaths.

Looking forward even more to learning why ON, SK, possibly others don't follow @GovCanHealth, @WHO guidance.

Read 36 tweets
3 Apr
Apr 2

1 of every 43 #Canadians with #COVID19 has died since Feb 2020

1 in 69 BC
1 in 75 AB
1 in 78 SK
1 in 36 MB
1 in 49 ON
1 in 29 QC

1 of every 5 Cdns w/ C19 in long-term care & retirement homes has died

LAST 28 DAYS: 817 deaths, 1,335 LTC/RH cases, 368 LTC/RH deaths Image
Apr 2

-#COVID19 is in top 4 largest mortality events in #Canadian history

-Last 28 days: 817 Canadians died of C19

-If every week is like this week, 834 Canadians may die in next 28 days Image
Apr 2

#COVID19 #Canada

CASE FATALITY RATES

Wave 1 (to Aug 17)
Wave 2 (to Feb 18)
Wave 3 (Feb 19 to date) Image
Read 33 tweets
22 Mar
Thread on Canadian excess deaths during #COVID19, round 3.

Why do I keep posting about this?

Because I'm worried we've missed a lot of C19 deaths outside LTC and that we may see many more during the 3rd wave because of slow rollout of vaccination of older adults in community.
When did I start thinking about this?

Last year, after reading a paper from @LauraCRosella & colleagues about excess mortality during first wave in Ontario, estimated from cremation data (which is reported fast and includes place of death information).

medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
Actually, it dates back further, to a @CIHI_ICIS report on #COVID19 deaths in congregate care in #Canada, which found that 80% of deaths in the first wave were in congregate care (long-term care, retirement homes), which in turn is twice the OECD average.

cihi.ca/sites/default/…
Read 73 tweets
21 Mar
Mar 19

1 of every 41 #Canadians with #COVID19 has died since Feb 2020

1 in 64 BC
1 in 72 AB
1 in 76 SK
1 in 36 MB
1 in 45 ON
1 in 28 QC

1 of every 5 Cdns w/ C19 in long-term care & retirement homes has died

LAST 28 DAYS: 1,026 deaths, 1,969 LTC/RH cases, 838 LTC/RH deaths Image
Mar 19

-#COVID19 is in top 4 largest mortality events in #Canadian history

-Last 28 days: 1,026 Canadians died of C19

-If every week is like this week, 925 Canadians may die in next 28 days Image
From Mar-Nov 14, 2020

For every excess death of Atlantic and Northern Canadians 45 years and older

This is how many excess deaths in same age group there were in other regions:

BC 62X
AB 39X
SK 51X
MB 24X
ON 65X
QC 108X
Canada outside Atlantic & Northern regions: 68X Image
Read 17 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(