First up, nowhere does it make any sense to push population level numbers. Reporting these as 'effective' is just a disgusting mis-appropriation of the math. Today, 324 people tested positive. That means 8,999,676 didnt, or 99.9964%. Idiotic to present it that way? Of course.
/2
Yet, somehow the Gov and his DOH thinks it ok to just pull that out of their ass and claim it means that the vaccine is 99.99999999% effective. Here's the truth. its not.
What they failed to realize is they gave us some important data today that made this easy to fact check
/3
By giving us the dates of the two breakthrough reports, they gave us the deltas, and made it possible to calculate true breakthrough cases/hospitalizations/deaths.
Here's how that rolls up. There's 2 nuggets of info in this data they gave us, so allow me to explain
/4
One, they admit that in the April report out on breakthroughs that only 30 of the 92 Breakthrough hospitalizations were "FROM" Covid, which means 62, or ~66% of all cases were "WITH".
/5
So, this is an admission that WITH/FROM is real, and the MAJORITY of cases that we count as covid hospitalizations in NJ actually have NOTHING to do with covid. So why are they being counted as such but excluded for breakthrough? Things that make you wonder...
/6
Two, they also admitted during this report that of the 14 Covid deaths, only 7 of them were FROM COVID. That means 50%, or HALF had NOTHING to do with Covid. So, why are they being counted as such but excluded from breakthrough?
/7
So this begs the question: Why are we applying one set of criteria for exclusion, but not doing using the same rigor to count both covid hospital and deaths? How many pregnancies are popping positive, for example, in NJ every day? What % of our total covid hospitalizations?
/8
Next, I determined the number of cases, hospitalizations, and deaths (based on IO) that occurred during those two blocks of time. That rolls up as follows.
/9
With cases between the two points in time, and the Change in breakthrough cases/hospitalizations/deaths from one report to the next, we can calculate the # of Breakthroughs that just occurred.
BT Cases: 2,155
BT Hosp: 54
BT Deaths: 24
/10
Finally, knowing the Change in breakthrough and change in Cases/Hosp/Deaths, we can calculate % of Breakthrough.
Now we can compare that actual result to Murphy's bullshit number.
How many media members pushed back on this? How many wrote about how great Murphy did?
/11
Not a thread to discuss if vaccines work or not, but I will add some of my own context:
* The Breakthrough cases seems in line to me. Its probably being understated
* The Breakthrough deaths to me is NOT good. 7.6% death breakthru? Seems very high.
/12
What would all of this data show if we DIDNT exclude cases/hospitalizations and deaths, like we do with counting covid cases, hospitalizations and deaths? Answer: It would be even worse.
Why do accept the one and not the other?
/13
At the end of the day, not only did Murphy try to pull this over on NJ residents, but the media was all but absent in actually being investigative journalists and call this out. Why does it always fall on others?
/14
This is being done to push vaccine uptake. To scare people, and make the vaccines seems as if they are the way out, all while ignoring natural immunity (Have you ever heard anyone who works for the DOH say those words? Murphy?)
/15
When will politicians and public health realize that people deserve facts, and REAL data, not getting lied to under the guise that its for their own good and they know no better.
Be honest with the data. Stop lying.
/end rant.
โข โข โข
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
#NJ#COVID19 Hospital Admission data, updated today through late last week. This will be stratified by age. Note that all these graphs will be 7 day sums. Divide by 7 to get the daily average admissions.
First, the total
Averaging about 24 confirmed hospitalizations per day
/1
First, pediatric and 18-19 yr olds. There hasnt been an 18-19 yr old admitted with confirmed covid in quote some time, and none through our entire fall wave, yet we are mandating vaccines for college kids. Insane.
/2
Second, 20-29 yr olds. Hasnt been a 20-29 yr old admitted with confirmed covid in almost a month. Again, college kids getting mandated to take a vaccine. Insane.
#NJ#COVID19 Screaming into the void. 1 region (SW) goes from green to yellow. At record low cases, record low hospitalizations. I can't stress how bogus this truly is. You're being warned, if this isnt fixed or brought to the surface by the media, it will screw us in the fall
/1
Case rate metrics have been set by an organization who's mission is a #ZeroCovid outcome. Not the CDC, not the State DOH, but CovidactNow. Why? With false positives and these testing levels, cases below 1/100k are NOT possible.
/2
Percent Positivity is NOT de-duplicated, so every double test positive gets counted. This overinflates true % positivity. Never been questioned, never been explained.
/3
This is the SIREN study in the UK. Of 32k healthcare workers, 10k were covid positive during the pandemic, defined as either PCR + or having AB. Of those 10k only 241 during the entire pandemic have been reinfected.
/1
Key note here:
As Delta has increased from 0 to 90% of all cases, reinfections remain flatlined.
Since Delta has gone from 0 to 90% of all cases, refinection rates are hovering at 0.2 reinfections per 1000 cases.
/2
Meanwhile, since the start of Delta in February, 4,087 of the 60,624 infections have been complete breakthrough infections, meaning > 14 days after the second dose.
This equates to a rate of 67.4 breakthrough infections per 100k
#US#COVID19 Talking points issued. 12-15 Vaccination demand is waning, CNN/MSNBC/White House and all the muppets will be screaming from now through Sunday at how kids are being hospitalized. Push back on the non-sense, because its just not true!
Talking Point #1: Hospitalizations as a percent are up!
Debunking: They are up as a % because all other ages are way down, but they child hospitalizations are still DOWN
Talking Point #2: These kids are in the hospital for covid!
Debunking: No, many of them (CA study found up to 40%) are in the hospital for something else and just happened to test positive.
#NJ#COVID19 Case update for 5/5. Mass Deletions continuing. Groundhog day. Growing increasingly frustrated with inability of *ANYONE* to press this issue.
Where's the media?
Where's the legislature?
Where's the Concern/Outrage?
Another 895 deletions. *13,092* in 10 days.
They are rewriting the epi curve. They are giving the public no transparency. Where the hell are the people running against Murphy? Look at what rewriting it has done to the curves. The winter wave is soon going to be similar than the Spring bump, with no explanation.
They are out of cases to harvest. The cumulative delta is negative.
Cases are close to the 1500 range, but we keep reporting under 100. This is going to crush Rt when it ends.
Reported: 1309 (??)
Adds: 1784 (!!) Love the 62 dumped on March 13th.
Deletions: 895 (!!)
Net: 889
#NJ#COVID19 Case update for 4/26, and its a doozy.
For those who don't know, at today's press conference, the state nonchalantly deleted 10,440 cases. Of course, everyone in the press in the room ignored it, and Lifshitz essentially read out a statement on what happened.
๐งต
The state claims that deletions of duplicates were a manual process and they just, for the first time, automated the process. This automation picked up 10,440 cases that required deletion that the @NJDeptofHealth missed for months. I dispute that claim, and here is why:
/2