1. Most of us do not really appreciate how resilient children and their immune systems are when they encounter #sarscov2. Most kids don’t even realize they have been exposed, which leads to ⬆️⬆️⬆️ over-estimation of the long-term effects of #COVID19 in children
Here’s why … 🧵
2/ when asked, most parents don’t even realize when they child was exposed to #SARS_CoV_2 because most kids either remain asymptomatic or have such a mild and transient illness that parents don’t even associate the illness with #COVID19
3/ In our primary schools study, although small numbers, parents reported no symptoms in 85% of kids who didn’t have #SARS_CoV_2 antibodies at start of the study & then developed antibodies during the study (ie. got infected) compared to 47% of staff
👉 thelancet.com/journals/lanch…
4/ In secondary schools too, although small numbers again, 67% of students who seroconverted (got infected & developed #SARSCoV2 antibodies) during the study reported having no symptoms at all compared to 24% of staff
5/ Importantly, antibody responses after symptomatic & asymptomatic infection in students were indistinguishable 👉 even asymptomatic infection leads to robust immune responses in kids, both in terms of amount of antibody & their ability to kill virus 👉 medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
6/ Also, some kids appear to have T cell (cellular) immunity against #SARS_CoV_2 even without antibodies against the virus. We think this might reflect cross-protection from previous coronavirus infections but this needs further work for confirmation 👉 medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
7/ So, when trying to estimate risk of severe #COVID19 or #LongCovid, remember that most kids do not even develop any symptoms after virus exposure & some kids may be inherently protected from cellular immunity. Surely these kids can’t be at risk of severe or long covid.
End
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ We studied the quality,
quantity and persistence of #SARSCoV2 antibodies in primary school students (6-11 year-olds) compared to staff (adults) over 6 months (until ~7-8 months after their #SARSCoV2 infection)
2/ The proportion of students & staff who had #SARSCoV2 antibodies in back June 2020 was similar:
👉 11.5% (95%CI, 9.4-13.9) & 11.3% (95%CI, 9.2-13.6; p=0.88) students had nucleoprotein & RBD antibodies vs 15.6% (95%CI, 13.7-17.6) & 15.3% (95%CI, 13.4-17.3; p=0.83) staff
3/ Live virus neutralising activity (ability of antibody to kill #SARSCoV2) was detected in 79.8% (71/89) of N antibody & 85.5% (71/83) of RBD antibody positive kids. RBD correlated more strongly with neutralising activity (rs=0.75; p<0.0001) than N antibodies (rs=0.37; p<0.0001)
1/ We developed & validated an oral fluid assay to measure #SARSCoV2 antibodies. Basically it’s a lollipop stick with a sponge that collects oral fluid (saliva) from around cheeks/gums. Kids can do the test themselves & sample can be posted to the lab 🧵👉 medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
2/ Here’s the technical stuff: We used contemporaneous blood & oral fluid samples from ~2,000 kids & adults taking part in our school studies and developed 3 different oral fluid assays for testing & validating: N-antibody, Spike-antibody & RBD-antibody 👉 medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
3/ The N-protein capture assay was the best candidate, sensitivity 75% (95%CI, 71–79%) specificity 99% (95% CI: 78–99%) when compared with paired serum antibodies, but higher sensitivity in kids (80%, 95% CI: 71–88%) than adults (67%, CI: 60%-74%) 👉 medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
1/9. In England, #SARSCoV2 infection rates in school-aged kids & #COVID19 outbreaks have both ⬆️ in recent weeks (latest data 4 July) but that does not change the narrative on kids & their role in infection/transmission in school
2/9. No one has claimed that kids don’t get infected or don’t transmit #SARSCoV2 to others. But the data suggest that lower risk with kids than adults. Eg. We don’t see two-thirds of staff/students infected in a single outbreak as we do in care homes 👉 thelancet.com/journals/eclin…
3/9. We & others have shown that #SARSCoV2 cases & outbreaks reflect community infection rates. Cases in kids generally follow adults *unless* adults are in lockdown & kids continue to go to school. This happened in Nov/Dec 2020 & Mar/Apr 2021. See👇👇
1/4 Childhood #COVID19 deaths. This preprint by @RCPCHtweets & @PHE_uk provides critical new information about #SARSCoV2 and kids which we didn’t have until now. Here’s why the small numbers in this paper matter 🧵
2/4 Death is the most objective outcome & can be accurately measured in countries like England. The results show ~3,000 of 12 million kids died in 1 year & only 61 with #SARSCoV2. Detailed medical record analysis showed only 25 (42%) died *of* #COVID19
3/4. Of the 25 kids who died of #COVID19, 19/25 (76%) had underlying conditions & of these 15/19 (60%) had a life-limiting condition & mostly with 2 or more medical conditions, esp. severe neurological conditions
2/5 Compared to 2 doses of the same vaccine brand, mixing Pfizer/AZ vaccines was associated with higher rates of severe reactions & requiring medical attention after the 2nd dose: esp. in younger adults, in women & in those with previous #COVID19 🧵
3/5 Adults who had a severe reaction after their 1st dose of #COVID19 were more likely to have a severe reaction after 2nd dose, whichever vaccine they received, but risk of severe reactions increased if 2 different vaccine (AZ/Pfizer) brands given 🧵