Thread: German orbats
German document can be very interesting, even if you don’t speak German.
Their visual OOBs are prob the best example of that, if you know what the symbols mean.
Yes, you can look those up online, but how about a crash course in several threads?
Modern publications typically use NATO symbols. Useful, but also boring.
(Examples from Zetterling’s ‘Normandy 1944’ and Zaloga’s ‘Cherbourg 1944’)
German OOB charts are great, and a little confusing
Regard them as a unit assembled on an inspection ground: that they're seen from the perspective of a commander looking at his troops. So left on paper is actually right and right is left: So 4-3-2-1. Applies to all subunits!
As for units, different types of numbers are used:
Div., regiment and companies/batteries/columns: Arabic
Battalions: Roman (also applies to Corps)
No letters for companies!
now we’re speaking about numbers:
division and company numbers come before the unit: 319.Inf.Div.; 1st Co
Most other numbers come second: Gren.Rgt.582, Nachr.Abt.319, etc.
So while English language publications *always* say 582nd Gren. Rgt., I'd say they are wrong 🙃
Note: the ‘.’ in ‘319.’ turns is into a ordinal number. So ‘319.’ means 319th. Also applies to subunits
II./Gren.Rgt.582 = 2nd battalion, Gren.Rgt.582. In English often written as 2/582, because they use Arabic numbers. Company A/582 is 1./582 in German
Back to the OOBs:
Flags are important. They identify units down to battalion level
Here we have:
-division flag
-regimental flag (square)
-battalion flag
Each of these can be modified to show a specific type of unit
Examples:
-simplest form: infantry
-add a rhomboid: Panzer-Div. (think of the first tank design)
-add two bars: Artillery-Rgt. (think of two wheels on an art. piece)
-add two arrows: engineer-bn
But more on this later
OOBs can show different things. 3 are particularly common:
-standard organization (Grundgliederung)
-authorized strength (Soll-Gliederung)
-actual strength (most important)
All of these do not include small arms. It’s basically machine-guns and heavier stuff
So a Gliederung can tell us the basic organization of a unit, incl. the subunits and heavy(ish) weaponry. Platoons can be included if they are ‘unique’ (within a larger unit or independent)
To be continued with a closer look at infantry divisions!
If you enjoyed this thread and would like to support me, you can get me Ko-Fi ko-fi.com/niels_1944
Let's continue examining Cross-Channel Attack's (CCA) take on the German troops. For 1950/1951 it was admirable, but as we have seen yesterday not all of it holds up.
Now look at this sentence. The German use of stomach units has become (in)famous, but CCA correctly states that was just one division: the 70ID
The existence of ear and stomach units is a popular story, but it is seldom explored for what it really was.
On D-Day the 70ID did not really exist yet...
In the bigger picture it was very much an emergency formation in the summer (crisis) of 1944.
Thread: German static divisions in Normandy supposedly had very poor personnel. While true to some extend but as always it's a bit more complicated. Cross-Channel Attack (1951) made a serious attempt for a balanced view. Arguably better than much what has been written since!
The book seems to be key in spreading the message that 'the average age of the 709ID was 36'. This is commonly presented as fact when in fact it was based on anecdotal evidence: An officer explaining the failure of his division.
His claim made it into German records as well 🙄
Fact: the maximum average age of the combat elements in static divisions was set at 36.
And yes, support elements could raise that to over 36. But that’s just theory…
Are there reasons to believe that actually happened in the 709ID? Not really. 🧐
The number of horses for the artillery as show here is actually too low because it included some batteries with just 3 guns, instead of the actual 4
For Normandy such 'standard' divisions included the 271ID, 272ID, 275ID, 276ID, 277ID, 331ID, 352ID, 353ID, 363ID. Of course these were not identical in strength for various reasons