I wish Ronen Bergman would finally decide to talk or write about these revelations (from his own book!) & I truly wonder what would happen if he did: Would he get "canceled"? Or would other journalists suddenly feel they had cover & could "safely" write about Israeli terrorism?
For ex: Would Tom Friedman, who covered several car bombings in the 1980s (when he got his Pulitzer!) that Bergman revealed in 2018 were covertly conducted by Israel suddenly find these revelations newsworthy/ suddenly find the courage to write about this?
I did a Thread about whether censorship & self-censorship may explain absolute silence of US media about these revelations. I am starting to think that no US media outlet will dare touch this topic UNTIL Bergman himself decides to write / talk about it ...
Note: I am still unclear as to whether Israeli journalists are allowed to write about these revelations, or if military censor ban is still in place. I assume that Bergman would be allowed to talk about this in public? Genuine Qs to those who know ISR censor system better than me
In 2019 Israel's military censor "barred full publication of over 200 articles & partially redacted another 2,000 stories." 972mag.com/idf-censor-isr… In 2020: 116 and 1,403. Were some of these stories about Bergman's FLLF revelations? IMPOSSIBLE to know: 972mag.com/idf-censor-new…
But there is no censorship in the US: the US media has decided on its own NOT to cover these revelations, to treat them as not newsworthy. EVEN THOUGH publication in the US would enable Israeli citizens to gain access to that information & bypass the censor
(Note: There may be have been Israeli media outlets that DID cover Bergman's revelations & that I missed / am unaware of. If that is the case, let me know, send me links, I would of course be very interested in reading those!)
Importantly, @rudoren acknowledged that US newspapers indeed have ways to circumvent the Israeli military censor in this piece from 2014. At the time, Rudoren was the NYT's Bureau Chief in Jerusalem: nytimes.com/times-insider/…
In this piece @rudoren also writes about how journalists deal with "gag orders." On "gag orders," this piece by @Ha_Matar for @972 in 2016 is quite informative as well: 972mag.com/gag-orders-in-…
I sent article to @jdforward about Bergman's revelations in late 2019. @bungarsargon was editor & rejected it. I had exchange w/ @rudoren (who is the editor now) about US media's silence about Bergman's revelations here:
If @ronenbergman finally decided to speak publicly or to write about his revelations regarding FLLF, would this give cover to other US journalists to talk about Israeli terrorism? I don't know, & I don't think we can know until it happens. But I'll repeat what I think we do know:
It is very difficult (maybe impossible) for Israeli journalists to write about this story. The military censorship is opaque, so we do not know for sure, but it is at least possible that stories by Israeli journalists about these revelations have been censored since 2018
I continue to find the censorship system confusing, and am in fact not even 100% sure that, even though his book was cleared by the censor, Bergman himself is allowed to publicly speak about the FLLF operation. What I know is that he has decided NOT to do so since 2018.
But US journalists (those not based in ISR) are not subject to the military censor. THEY can decide to write about this campaign of Israeli terrorism. If they did, THIS in turn would give cover to Israeli journalists to write about it, & Israelis would learn about it
2 years ago I wrote about how military censor killed story by Yediot journos that would have revealed whole thing back in 1981! This story has been censored & covered up for 40 years. US journalists can help bring light to these crimes. OR continue to participate in the cover up
Surely, there are countless Israeli citizens who DO want to know the truth about what their leaders (Dagan, Eitan, Ben-Gal, Sharon) did in the 1980s. Until they do, they CANNOT hope to hold these officials (& others?) accountable. US journalists: you can help make this happen!
Not only is the US media remaining silent about an extraordinarily deadly #terrorist campaign conducted by senior Israeli officials
It is also remaining silent about fact that the truth about this terrorist campaign was covered up through an act of censorship
But that's not all:
If FLLF related stories remain censored in ISR (I do not know if that is the case: there is no way of knowing. what is clear is that Bergman's revelations have NOT been mentioned in the Israeli media since 2018), then US media silence is REINFORCING this ongoing act of censorship
Again I ask: US journalists: Do you want to continue to participate in covering up the truth about this #terrorist car bombing campaign OR do you want to be part of a movement that would enable Israeli citizens to learn about their government's crimes & call for accountability?
And of course, of course: US journalists could thus enable a movement that could bring justice to the VICTIMS of these #terrorist attacks, the hundreds of Palestinian & Lebanese civilians (& their families) killed & maimed by the FLLF's (ie Israel's) car bombs
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Context on how "terrorism" discourse is PURE IDEOLOGY: in 2018 @ronenbergman revealed that senior @IDF officers created & ran #terrorist group that killed 100s of civilians in Lebanon in 1980s. This has been greeted w/ TOTAL media silence & ZERO answer from the Israeli government
In 1981 the Israeli military censor (how often do we hear, in US, about existence of that censorship system?) killed story by 2 @YediotAhronot journalists that would have revealed the whole thing. And still, ONLY Palestinians are ever called "terrorists"
In his book, @ronenbergman describes IN DETAIL how Ariel Sharon played a DIRECT role in a 2-week car bombing campaign that killed at least 200 civilians in Sept-Oct 1981! Somehow THIS has been deemed NOT newsworthy by US media:
10/01/1981: 40 years ago TODAY: Massive car bomb explodes in front of PLO offices in Beirut. 83 are killed. The street is mangled with body parts. Other bombs are defused. A mysterious group called the Front for the Liberation of Lebanon from Foreigners claims responsibility 1/
This is just the latest in series of extraordinarily deadly car bombings that started 2 weeks earlier. Hundreds of Palestinian & Lebanese civilians are killed. At the time, it is the deadliest car bombing campaign in history. All are claimed by that mysterious group, the FLLF 2/
At the time, Palestinians & many Lebanese people insist that Israel is behind FLLF, that it is a fictitious group created by Israel to hide its role in this #terrorist campaign. Media often report these accusations. Israel insists this is a form fo "Arab on Arab" violence 3/
40 years ago today. Sept 29, 1981. The Washington Post: "Another Car Bomb Explosion in Lebanon Kills 15." It is the latest explosion in a deadly terrorist campaign that started 2 weeks earlier. A mysterious group, the FLLF, has being claiming responsibility for these attacks 1/
In 1980, the FLLF claimed responsibility for an assassination attempt vs the US Ambassador in Lebanon. Palestinians and others in Lebanon insist that the FLLF is merely a cover for Israeli agents acting covertly. Western intelligence sources aren't sure. 2/
In 2018, Ronen Bergman (journo for @nytimes & @YediotAhronot ) confirmed that the Palestinians had been right all along: senior IDF officers did indeed create & run the FLLF. Since 2018 US media has remained completely SILENT about these revelations:
@bungarsargon@JoinPersuasion@Yascha_Mounk@TomRachman This is probably true: "critical race theory is the perfect ideology for affluent progressive whites who want nothing to change—but who still want to feel like the heroes of a story about social justice." But COUNTLESS progressives are not affluent/white & DO want real change
@bungarsargon@JoinPersuasion@Yascha_Mounk@TomRachman Also: you caricature the 1776 Project: its authors say "we should consider whether..." & the entire note u link to is devoted to how this idea was phrased & rephrased, is about nuance. In your version leftists speak in absolutes: "it must be that," "cannot be," "it is proof that"
@bungarsargon@JoinPersuasion@Yascha_Mounk@TomRachman & there is this (insulting?) caricature of the social justice mvt. Do u truly believe that everyone in this broad, diverse mvt follows just one theory? Thinks only in terms of power & only as it applies to race? That they all agree? Never talk, debate, fight over these issues?
It's been 49 days. 49 busy days. And yet somehow the Biden administration still has NOT reversed Trump's Executive Order that threatens sanctions, monetary penalties & imprisonment on persons who assist the ICC!
This is shameful. And so revealing.
One way to think of terrorism is that it is the peacetime equivalent of war crimes. Opposing the ICC (as Israel does, as the US has done: see the Hague Invasion Act!!!) is a clear indication that "we" are NOT opposed to terrorism at all: we want impunity for "our terrorists" 2/
The car bombing described below was conducted by the CIA, Great Britain, Saudi Arabia & Israel. It killed 80 civilians in March, 1985. There has of course never been any accountability for this crime. Nor any acknowledgement of our responsibility!!! 3/
March 8, 1985: Massive car bomb kills 80 people (mostly women & children) in Beirut. The target: Mohammed Fadlallah, a Shia cleric. A few weeks later, Bob Woodward writes that the CIA was behind the bombing. The war on terrorism is, & always has been, pure propaganda 1/
May 12, 1985: Woodward writes that the CIA played a role in the bombing. Note the headline: "Anti-Terrorist Unit Blamed in Beirut Bombing." What "we" do is NEVER "terrorism." It is always "anti-terrorism." The "terrorists" are always the "others" 2/ latimes.com/archives/la-xp…
In his 1987 biography of CIA Director Casey, Woodward would write that the DCI, on his death bed, confirmed to him that the CIA was indeed involved in this massive car bombing: chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-19… 3/