Thread by @barandbench

#SupremeCourt to hear the Lakhimpur Kheri violence case after it rapped the Uttar Pradesh police for “dragging its feet” in the investigation. @Uppolice #LakhimpurKheriViolence

Noting that the special investigation team (SIT) probing the violence needed to get more witnesses to record their statements, the top court adjourned the proceedings last week to October 26.

#SupremeCourt #LakhimpurKheriViolence

Hearing to begin shortly

#SupremeCourt #LakhimpurKheriViolence

UP AAG Garima Prashad: We had circulated the status report

CJI: Why have you kept all accused except one in police custody. For what purpose

AAG: Statements are being recorded and some statements are yet to be recorded

AAG: after filing this report, seven more statements have been recorded under Section 164 CrPC

Sr Adv Harish Salve: There are some updated figures.

CJI: Come to para 3 first

Salve: Out of 68, 30 witnesses have been recorded under 164 CrPC. Of these 23 are eye witnesses. A lot of them are former witnesses etc

CJI: case is there were hundreds of farmers are in a rally. Only 23 people were there ?

Salve: we gave an advertisement. The people who saw the onea in car etc are already there. A large no of digital media has been recovered. There are overlapping videos.

Salve: There was also a person who was conducting videography of the event. These have to be sent to labs so that they can be taken as evidences.

Bench discuss among themselves

#SupremeCourt #LakhimpurKheriViolence

Surya Kant J: You said there was 4,000 or 5,000 people. Mostly they were locals. Post incident most of them have been agitating for an inquiry. Accessibility and identification of such persons in the vehicle should not be a great issue

#SupremeCourt #LakhimpurKheriViolence

Salve: People have seen the car and people inside the car and people being killed

CJI: In such a case there is a possibility of....

Salve: if you approve we can show some 164 statements to you

#SupremeCourt #LakhimpurKheriViolence

CJI: if the eye witness is more credible than a bystander then it's best to have that first hand information

Salve: Can we show you in sealed cover which are the 164 statements. I have been told what kind of statements have been recorded.

Kant J: Let us not forget that some people in this crowd are just fence sitters. There will be only some who can stand and depose

CJI: Identification is important

Salve: all 16 accused have been identified

CJI: Are there any injured witness?

Salve: don't think so

CJI: Not a single injured witness, ok. We can direct the labs to expedite the delivery of the reports

Salve: I believe there are some injured witnesses and some of them are there in the recorded 164 statements. I will give a list

#SupremeCourt #LakhimpurKheriViolence

CJI: Another issue is witness protection and you asked them to apply for it

Salve: That ia a problem with the statement, they have already been provided with security.

CJI: That's okay, just provide them security like CCTV, Home guards...

CJI: We have seen the second statua report by UP. We have been apprised of different steps being taken and development in the case. However the concern is getting reports from FSL labs as early as possible.

CJI: Regarding witness protection we direct the witnesses to be provided protection by the state. We further direct that 164 statements and the relevant ones be recorded expeditiously.

CJI: If a judicial officer is not available, district judge can allocate a nearest magistrate can hear the 164 statements.

Sr Adv Arun Bhardwaj: I appear for Ruby Devi. My husband has been killed. I want justice. The killers are roaming free and threatening me

CJI: Mr Salve..

Salve: I will inform the police...

Salve: Shyam Sundar, the accused is the one here. Husband of Ruby Devi. This is being probed. The death of the journalists who was in the car was also killed.

CJI: you have to file separate replies Mr Salve

CJI: there are two complainants before me. One by Ruby Devi and one death of journalist. State is directed to file separate replies in the case

Bhardwaj: Kindly allow our statements to be recorded..

CJI: Yes

Salve: It will be done

#SupremeCourt #LakhimpurKheri

Matter to be heard next on November 8, 2021
#SupremeCourt #LakhimpurKheri