The current winner for VERY FIRST reference to #CriticalRole goes to Christopher Madan's "Multiple statistical tests: Lessons from a d20" (2016) 10.12688/f1000research.8834.2
As some longtime Critters will already know, the first academic work to focus on #CriticalRole is Robyn Hope's 2017 MA Thesis, "Play, Performance, and Participation: Boundary Negotiation and Critical Role" (which I believe @matthewmercer read) spectrum.library.concordia.ca/983446/
The first book chapters on #CriticalRole wouldn't appear until 2019, academic publishing being what it is. CR is discussed in Steven Lumpkin's "Procedural Storytelling in #dnd" (2019) taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/…
The first chapter to *focus* on CR (& TAZ) was Josh Zimmerman & Antonnet Johnson's "'Roll for Seduction': Sex as Forbidden Play in Critical Role and The Adventure Zone Fan Fiction" in Representing Kink (2019), eds. Sara K. Howe & Susan E. Cook rowman.com/ISBN/978149859…
2019 was also the year of the first currently-known conference paper, Elise Vist's “Their Game or Our Show? Creating a White Canon in Critical Role” presented at @FSNNorthAmericafsn-northamerica.org/wp-content/upl…
Most submissions so far to CRBib are in English, but in 2021 there was a Czech MA thesis by Adéla Motlová "Current role-playing and role of mediation in the Czech Republic on example of Dungeons & Dragons" supervised by Jaroslav Švelch hdl.handle.net/20.500.11956/1…
We have yet to see a book-length, single-authored academic work or dissertation on #CriticalRole, but Joe Lasley's dissertation (Leadership Studies), "An Examination of Gaming Environments in Dungeons and Dragons Groups" (2021) does make reference to CR. digital.sandiego.edu/dissertations/…
I expect that @MariaKAlberto's dissertation in progress on canon formations will be the first dissertation to include a full chapter on #CriticalRole
That said, I know @anitchang beat me by a semester, as his summer 2021 course addressed CR as part of its larger scope.
So, those are the milestones currently in the @CritRoleBib. But roots grow in the dark: my @AtPost45 intro will discuss CR alongside the other important actual plays past & present, & (fingies crossed, y'all) a #CriticalRole edited collection is in the works.
From Musicology to Political Theology to the History of Emotions to Pop Culture to Fan Studies to Statistics to the study of the Irish English Accent, scholars from a wide variety of fields have put their nerdy-ass talents to the study of #CriticalRole. To another #CR7Years!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
For @carolinethegeek & #CR7Years I *think* my first CR tweet is here. I’d gotten tenure the year CR started, my 1st book was out, & I was a lurker for a long time. But I’d respond to that call & write my 1st piece on #CriticalRole.
I’d loved actual plays for a long time, but that chapter gave me “permission” to pitch a course on #TTRPG narrative, which plunged me into the community of nerdy-ass designers, players, fans, & academics.
That course will be followed by two more this fall.
Now I’m finishing up my 2nd academic piece on CR & narrative, & used CR as a “way in” to talking about actual play more broadly for broader audiences. My career spent telling the stories of emerging genres & hidden creative histories is now focused on the spaces CR has opened up.
Seriously, somebody RIGHT now should try to do the same move that Texas A&M did with fantasy authors — convince them to donate their materials now instead of binning them.
Good morning! Between meetings it’s time to read the first #CriticalRole *adventure* (rather than setting) book, CALL OF THE NETHERDEEP. I’m finishing a chapter about CR’s narrative structures, & Netherdeep is the final case study. Throughout the day I’ll post some notes here. 🧵
A note: I’m going to try to avoid specific *spoilers* here (no promises about the chapter). My interest is in thinking about how the book is set up for different audiences.
The prior CR supplement books (Tal’Dorei Guide/Tal’Dorei Reborn, & Explorer’s Guide to Wildemount) were settings, not adventures. So while they were neck-deep in worldbuilding, they were sparing of full-on narrative (until the end of Reborn, which recaps Vox Machina 20 years on)
Just so my non-academic friends are clear: no one, absolutely no one, wants to be the chair of an academic department. ESPECIALLY an English department.
Reasons you might do it anyway:
- you’re in a decent dept that takes turns (uncommonish)
- your school calculates retirement based on highest earning years & the temporary bump will mean something (slightly more common)
- the alternative is a nightmare (often)
Also, it’s kinda like electing a Pope: you really, really don’t want to elect anyone who jumps at the “opportunity” quickly & without hesitation.
Re-upping for the morning shift, partly to remind myself of today’s goal, but mostly to hype the work of my friend the late Bill Bradley. If you love writers who write movingly & hilariously about comics (hi @enthusiamy), soap operas, love, death, & more, you would love Bill.
Some of my favorites that I am turning to today with fresh, wet eyes: “Cathode,” a flash essay about teenage boys, #DnD, and all the things we don’t see until it’s too late: sweetlit.com/issue-7-2/pros…