1/ Militarily, TPLF looks finished; at least as a conventional fighting force. At least for the time being. Its ranks decimated, its fighters demoralized and its popular support at an all time low.
2/ In reality, #TPLF has nothing in its hands to bargain with, other than the threat of future insurgency. At this point in time, the only bargaining chip it has is the support of the USG.
3/ The US is in the talks not only to 'observe' but also 'particiapte', as per @StateDeptSpox Ned Price.
4/ The US is the third negotiating party. The fact that the TPLF delegation flew out on a US army plane along with @MikeHammerUSA is very telling. It is also telling that the preconditions put forth by TPLF are carbon copy of the one outlined by @StateDept. It is Team TPLF/USA.
5/ The US is at the table for the sole purpose of keeping #TPLF alive; convinced that the only power that can keep the HoA divided & subservient to the interest of the west is TPLF and they are threatening GoE with sanctions & financial embargo on behalf of #TPLFinc.
6/ Normalization of relationship, financial support through WBG & IMF and possibly even the return of AGOA would be touted as potential rewards.
7/ In the SA negotiations, the red lines for team Ethiopia are most probably claims over Welkait and Raya and disarmament of TPLF. These should be NONNEGOTIABLE!
8/ For team TPLF/USG, the concessions they want so desperately are assurances re the continuation of TPLF as a political entity to be used as a continuous leverage by the US in HoA.
9/ However, the continued gains by ENDF are keeping the Team TPLF/USG bargaining powers less compelling & shifting the discussion towards terms of surrender and the fate of TPLF leaders. Hence, their insistence on 'immediate cessation of hostilities.'
10/ The US is hoping that the GoE would make significant concessions out fear of being punished economically through WBG and IMF. The bills that would make these possible are still sitting menacingly in both houses of Congress.
11/The question the GoE is probably grappling with at this moment is whether the US will go to that length once #TPLF is 6 feet under.
12/ Allowing TPLF to continue as an entity would most probably mean keeping a potentially very destabilizing force alive that could at any moment launch another insurgency or keep working with historical and geopolitical foes of Ethiopia.
13/ The #TPLF will wait quietly in the background for their opportunity. And the opportunities will come or will be manufactured by the likes of USG or Egypt. It is a matter of time.
14/ The alternative is equally daunting. The economy is already very strained by the financial warfare being waged against Ethiopia by the US and EU.
15/ However, if the TPLF are not viable anymore, to what end would these Western powers wield their influence. Retaliation? Cautionary tell for others who dare to defy the West? Or will they at last come to their senses and accept a #NewEthiopia without the scourge of TPLF?
16/ No one has all the answers. What we know is that a very high stake game of poker or Russian roulette is unfolding in SA.
One thing is crystal clear, though. This was a US-EU war as much as it was an Ethiopian one; albeit, one paid in full with #Ethiopian blood.
SAD!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ The voice of 150+ million people in East Africa is being actively censored by @Twitter. Over the past yr prominent voices have been deplatformed & many others shadow banned. Twitter even went to the extent of banning the trending section for the region!
2/ The global digital town square you envision @Twitter has been a distant dream for us. Twitter has been actively discouraging plurality of thought in the region by suppressing one narrative while promoting another, aligned with interests of certain powerful countries.
3/ Suppression forces ideas underground; makes them more violent by taking away the moderating effect of moderate voices. It fans the flames disinformation. It makes people more paranoid and less tolerant of opposing view points.
1/ Borrell's Garden perpetrated unspeakable atrocities on Africans & other indigenous populations: genocide, slavery, colonialism, nuclear bombs, agent orange! And now they want the world to accept them as paragons of decency!
Shameless.
2/ The Garden People took a Congolese Pygmy by the name Ota Benga and kept him in a Bronx Zoo Monkey House. He committed suicide in 1916.
3/ In 1958, as part of Expo 58, Belgium put 598 people – including 273 men, 128 women and 197 children, a total of 183 families – brought over from Africa on display. The spectators "threw money or bananas over the closure of bamboo,” one journalist wrote at the time.
2/ Unlike the more comprehensive report of the JIT, the #IHRCEE depended on remote interviews, focused only on three incidents and two thematic areas and completely ignored Afar! And yet managed to arrive at more sweeping conclusions. This is as substandard as you could get!
2/ @LaurenBinDC's defense of @kaari_murungi is that she was not a member of the commission at the time she posted those clearly biased tweets calling for R2P against #Ethiopia.
1/ The tweets of @kaari_murungi
did not want to the world to see have been recovered [courtesy of @EthioCyberia]!
It is extremely striking how Murungi's tweets were predictive of the #IHRCEE's most recent statements
2/ Here is Mrs. Murungi calling for R2P in April 2021 long before her appointment to the Commission. Put her tweet side by side with the #IHRCEE statement from Sept 7 urging the UNSC to "take action" and how much her bias affected the Commission becomes glaringly obvious.
3/ Her tweets make it abundantly clear that Murungi has concluded that Crimes Against Humanity have been committed way before Sept 2022. No need for due diligence, no need for witnesses; apparently @kaari_murungi can make such weighty determinations from the comfort of her couch
1/ @DrTedros, recently accused the 'IC' of being racist for paying more attention to #Ukraine.
We (@Qnie_Addis & @Kings_of_Nile) analysed his tweets, RTs & likes starting from Oct 2021. Given his pronouncements, what we found was quite revealing.
2/ When you pay close attention to his Twitter activity, despite his protestations, #Tigray predominate his TL. He sometimes tweets, RTs or likes up to 8 Tigray related tweets per day! He has tweeted, RTd or liked tweets mentioning Tigray 208 times over the past 23 months!
3/ What about #Yemen you ask? And #Syria? Surely, the man who claims to be the conscience of the world would tweet incessantly about these humanitarian crises that had been raging for years. Nope! In reality, they are occasionally invoked only to accompany #Ukraine and Tigray.
1/ TPLF is facing serious setbacks in the battlefield, despite rearmmamanet and logistical support from Egypt and the UN. The Americans are convinced the only way to keep #TPLF viable is to bring them to the negotiation table.
2/ The US and probably EU have strong armed the AU to be included in the negotiation in some capacity; to make sure TPLF gets a better deal than it deserves based on it's current military standing.
3/ If the GoE refuses, then the sanctions and 'genocide' determination will be reactivated. Behind th scenes, the cosponsors of #HR6600 have increased from 9 to 18 between April and Sptember! In a way this negotiation is between the USG and GoE!