1/n what did MSCI Say ?
"MSCI has received feedback from a range of market participants concerning the eligibility"
“Characteristics of certain investors have sufficient uncertainty that they should no longer be designated as free float pursuant to our methodology.”
=> basically MSCI felt there is truth in what #Hindenburg portrayal of a "Close Relationship" with the FIIs
MSCI Also Said
"This determination has triggered a free float review of the Adani Group securities" which will be informed in Mid-feb and implemented by End-feb
Using the analysis of the Hindenburg Research report, rough numbers indicate (my calculations) outflows.
Adani Ent: $95mn
Adani Pow: $25mn
Adani Total Gas: $220mn
Adani Trans: $210mn
Adani Green & Adani Port dont get impacted.
In my there are several more events that would be triggered by #MSCI and purely based on my opinion. 1) Index Provider FTSE will also implement the same but the impact would not be as large 2) As more data emerges on the other FIIs not mentioned in the #HindenburgReport
2 contd) there could be more weightage tweaks
3) An action by MSCI and FTSE would put pressure on the #NSE to also consider their free float. BIG ONE
4) Its very possible that pending investigation, #SEBI could put restrictions on the so called #AdaniGroup friendly FIIs/FPIs.
5) Significant losses for $ #BOND holders & #Equity holders (ETFs) of ADANI group Secuities, given concerns around the web of entities & money highlighted by #Hindenburg, #WSJ, #FT Analytics, a potential CLASS ACTION Lawsuit against #AdaniGroup is quite possible IMHO.
6) IMHO, this would put even more pressure on the likes of @LICIndiaForever whos the ONLY Active Discretionary Institutional Buyer of #Adanigroup (Ex ports & cement) stocks to hold off... basically NOT DOUBLE DOWN.....
7) IMHO, given very (1) limited CASH FLOW support, (2) Limited incremental buying (3) NO Valuation Support with Significantly lower DCF valuation vs Current mkt Price... there is likely to be pain for equity holders
8) Pressure on the Stock Price would also put pressure on Lenders - both Organized and Unorganized - to also reduce but for sure NOT ADD INCREMENTAL exposure to the group which Required TONS of CAPITAL every year.
9) Recall that GROUP Debt rose in FY21 from Net Debt of 1.2 lac cr to 2.2 lac Cr despite group operational Cash flows..... that's a massive 1 LAC CRORE of INCREMNETAL borrowing in FY22.
But this does not include many recent acquisitions.
9 contd) ACEM & ACC $10bn Acquisition happened in FY23. The Port in Israel, Egypt & Sri Lanka and potentially Bengal happened in FY23. NDTV happened in FY23. It's very easy to lose count.
Bangladesh wants to renegotiate power deal with Adani. No wonder. Exclusive analysis for AdaniWatch shows Bangladesh will be paying double the cost of power from other plants. adaniwatch.org/is_bangladesh_…
I personally know of a Operations consultant- a super guy - who was working on ACC and AMBUJA cost cutting programs for over 30 months starting 2019… Covid didn’t stop him but Covid just delayed his program which was to be taking just 18 months.
He was deputed by the previous CEO of HOLCIM India and the consultant worked on both ACC and AMBUJA. In his view ACCs plants had a structural problem which would keep the Gap between ACC and say ultra tech. So am surprised that after he left this COST improvement came in 6 months
There needs to be more explaining on what drove these sharp cost improvements.
#Budget2023#CAPEX growth of 30% Year over Year is just a game of #Smoke & #Mirrors (the hallmark of #Modinomics) .... if you recall, I mentioned that "Devil Lies in the Detail"
Entire Story in 1 Chart. Combines Central Govt & PSU Capex excluding dirty tricks.
@nsitharaman budget numbers for CAPEX includes items below 1) 50yr Loans to the States (much of this is consumption by state & double counted) 2) Loans to Food Corp India (Rations & MSP) 3) Capital Infusion is Loss making PSUs to pay Salaries & O/p Losses (BSNL, Air India)
These 3 items are NOT Capex .... so when does an Apples to Apples comparison, these adjustments needs to be made...
In short Central Govt & Off-balance sheet or PSU Capex is ONLY 3.8% of GDP (Lower than pre-covid) vs say 4.5% of GDP in FY10
Booking my profits on Adani Ports. It’s given a decent 28% return on my avg entry price. Am happy.
Not a stock reco. Just my thoughts
Honestly I made a mistake buying AdaniPorts since ideally I think it can still go back to 15X multiple if the MSCI action happens for the group. I got an opportunity to Get out and I did. it’s the ONLY CF generating Co with a solid moat.
MSCI China vs MSCI India..
The MSCI China Index’s members have seen about 10% increase in forward earnings estimates since end-October. India has witnessed a mixed bag.
Consumer vs basic materials
In China, HSBC’s Van der Linde expects health care and consumer discretionary profits to grow by 61% and 40% in 2023, respectively, compared with a 6% growth for basic materials (Metals, Cement & Chemicals).
Chinese Accounted for 33% of European Luxury sales pre-Covid .... it fell to 17% in 2022. China Accounts for 18% for consumer durables and 10% for household items for European Cos
#AdaniGroup cannot file a case against @HindenburgRes for two reasons 1) Report was published in US. A case filed in India, it will be Transferred to the US under law.
Adani can’t risk providing Documentation for 270+ Entities plus Related Party Overseas Entities & 7 FPIs
Which might be made party to the case
2) There is nothing Wrong with what the Hindenburg Report disclosed. It’s contains Public Information as well as Investigative Journalism obtained at their one cost
One of the MOST important accusations of made in the #HindenburgReport is that Adani Listed Cos, Adani Family & People acting in concert are round tripping money from Adani back into Adani via FPIs. In the #AdaniGroup410page Response, they have NOT ADDRESSED THIS