1/ Good morning!
I am still not over the crisis that has been whipped up regarding #DianeAbbott regarding a conversation about distinguishing between RACISM vs PREJUDICE 😳
The articulation may have been clumsy, but I invite someone to explain something to me…
2/ I have Jewish friends- they’ve white skin outwardly.
The only thing that identifies their Jewishness is “name” and of course when they literally tell you “I’m Jewish”
Is it antisemitic to say “a white Jewish person is able to use their white skin to shield away from racism”
3/ As far as I am concerned #DianeAbbott ‘s discussion centred around “our outward appearance influences the way racism/prejudice can be used to harm minorities”
Most Jewish people I know (directly) are white skinned, until they told me they’re Jewish - I’d no idea whatsoever🤷🏾♂️
4/ There are people with Jewish heritage (I.e. ancestry) who are Christians/atheists etc, and their only connection to Jewishness is “heritage: I.e a grandparent was Jewish” - outwardly they’re simply WHITE male/female - can some1 explain what structural racism these people face?
5/The reaction from British media, pundits, and indeed some white Jewish people on twitter has suggested that we should not be able to comment on the concept that there are WHITE skinned people with Jewish ancestry- who are actively not practising Jews- who simply pass as white🤷🏾♂️
6/ commenting on the above, does not mean one dismisses the existence of prejudice and racism that Jewish people face, on the contrary - it brings forth the complexity of how diverse and subtle everyone’s experience of discrimination can be.
It also discusses white privilege🤷🏾♂️
7/ Whether British people want to hear it or not (including white Jewish people)- a key cornerstone of SKIN COLOUR based RACISM is that “white is superior, whereas anything non-white is deemed unworthy and undesirable”
Black/Asian/Chinese/Japanese etc CANNOT hide their skin🤷🏾♂️
8/ a Black person, Asian person, Arab person, Chinese, mixed raced person etc - will be judged by a white supremacy world without the need for additional information! They’ll be judged purely from the colour of their skin!
A white Jewish person can evade racism by non-disclosure
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/I feel sad this evening about race relations in the UK…
The fact that 2 demographics that collectively have experienced genocides/crimes against humanity at hands of “white supremacy” cannot seem to understand each other is tragic
One demographic CANT hide behind white skin😪
2/ The Jewish community endured and fortunately survived the horrors of the holocaust - a period where white supremacy aryans: confiscated their livelihoods, subjugated them, sent them to labour/murder camps
Black people endured and survived centuries of similar abuses 🤔🤷🏾♂️🤷🏾♂️
3/Yet today because of a clumsy wording in a context of a much broader discussion— about RACISM vs PREJUDICE… Jewish people are joining with the British media to whip #DianeAbbott publicly, whilst belittling her lived experiences of racism, by highlighting their pain as superior
2/ In @Baddiel apology for his antiBLACK racism, he says to JasonLee:
I quote: "...Stuff happened to me, that helped me understand how you (BLACK) must have felt. As I became more well known PARTICULARLY as I put my JEWISH identity a bit more forward, I experienced racism"
3/ In @Baddiel 's apology, he implies that outwardly, without him putting out his Jewishness, Baddiel is ABLE TO PASS as a causal white man.
He experienced heightened racism and abuse, ONLY WHEN he exposed his Jewishness.
Everyone on this earth 🌍- of any race, orientation, ability, gender etc can face discrimination and prejudice
RACISM as it was designed by WHITE Europeans centred around the outward appearance of an individual, with WHITENESS being a protective factor
2/ As we have seen from #Israel with regards to their comments and attitudes towards BLACK people, ARAB people, it is very much possible for people who are outwardly non-of-colour to identify with white supremacy and commit racism against people who are outwardly of colour🤷🏾♂️🤔😳
3/ it doesn’t however suggest or mean that all Jewish or all Israeli people are outwardly white.
Similarly, People from the Middle East (including settlers who fly in from USA, Europe, Australia, Russia, Ukraine etc) can be outwardly protected from white skin influenced racism!
1/ About #DrOki, the @TheBMA - and some of the responses I am seeing from "random" people.
RACISM is a DREADFUL experience for those of us who are not WHITE, who have to experience a form of hate crime that centres around "White is superior, any other race is lesser than"
2/ #Racism in the form that we know it today, centres around Eugenics spread by EUROPEANS as they sailed around the world, invading non-European lands and subjugating the populations they found.
3/ The issue we have today is that:
When BLACK people/ASIAN people/ARABS/CHINESE (anyone who isn't white) points out how UGLY, EVIL, PAINFUL racism is:
There's a white person somewhere who feels awkward/fragile/emotional and to feel better - they have to SHUT DOWN minority voices
1/ Being a survivor of the #Rwandan genocide that happened in 1994…
I cannot help but notice similarities between what the west is doing with #sudan and what they did with #Rwanda — which was “rescue their own white people, and abandon the local BLACK to doom and death”
2/ So far both #USA and #UK have apparently prepared planes to removed “their citizens” from #Sudan — this is what happened in #Rwanda too
In rwanda - white people were told to leave their black friends behind, and those black people were butchered to death…
This is awful 😳
3/ My family had a dreadful experience of this white privilege… my family was a mixed family - French/Belgians married to #Rwandans
They allowed white people, their spouses and only mixed raced kids! Any black adopted kids/ cousins etc had to stay behind … and perish!
2/We as a country are reaching dangerous times - we are living a situation where politicians pander to the xenophobic views of voters in order to gain votes and stay in power!
I’m still astounded that @Mark_J_Harper practically skirted around @adilray ‘s concerns with NO empathy
3/ It is highly inappropriate for politicians of all sides to use xenophobia towards minorities as bouncing board to gain votes
The Tory party, @reformparty_uk and other right wing parties are particularly prone to doing this! Sadly @UKLabour has started to emulate this: awful
4/The UK needs to look in the mirror and start holding its politicians to account
I’m tired of seeing white British people clutch their pearls when Black/Asians say “the UK is a racist country”- white voters are enabling the abuse of people like @adilray then acting shocked😳 🤔