Adam Briggs Profile picture
26 Nov, 21 tweets, 12 min read
Wk 25 T&T report thread. 12 - 18 Nov.

tl,dr: cases down, contacts up, improvements stalled, and £37bn is a lot of money.

Summary in pic, details in thread.
gov.uk/government/pub…
Interesting that number of individuals tested down by 1% this week (although that's still 1.74m people).
This includes the lateral flow devices being used in Liverpool and some other settings (reported in pillar 2).
Cases fell for the first time since mid-August. Down 9% to 152,660, and positivity also down. This is consistent with PHE data today, as well as ONS survey.
Also general better news all round with turnaround times on testing. This may (in part) reflect a system that's generally less stretched.
For contact tracing, there were 156,574 case transferred to the system, of which 132,905 (85%) were reached. Last week was 86%, and whilst this is still pretty high, 23,669 cases weren't reached.
And as with previous weeks, around 3% of cases were handled by PHE health protection teams (part of outbreaks in specific settings) and the remainder handled by the national T&T team (or local contact tracing teams where the national team can't reach cases)
81% of cases provided details of one or more close contact, and whilst it's been around this level for a while, the trend does look to be tapering off slightly.
I wonder how much of this is cases & contacts being in same household.
We know from local contact tracing that HHs with >1 case and multiple HH contacts can receive huge numbers of calls, making people less willing to engage.
And proportion of contacts that are same HH is rising.
In terms of timing, after a couple of wks' improvements, the number of cases reached within 24hrs (v important for local contact tracing systems who get cases *not* reached by national team w/i 24hrs) has now stalled at around 71% for 3 wks in a row.
On contacts, despite number of cases giving details of contacts falling by 2%, the number of contacts increased by 11% to 347,575.

This reflects a rise in contacts/case among those not managed by PHE teams from 2.3 to 2.6.
It's really hard to know why this might be - people more willing to give information, more mixing, random variation?

It does go against 5 weeks of downward trend from 3.1 contacts per case in wk of 08/10, to 2.3 last week.
Either way, the percentage reached hasn't budged. 59% reached by the national system, and 60% overall.

That's 210k contacts reached.
And 138k not reached.
The time to reach contacts is worsening again.

Now 44% of contacts reached within 24hrs of a case being transferred.
As keeps getting emphasised, irrespective of mass testing ambitions and of rolling out vaccines, contact tracing still has a huge role to play in managing COVID, and it will continue to do so for many months yet.

T&T now has a 2yr budget of £37bn.
In terms of improving the system, there are clearly still lots of marginal gains to be had, there are more local systems in place, and tonnes of learning to be had about how these work and how they best interact with the national team

And people must be no worse off if isolating
Isolating if you have symptoms, a positive test result, or are identified as a contact is critical to stop transmission, but it can be really hard to do for loads of reasons, with big big implications for inequalities.
There's £500 for people fulfilling specific criteria, and local govs have put in place lots of support infrastructure.
But the impact of the T&T model on inequalities is still unclear, and there seems to be no coherent national targeted strategy to help those who need it most.
Without this, many people aren't going to go and get tested, and aren't going to isolate. So whilst mass testing sounds good, and improving contact tracing will inevitably help, neither solve this underlying issue. £37bn is a lot of money.
And happy thanksgiving everyone. Our pumpkin pie was undercooked, but it still tasted good and we needed to get the kids to bed. 🦃

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Adam Briggs

Adam Briggs Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ADMBriggs

26 Nov
Latest PHE covid/flu report thread.
Covers 16th - 22nd Nov.

COVID rates and hospitalisations are falling, but there are important big regional variations.

And the number of children and over 65y/os getting their flu jab is already higher than last year!

gov.uk/government/sta…
Welcome signs that case numbers and case rates are falling both in PHE data & ONS survey

Not going to disentangle positivity rates here, mass/lateral flow testing is in pillar 2, many will have confirmatory PCRs, & ideally symptomatic vs asymptomatic would be reported separately
And these falling case rates are across ALL age groups and ALL regions.
Read 15 tweets
23 Nov
ICYMI, today the gov launched the COVID Winter Plan.

It includes an additional £7bn for Test & Trace, who's budget now stands at £22bn.

The comparison with PHE's entire budget is old news. But in case it helps, it was £300m.

gov.uk/government/pub… Image
There can surely be very little argument left against reversing long term cuts to public health budgets.

Instead, long term sustained investment in local and national public health systems must be a key priority in the post-covid national recovery.
Have just finished reading the plan.

Aside from the continued roll out of local contact tracing, the T&T improvement is entirely focused on scaling up testing. Entirely.

I know there are lots of people working really hard on this, I just hope they're being listened to.
Read 4 tweets
19 Nov
Week 24 Test & Trace data summary. 05/11/20 – 11/11/20.

After two weeks of improvement, performance has stalled whilst the number of people testing positive continues to rise.

As ever, summary in pictures, detail in thread👇

gov.uk/government/pub… ImageImageImageImage
12% increase in people getting tested which is good (now 1.74m in a week(!)), but note from 6th Nov, pillar 2 now includes people having the rapid lateral flow tests (e.g. Liverpool pilot) and this will only increase in numbers.
The knock-on impact is lower P2 positivity rates. ImageImageImage
The implications of this is that it makes it far harder to interpret positivity rates, esp if you don't separate out test device, or asymptomatic vs symptomatic testing.
Read 19 tweets
19 Nov
Latest PHE flu & COVID surveillance report, up to 15th Nov.

- ⬆️Case rates in over 70yrs.
- ⬆️hospitalisations, ICU admissions & deaths.
- Big variation by region, ethnicity, age, and deprivation.
- (+ some good news on flu & flu jabs)

gov.uk/government/sta…
Confirmed cases of COVID plateaued this week, and positivity rates dropping.

Still probably a little early to see results of 6th Nov restrictions, but local restrictions likely important. And new use of lateral flow tests (pillar 2) may be contributing to lower positivity rates.
And case rates falling across most aged but crucially NOT among age 70yrs+
Read 15 tweets
18 Nov
Irrespective of the fact that 50,000 of 5,000,000 is 1% rather than 0.1%, here's a v short selection of data that might help to clarify some of the differences between flu and COVID-19.

Short thread.
Fortunately, @PHE_uk have a flu surveillance programme.

Over past 5yrs, the worst flu season saw an estimated 22k deaths in Eng (2017/18).

So far ONS have recorded 55k deaths including COVID. Gov.uk estimate 46k.

It's not yet December.

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/upl…
Hospital admission rates from flu in the past five years peaked in 2017/18 at around 10/100,000.

In the first week of November, it was already >14/100,000 and >25/100,000 in the NE.
Read 5 tweets
12 Nov
Week 23 Test & Trace data summary. 29/10/20 – 04/11/20.

It's getting better but there's still a way to go.

Summary in pictures, detail in thread 👇

gov.uk/government/pub… Image
>1.5m people tested this week, 2% more than last week.

So whilst testing capacity's grown, it's not translating into more people being tested.

Number of positives up 8% as well to 149,253, across both pillar 1 and pillar 2. ImageImageImageImage
So despite more capacity, positivity ⬆️this wk (to 11.5% in P2, 5.1% in P1). Although today's PHE data suggests this rise may be stalling.

And still not separating symptomatic vs non-symptomatic testing, plus these results are before L'pool mass testing. ImageImage
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!