On the face of it, this does seem to be more weighted to dates rather than data.
It will be interesting to see if *any* quantitative thresholds for cases, hospitalizations, or pressure on hospitals are set out on Monday, or whether the only thing that are set are dates.
It is obviously a risk, I'd reports are correct, to send all school children back on the same date. One critical thing missing is the ability to adapt. If R exceeds 1 and hospitalizations increase as a result of this, all that can be done is to close face to face...
schooling with the effect this will have on children's continuity of education. It would be prudent to send *some* children back and see the effect before committing all children.
Remember, it is not just the interactions between children (which *could* be mitigated...
e.g. by introducing new measures e.g. ventilation requirements as a result of increased transmissibility and severity of the Kent variant), it is also the increased interactions between parents and carers.
While many vulnerable grandparents may have been vaccinated ...
the newly-categorised shielding group will only have recently has their vaccinations when schools reopen.
The critical thing is that a reopening plan can *adapt* to new data. It will be interesting to see how this is planned for in the reopening policy...
If reopening cannot be reversed if new data is forthcoming, we may yet see a fourth lockdown.
There are encouraging signs on case numbers, vaccinations, and hospitalizations. It is critical that optimism bias does not cloud prudent policy setting.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The Government's roadmap for reopening has been published.
I will add commentary as I read through.
From first glance, there are no numbers for thresholds, which does in some way question the notion of 'data not dates'.
There are however a lot of dates in the document.
The roadmap itself is only 15 pages long.
It sets out 'principles'
- whole of England rather than regional response
- "led by data not dates" (see above)
- five weeks between steps - 'no earlier than'
- face-to-face education a priority
We risk creating a legal fiction that workplaces are safe when they are not.
A short thread on the DVLA outbreak, and Government policy.
In order to encourage people back to work after the first wave (presumably under political pressure), the civil service set targets for 4 out of 5 civil servants to return to their workplaces