Sid Mehta Profile picture
Aug 8, 2021 27 tweets 15 min read Read on X
I'm not a lawyer. I didn't attend law school. I'm the biggest skeptic of the #RuleOfLaw that I know.

Here's my thread of highlights (excerpts & passages) from #SupremeMyths: Why The Supreme Court Is Not A Court & Its Justices Are Not Judges by @espinsegall + my comments.
Preface | “It’s no great secret that the Supreme Court’s Constitutional Law decisions reflect the personal values of the Justices…that politics & personality affect the Court’s decisions is only the beginning of the story.”

#SCOTUS produces case law, hence, it's a legislature.
Prologue xiii | “If changing judges changes law, it is not even clear what law is.” ~ Judge Richard Posner

A law means whatever the hell the writers say it means or doesn't mean, based on definition of words & syntax. Writing laws is an art form, it's not mathematics.
Prologue xv

The fact that the Legal Tender Act cases in the prologue set the scene for the entire book is the chef's kiss - money & government. 🤑🤑🤑 Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Prologue xvii cites the term “limited gov’t.”

The description of "limited gov't." varies from one person to the next due to political ideology & preferred systems of governance & governing or rule & dominion. When political terminology isn't universal, conflicts are guaranteed. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 1, p. 1 | Asks the question: Does #SCOTUS function more like a court or more like an ultimate veto council?

Since the Court produces case law - which makes or breaks laws enacted by the Legislative Branch & the Executive Branch - the Court is an ultimate veto council. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 1, p. 2-3 | Cites a rule that judges are to apply pre-existing law.

The legal rule of stare decisis (precedent) binds you to the past - meaning, it can prevent progress as times change or it can provide security during periods of strife. I'm not a fan of this concept. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 1, p. 4 | “Essentially, that means the Court is free to change its prior decisions, and thus the law, as it sees fit, and it does so frequently.”

#SCOTUS is said to be a co-equal branch of gov't. It's a law-making body, just like Congress (acts) & POTUS (Executive Order).
Ch. 1, p. 5 | “These Justices view the Constitution differently...because they...have had different life experiences. When nine such people...need at least five votes to produce an outcome, it’s not surprising that their decisions resemble the work of a political veto council..."
Ch. 1, p. 6 | “To make sure this constitutional democracy works, judges...should not substitute their own policy choices for those of other political officials, but...to make sure that the Constitution’s pre-existing rules (to the extent they’re ascertainable) are enforced.”
Ch. 1, p.6-7 | Cites the problems of life tenure & the Senate confirmation process.

Since #POTUS selects nominees & then the Senate conducts the job interview and either hires or rejects the job seeker - rather than a Justice being elected - the entire process isn't democratic. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch.1, p. 9 | Repeating the rule of being bound by pre-existing law.

Repeating, I'm not a fan of the rule of precedent (stare decisis). Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 2, p. 14 | “…but Levi Lincoln refused to answer questions on the grounds that a high-ranking Executive Branch officer couldn’t be forced by the Court to testify about official business.”

The concept of secrecy is at odds with an enterprise that claims to value transparency.
Ch. 4, p. 31 | “The Constitution isn’t intended to embody a particular economic theory…It is made for people of fundamentally differing views.” ~ Oliver Wendell Holmes

Bullshit. The USA's economic system was established centuries earlier: Exploitation & theft. #Capitalism
Ch. 4, p. 38-39 | #SCOTUS invalidates laws regulating the economic system during the first 35 years of the 20th century.

Again, calling bullshit on Justice Holmes. America is a capitalist, colonial enterprise, thus SCOTUS ruling to conserve #capitalism despite needed reforms. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 4, p. 46 | The Court's Justices are political actors and they're making political decisions.

After all, the Judicial Branch is a co-equal body of the gov't. Producing case law is de facto writing & passing laws. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 5, p. 66 | #POTUS Ronald Reagan isn't criticized for misstating facts.

In America, elected politicians are given way too much deference, especially at the national level. Also, this reminds me of POTUS Richard Nixon: "When the President does it, that means it's not illegal." Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 5, p. 68 | Stare Decisis – the need to follow prior cases.

The legal rule of stare decisis (precedent) binds you to the past - meaning, it can prevent progress as times change or it can provide security during periods of strife. I'm not a fan of this concept.
Ch. 6, p. 79-81, 83, 85 | The Second Amendment.

Professor Segall doesn't include the backstory of #2A: It's a white supremacist law to empower white men to control enslaved Africans and to fight and/or massacre the "merciless Indian savages." Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 6, p. 92 | #SCOTUS Justices are interpreting text, tradition, history and precedent to justify public policy decisions made on other grounds.

This makes me think of a storytelling technique called reverse engineering. It's used sometimes in "unscripted" TV show productions. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 7, p. 118 | #SCOTUS Justice Sandra Day O'Connor predicts the future of racial affairs in a case about affirmative action.

The legal rule of stare decisis binds you to the past. How does any white American predict a racial affairs future that differs from the past? Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 8, p. 139 | #SCOTUS Justices set national public policy.

According to the colonizers who framed the Constitution, the Court is a co-equal branch of the gov't., thus, the Court does have a say in public policy. If the Justices were meant to be judges, then the Framers f-d up. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
Ch. 8, p. 145+148 | Western Civilization & Western World

There's the rub: The U.S. #Constitution establishes & enshrines European Power & Culture as the Supreme Law of the Land, at the expense of #IndigenousPeoples & enslaved Africans.

America's Originalism is #WhiteSupremacy.
Ch. 8, p. 153-154 | Proselytize & Proselytization
p. 157 | “…The Ten Commandments have profoundly influenced the formation of Western legal thought…”

@Pontifex launched the #OrganizedCrimeSyndicate, European #colonialism, with the #DoctrineOfDiscovery.

Ch. 9, p. 183 | “…vague phrases & amorphous concepts...”

A law means whatever the hell the writers say it means or doesn't mean, based on definition of words & syntax. Writing laws is an art, it's not mathematics.

ThE RuLe Of LaW Is SaCrOsAnCt.

It's a confidence game to me.
Ch. 10, p. 185-187 | Designing a new enterprise from scratch.

I wouldn't base a new sovereign nation-state on the #Bible nor #colonialism nor #capitalism nor a fixed charter. I wouldn't be the East India Company (EIC) nor the EIC on steroids - the #USA.

Singapore seems nice. Supreme Myths: Why the Supreme Court Is Not A Court & It’s
@threadreaderapp Unroll, please. Thank you.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sid Mehta

Sid Mehta Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(