Today's BC govt briefing on #Covid19BC was even more disappointing than anticipated. In response, there will be a briefing from @Protect_BC on Thursday, with lots of time for media Qs to PoP doctors, incl. @DrFiliatrault who stopped SARS in its tracks in Vancouver in 2003 #bcpoli
@Protect_BC@DrFiliatrault Why was today's BC govt #covid19BC briefing disappointing?:
- NO rapid tests for BCers before Christmas/NYs! Nothing til mid Jan. Dangerously slow compared to other provs..
- rapid tests misinformation (see next tweet)
- NO acceleration of booster shots or kids vaxx shots #bcpoli
@Protect_BC@DrFiliatrault Misinformation on rapid antigen tests (RATs) from Bonnie Henry today: 1. 'BC has different RAT kits than elsewhere' - she has said this before & it's UNTRUE. 2. Her strange false distinction between lateral flow tests & RATs; they're the same:
@Protect_BC@DrFiliatrault 'People won't go to parties if they don't have rapid tests, but if you give them RATs they'll feel too safe & socialize'...(the same nonsense she gave us re masks -- they make people feel too safe).
You can see what's wrong with this argument from a public health perspective:
@Protect_BC@DrFiliatrault As one doc just commented, Bonnie really doesn't understand the difference between individual decision-making & population level decision-making (her job). They aren't the same.
Breaking even a few chains of transmission prevents 100s of cases down the line. That's the math.
@Protect_BC@DrFiliatrault And worse, Henry's implying rapid antigen tests aren't pretty accurate, which they are.
Also, as was pointed out a few tweets back, if RATs are not accurate, why is she using them in the large settings she says she's going to use them in?
We're at Contradiction Junction here
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This briefing by @Protect_BC is today at 12:30. I'm volunteering to live-tweet it. I'll use the #covid19bc & #bcpoli hashtags, but sparingly. Follow this thread.. this is tweet #1. See you at 12:30.
This train is off the tracks. Dr. Henry was just on @CBCStephenQuinn Early Edition saying 2 vaccine shots is the same protection against #Omicron as Delta & downplaying need for boosters. Has she not read the ample data?! Deal with this, @adriandix@jjhorgan. #bcpoli#Covid19BC
@CBCStephenQuinn@adriandix@jjhorgan Are we to assume Bonnie Henry hasn't only failed to read Pfizer's own data, but also the data that UK public health has put out on the superior protection of 3 doses over 2? What the hell is going on? She just boldly spread misinformation on our national broadcaster. #bcpoli
@CBCStephenQuinn@adriandix@jjhorgan There is no reality principle here. It's not just the NDP mistaking optics for actual governing ; it's BC public health. This isn't science, or health; it's spin.
@TorontoStar “Honestly, I’m not sure I have been as worried as I am now. Probably not..." - Dr. @beatesander
"It’s hard for the human mind to grasp; part of that is the sheer bloody wall of exponential math. The numbers feel imaginary."
@TorontoStar@BeateSander "With a 400 % increase every week, Sander points out the numbers do something like this: 145 today, 600 in a week, 2,400 in two weeks, 9,600 in three weeks. That would be New Year’s Eve, and left unhindered it would mean almost 40,000 cases per day a week after that." #Omicron
I sent this quote to a friend who works in health policy. His reply (pardon expletives):
"That is just.. f'g violent, what she said. Putting the onus back on people to deal with the fallout of her policies. But the thing I don’t understand is... " (cont'd)
.."But what I don't understand is this thing of "x is not a silver bullet, y is not a silver bullet.” Vaccination is not a silver bullet! Should we stop vaccinating? I mean, #Omicron proves that vaccination is not a silver bullet. None of these things are silver bullets"...
.."Hasn’t Dr. Henry herself used the 'layers of Swiss cheese' metaphor? Isn’t she the one who talks about “layers of protection”? How can she have it every which way? She’s just a politician.
Somebody just needs to say none of these measures are silver bullets.."
You need to respond to this, @adriandix. Your ministry openly dodged reporter @PennyDaflos's questions. We don't pay you to run an opaque operation. You work for us. Come clean, start talking, and release the rapid tests to the public now. #bcpolibc.ctvnews.ca/ministry-staff…
@adriandix@PennyDaflos Shall we review how much evidence there is that rapid tests work, and that BC health officials have been evasive, uncooperative, even negligent on this issue? This goes back a year. Start with this fantastic thread by @npescod
@adriandix@PennyDaflos@npescod Here's Bonnie last December & this December making untrue statements about rapid tests, followed by a counterpart in Nova Scotia who says that rapid tests work and are a crucial public health tool that should be handed over to the people.
BC public health is not doing math. We know that a chunk of transmission of #covid19 is by asymptomatic people. How can you break those chains of transmission if you're only testing symptomatic people? I don't understand. #math#bcpoli#FreeTheRATs
There's a whole component of epidemiology that involves stats. It's math: how many people does one person infect; how many of those go on to infect others, & over what space of time; what is the Rt value & is this exponential spread? You want to catch even ONE asymptomatic case..
Breaking *one* chain of transmission can stop countless cases down the line. By not distributing #rapidtests to the public, isn't BC public health admitting they grasp neither asymptomatic transmission NOR the exponential function? #bcpoli#FreeTheRATs