1) Quebec’s new chief of public health, Dr. Luc Boileau, asserted on Wednesday he believes the province’s severely weakened health system could handle a potential influx of long #COVID patients. In this thread, I will examine whether this assertion stands up to closer scrutiny.
2) This is what Boileau said in response to a sharply focused question by the @mtlgazette’s @JesseFeith: “I think we are. I think it’s going to be a challenge. I think the more they are vaccinated, in particular with the 3rd dose, the less they are at risk to develop long COVID.”
3) Dr. Boileau may have confidence in Quebec’s health-care system, but it’s been years since he managed the Montérégie health authority. The system today is in much worse shape than when Boileau ran hospitals and clinics on the South Shore 13 years ago.
4) Citing as-yet unpublished research, Boileau estimated that among the unvaccinated, “it’s possible that 30% of them, close to 30% of them, will still experience very important symptoms after four, eight, 10 and 12 weeks and it may last for a year, a year-and-a-half.”
5) At present, more than a half million Quebec adults have still not yet received a first dose of a #COVID vaccine – let alone a third – placing them at much higher risk of being infected by the super contagious #Omicron variant now circulating everywhere.
6) Let's presume conservatively that half of those vaccine holdouts never get vaccinated, and let's further presume that only 10% of those unvaccinated holdouts develop long #COVID, that would mean the addition of 25,000 patients with chronic illness who would need to be treated.
7) This predicted influx of long #COVID patients – in addition to those who developed the chronic form of the #pandemic illness long before Omicron’s arrival – will no doubt pose a huge burden to a health system some have argued has already collapsed. montrealgazette.com/news/local-new…
8) Consider, too, that Quebec surgeons must clear a backlog of at least 148,000 surgeries – many of which had to be put off during the #pandemic. Consider also the projected increase in cancer mortality in Quebec as a result of missed screening during this unprecedented crisis.
9) McGill University researchers project that délestage during the pandemic, or purposely ramping down clinical activities, will result in nearly 2,800 more cancer deaths in Québec by 2030. Many of these patients will be treated for years in hospitals and clinics before they die.
10) Lest skeptics doubt my long #COVID extrapolations for Quebec, it’s reasonable to look at Finland's experience. The government there is warning long #COVID could become that country’s largest chronic disease, with as many as one in 50 infected children also developing it.
11) Last May, I wrote a column in the @mtlgazette, entitled, “Has Quebec abandoned those suffering from long COVID?” That column gave an estimate at the time of 30,000 Quebecers with the chronic affliction. montrealgazette.com/news/local-new…
12) It’s safe to assume that number has grown since then, which is probably one of the reasons why Dr. Boileau repeatedly emphasized long COVID during his appearance last Sunday on Tout le monde en parle, Quebec’s most-watched TV show. But what is long COVID, after all?
13) According to England's National Health Service, symptoms of long COVID include extreme fatigue, shortness of breath, chest pains, “brain fog,” insomnia, heart palpitations, dizziness, joint pain, rashes, anxiety, and tinnitus, among many others. nhs.uk/conditions/cor…
14) Still, there is so much that's not known about long COVID. But one thing is certain: in its current state, Quebec’s fragile health-care system may not be able to adequately treat this influx of patients in the years to come, contrary to Dr. Boileau's optimism. End of thread.
ADDENDUM: I'd like to refer you all to an excellent Twitter thread on #LongCovid from a couple of hours ago by Dr. Wesley Ely, sub-specialist in pulmonary critical care, laying out the impact of this chronic illness on the lungs.
1) Dr. Jordan Peterson (@jordanbpeterson), one of Canada’s preeminent intellectuals, cited a meta-analysis on Tuesday concluding that the average #COVID lockdown resulted in only a 0.2% reduction in mortality in Europe and in the U.S. Is that really true?
2) Given Peterson’s huge audience and his commitment to scientific rigour, it is worth stress-testing this meta-analysis that has appeared in Studies in Applied Economics. That would be part of the scientific method of open and fact-based debate.
3) It’s in that scientific tradition that I would like to report the reaction of various British scientists to this meta-analysis. Courtesy of sciencemediacentre.org, this is what Neil Ferguson, director of the MRC Centre for Global Infectious Disease Analysis, had to say:
1) At least two countries in the Northern Hemisphere – Ireland and Denmark – have started lifting #pandemic restrictions despite the more contagious #Omicron variant and the fact deaths are still rising in the latter. In this thread, I will examine the risks of lockdown fatigue.
2) First, though, let us focus on Quebec's latest #COVID death wave, which is stubbornly resisting to subside. In fact, the current wave has surpassed the wave last January, when Quebec still had a curfew in effect at this point in 2021. Please take a look at the chart below.
3) The Quebec government is wary to discuss this, but I submit it must be held accountable on this score. Most deaths are now occurring among Quebecers who were at least 70, who had been living at home, many of whom did not get their booster doses in time.
1) On Nov. 30, 2012, François Legault, as leader of the then-fledgling Coalition Avenir Québec, pronounced that he was “shocked” when he read a report by the province’s auditor-general on the poor quality of air in elementary schools back then. What has he done since about this?
2) Back in the fall of 2012, Legault was not in power. The Parti Québécois was, and the Liberals formed the official opposition. Still, Legault issued a news release in which he deplored the state of the province’s schools. See the press release below.
3) The auditor-general’s report to which Legault alluded was 50 pages long. The report mentions the word “ventilation” 48 times in those 50 pages. The report itself referred to other studies going back to the year 2000 calling for improved school ventilation. See below.
1) For the longest time, Montreal remained the epicenter of the #COVID19 pandemic in Quebec. But in a disturbing new development, the Indigenous-populated Far North of the province is now reporting the highest number of cases per capita.
2) In this thread, I will examine this new trend — one that probably deserves more attention by public health authorities. The Health Ministry chart below shows Nunavik and Terres-Cries-de-la-Baie-James now recording the highest #COVID incidence of any region in Quebec.
3) Perhaps this could be a perverse artifact reflecting much lower #COVID screening in the rest of the province. But the chart below prepared by the Cree community reveals a particularly low adult vaccination rate of 45% in Mistissini.
1) COVID deaths are again rising in the U.S. as mass vaccination of booster shots has stalled. In contrast, Quebec’s #pandemic wave of deaths is beginning to subside following a ramp-up in boosters in the adult population. In this thread, I will delve into these latest trends.
2) According to the latest analysis by the Institut national de santé publique, Quebec’s seven-day average of #COVID deaths per million population has decreased to 7 from 8.4 a week ago. By comparison, the rate in the U.S. climbed by 1.2 to 6.8 during the same period. See below.
3) The resurgence in #pandemic mortality in the United States follows a plateauing of booster shots administered there in recent weeks. Meanwhile, the chart below shows a steady increase in boosters given in Canada to counter the #Omicron variant.
1) Quebec’s new chief public health officer stunned the scientific world Thursday when he seemed to shrug off the precautionary principle and dismissed installing air purifiers in schools during the #pandemic. What key knowledge does Dr. Luc Boileau possess on this subject?
2) "We don’t have to deploy this equipment, which has not been shown in a school context to be a factor of improvement (in dealing) with COVID in particular,” Boileau said at a news conference. “There’s no demonstration on the scientific side.”
3) In this thread, I will draw your attention to what just a few other jurisdictions and scientific bodies have had to say about air purifiers in schools, each one applying the precautionary principle during the worst respiratory #pandemic since the 1918 Spanish Flu.