1/13 Thread on Russian reaction to #war with Ukraine
For years Russian legal and political system has been repressing the most active civic society leaders, those capable of gathering support for street activity. State adapted multitude of laws that penalize protests of any kind
Despite all that (details below) we are seeing massive protests all across the country for the second day in the row. That is both inspiring and astonishing. I would like this to be known and reported. That Russians showed their disagreement with what Putin does to Ukraine. 2/13
Here is a good explainer to what was done in 2021 alone in terms of adapting political system to a more war-like authoritarian rail ridl.io/en/one-year-in…
With first and by most elimination of the main opposition force - Navalny and his organization 3/13
Russian independent media been under fire from Putin since 2001, he always knew that independent media is his enemy. Again look at what was done in 2021 alone to make it even harder for Russian media to survive without gigantic fines and imprisonment 4/13 ridl.io/en/media-in-20…
Civil society organizations have been bothering Kremlin since at least 2004 and last decade it has been a non-stop slowly execute assault. 2021 so far proved to be the worst year for NGOs in Russia 4/13 ridl.io/en/the-worst-y…
Those who were too stubborn the state penalized; others, who agreed to fully play by the rules, were basically bought with state funding 6/13 ridl.io/en/not-only-th…
None of that means that Kremlin did not have a growing problem with legitimacy with how Russians view it. Repressions alone do not grant mass support, there is not enough $ to satisfy all. So 2022 was a struggle from afar. 7/13 ridl.io/en/authoritari…
But the bigger problem here is that Russians did not want war - as indicated by all latest polls, Moreover, they feared it with over 65% naming it as one of key fear 8/13 ridl.io/en/we-are-bein…
But the Kremlin mindset was departing from Russian reality for years. Their goals and aspirations had nothing to do with what society needed. It was all about history, might and glory 9/13 ridl.io/en/troubleshoo…
When this crisis began, I was among many who argued for more or less rational explanations. Leaving a full on war option as a possible but not likely version of event. Assessing deal on Ukraine and compromise with NATO will prevent a horrible outcome 10/13 ridl.io/en/will-russia…
I even dared to be optimistic for a while believe that diplomacy would solve this arguing "they can't be suicidal, right?" 11/13 ridl.io/en/the-drumrol…
I have been monitoring closely what Russian IR and foreign policy specialist were writing this past few months with one camp arguing for full on "tearing apart" the existing order. Turns out they were right - they represented what Putin believes. 12/13 ridl.io/en/too-proud-t…
On February 21st, right after Putin's speech I wrote this finally accepting the fact that war is the only way forward in the mindset of Russia's leader.
There is no rational component to this mindset. That scares me the most now. 13/13 ridl.io/en/putin-in-th…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
New Russian FP thinking is triumphing. It started taking root in 2014 and now it is finally celebrating its first major act - war on Ukraine.
Thread 1/5
One of the leading Valdai Club guys congratulates us with Russia's finally parting with Western centric world and starting its own journey.
He says for decades Russia used diplomacy but always failed since West didn't listen 2/5
He claims some time will pass and things will come down and Ukraine will be demilitarized and will get a new government and alike Belarus become Russia's close ally. Says if US attempts to increase military presence in CEE - Russia will respond and discourage. 3/5
My take for @RiddleRussia with a few takeaways on why February 21st will mark a new reality for Russian foreign policy for at least the next decade. Thread 1/7 ridl.io/en/putin-in-th…
The entire show: from Security Council meeting to Putin's speech to signing the documents was unprecedented. The level of humiliation of Putin's boyars and degree of his conspiracy theory driven motivation behind Russian FP stance is a new high 2/7
No longer can any Russian argue for a "smart" realpolitik justification or some other civilized version of Putin's actions: he made it clear it was about him not recognizing Ukraine and believing US wants to destroy Russia. 3/7
It seems Lukashenka still denies Russia a permanent military base but Russia is becoming more flexible. The ‘Union Resolve 2022′ is technically not an exercise by "test of the Union State’s response force". Regular Zapad Exercise are announced well in advance - this was just 2/8
announced 3 weeks before the start. Regular exercise count from 2500-3000 Russian participants, now the estimations go as high as 30,000. More conservatives estimates give 5k-7k personnel.
3/8
Karaganov here promotes emerging Russian discourse of "constructive destruction" of Western-centeric Russian foreign policy. In other words - practical steps towards multipolarity in the 21st century. Thread. 1/
Karaganov says Russia does not wish to war with anyone for now for as long as it is not threatened (taking Ukraine to the West is a threat). Basically, he says Russia needs to wait out until West finally gives up pretending that it is almighty and a deal would be made
Then Russia can rebuild its relations with the West to balance growing might of China.
Karaganov, unlike Kortunov for instance, claims Russia should abandon all attempts to play by the West's rule and invest in new rules of Greater Eurasia.
What will happen in Russia domestically in case Russia - US talks fail and major escalation is on its way. @Stanovaya here for @CarnegieRussia raises a number of important points. Thread 1/9
Naturally if the frontier is on fire, all the conservative forces would accelerate their efforts to secure the country from within with triple speed.
Obviously the first target would be the internet. 2/9
I can imagine a situation of a massive coordinated attack by Rozkomnadzor+ on foreign platforms with demands to ban "war propaganda" which could be anything and everything that Russia would be denying at the moment: failure to comply will lead to slowing down and blocking 3/9
1. Luzin asserts that you need to add defense spending to “National Security and Law Enforcement” budget spending to see a broader picture and it is that spending is on the rise since 2021 and will rise at least until 2024 after stabilization of 2017–2020. 2/12
Russia seems to have already entered a phase of long-term increase in spending. From the perspective of the Russian authorities, the need for such an increase is no longer closely linked to the overall growth rate of the economy. 3/12