Samuel Doveri Vesterbye Profile picture
May 20, 2022 20 tweets 13 min read Read on X
This week’s violence & protests in East #Tajikistan is happening because of existing & new social-economic, geo-political & historical dynamics.

[18-points🧵]

⏩ Historical context
⏩ Protest
⏩ Remittences & COVID
⏩ Geo-Afghanistan
⏩ Local expert & voices to follow

👇⬇️
Historical context: Tajikistan’s 🇹🇯 civil war lasted from 1992 until 1997. The Lali Badakhshan party (part of United Tajik Opposition) represented an important element of the East Tajikistan faction from the Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Region(GBOA) located in the Pamir area . . .
The GBOA in Eastern Tajikistan borders Afghanistan to the South, China to the East and Kyrgyzstan to the North and has long been supporting the rights and representation of ethnic minorities (Pamiris) in the country . . .
. . . At the time of the civil war, the United Tajik Opposition was a merger of convenience between secular, Islamic & democratic post-Soviet Tajiks, regional leaders, Taliban factions and ethnic minority groups seeking genuine rights and change (incl. Lali Badakhshan). . .
. . .The civil war ended in a truce coord. by Russia 🇷🇺. In 2000s, the balance of this ceasefire broke, as Tajik President cemented absolute power across country, in part due to strong US and (later) Russian support in Afghanistan invasion (logistics military, bases & funds) . .
Protests: During the past two decades, GBOA/East Tajikistan witnessed regular protests & eruptions of violence, notably in capital Khorog. These tensions are a complex mixture of opportunistic warlord interest mixed with Taliban-infused narco-trade & genuine civilian protest . .
. . .Tensions are also result of Pamir desire for political rights, as well as rapidly deteriorating socio-economic conditions & Russian-supported authoritarian repression from the centralised Dushanbe-government both in term of economic ownership/freedom of expression/media . .
In 2010 tensions in East flared up after multiple attacks, a prison escape & violent escalation between government and militants. These outbursts culminated in assassination of Tajikistan’s head of intelligence agency in 2012 followed by clashes with warlords linked to drugs . .
. . . In 2021 clashes also took place in Badakhshan when Tajik security forces fatally wounded Gulbiddin Ziyobekov, while locals protested the attack and demanded an investigation into his “arbitrary execution” caught on video (Guardian source) . . .
. . . The context of Tajikistan’s strategic geography & worsening economy are factors of importance when explaining protests/clashes. For an extended period of time, 25%+ of Afghanistan’s drug trade passed through Tajikistan while average income is 80€ a day in some region . . .
This weeks protests started around May 16 and now claim dozens of lives. Reports include serious clamp-down on Pamiris, including violent attacks on local & international media (RFE/Asia-Plus were closed/attacked in Khorog). GBOA is setting up an inquiry into 25+ deaths . . .
In Tajikistan, and particularly in GBOA, the Internet is regularly shut down, media censorship is high and families are reliant on development aid and remittances (labour migrants going to Russia) . . .
Remittances are the key since they have accounted for up to 33% of Tajikistan’s entire GDP, most of which comes from Russia. Since COVID the drop in remittances is estimated at 23%, while sanctions in Russia is worsening the situation . . .
According to @ENC_Europe 2021 study on labour migrants and vulnerable communities in Central Asia, including stateless people and ethnic minorities specially, the quantitative socio-economic worsening situation is affecting ethnic minorities the most . . .
According to our large scale quantitative and qualitative study on this issue: 74% of ethnic minorities in Tajikistan were reported as unemployed, which is nearly double compared to any other Central Asia Republics (internews.org/wp-content/upl…)
. . . The proximity of Afghanistan could also lead to spillover in terms of arms/drugs/foreign influence/Taliban. The nearby location of the Wakhan Corridor in South Tajikistan, which links Afghanistan and China, is a ticking time bomb that can further escalate violence . . .
. . . The protests are an extension of these social-economic realities, amplified by COVID & remittance decreases from Russia. The likelihood of continued unrest is high due to mixed demography, brutal clamp-down by the government and regional spillover (Afghanistan) . . .
⏩ EU Statement eeas.europa.eu/delegations/ta…
⏩ RFE article: rferl.org/a/tajikistan-g…
[END]
And @susile 👍🏼📚

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Samuel Doveri Vesterbye

Samuel Doveri Vesterbye Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SamuelJsdv

Apr 24
Everyone (including myself) is disappointed about last week's #EU 🇪🇺 Council #EUCO #Türkiye 🇹🇷 conclusions.

5️⃣-point 'real(ity)-politik-check'

🧵⤵️


Image
Image
Image
Image
1️⃣ Last week's #EUCO demonstrates a perfect case of the 🇪🇺 #EU reaching the lowest common denominator.

The statement (See image) recycles previous #EUCO wording and @JosepBorrellF's Joint-Communication 🇹🇷 from 2023. Its generic, reversible and dependent on #Cyprus 🇨🇾🇪🇺, which means its close-to-a-dead-end.

This has been described eloquently by longtime experts @NathalieTocci, @narisan61, @sinanulgen1 and others.

. . . (Continued)Image
2️⃣ Yet despite the "disappointing #EUCO results" two conclusions can be drawn:

First, the 🇪🇺🇹🇷 #EU-#Türkiye relationship seems too geo-politically-complex for the 🇪🇺 #EU to handle. The 🇪🇺 #EU doesnt have authority over core areas that are of utmost importance for key #EU Member States in dealing with 🇹🇷 #Türkiye like intelligence, defence and signifcant military-security fields linked to the #Caucasus, #Sahel, #Syria 🇸🇾, #Libya 🇱🇾 and other geo-strategic policies.

Second, a series of more quiet cross-country negotiations between #Türkiye 🇹🇷, #France 🇫🇷🇪🇺, #Germany 🇩🇪🇪🇺, #Cyprus 🇨🇾🇪🇺 and #Greece 🇬🇷🇪🇺 amongst others will likely gain more importance.

(Continued) . . .Image
Read 6 tweets
Apr 1
Yesterday #Türkiye 🇹🇷 witnessed a #CHP-opposition landslide in local elections.

But with a general election 4 years away, what does it mean?

5️⃣ socio-analytical points ⤵️


Image
Image
Image
Image
1️⃣ The results are historical.

The last time CHP (opposition) won nationwide was in 1977. With 90+% of the vote counted this morning it is certain that all major cities/metropolitan municipalities of #Turkiye 🇹🇷 have re-appointed CHP or switched away from AKP, including: Istanbul, Ankara, Bursa, Izmir, Adana, Antalya, Balıkesir, Manisa, Kütahya, Adıyaman, Amasya, Kırıkkale and Denizli.

CHP won 35 of Turkey's 81 provincial capitals. This is how all political parties performed nation-wide:¹

CHP  37.74% (Won 7.93%)
AKP 35.49%. (Lost 7%)
YRP 6.19% (Won 6.19%)
DEM 5.68% (Won 1.16%)
MHP 4.98% (Loss 2.46%)
IYI 3.77% (Loss 3.99%)

In practice, the government (Erdoğan's party and his ultra-nationalist alliance MHP) faced a big loss, while the other more pro-opposition nationalist party (IYI) also performed poorly while Aksener has stepped down. Same thing applies for the hardline anti-migration party Zafer Party. The real winners were the opposition, with CHP and Ekrem İmamoğlu in first place, followed by a small growth for Kurdish-ex-HDP party now known as DEM. The fastest - and very important - electoral rise came from ex-Refah party which is now known as the New Welfare Party (YRP). This party is run by the son of Necmettin Erbakhan, a much loved/hated² #Turkiye 🇹🇷 Prime Minister of the 1990s. YPR is a blend of very hardline religious views (e.g. close to anti-secular), ultra-nationalism (e.g. #Turkiye First Protectionism) and vehement anti-Israel 🇮🇱 views.

(Continued . . .)Image
Image
Image
Image
2️⃣ Municipal budget impact.

The landslide win for CHP at municipal levels across the country first and foremost means a significant increase in available funds for the opposition.

Out of the overall national tax collection, 2.85% goes to non-metropolitan municipalities, whereas 2.5% goes to district municipalities in metropolitan areas, 1.15% goes to special provincial administrations.

Metropolitan municipalities receive 5% of the taxes collected in their territory as well as 30% of the subsidies received by their district municipalities.³

In numbers: the budgets of #Istanbul Municipality is larger than some national Turkish ministries at €15.3 billion euros (516 billion Turkish Lira). #Ankara is in second biggest with a budget of €2.63 billion euro (92 billion Turkish Lira), while other major cities are within the multi-billion range, including #Antalya at €457 million euro (16 billion Turkish Lira).

An opposition victory of this calibre has a structural impact on funds, as described above. This will likely foster new dependencies, which can (grossly) be summarised as more money and campaign-capacity to CHP ahead of any future elections.

As a result, it is realistic to expect some disputes concerning how national and local funds are allocation/disbursed.

(Continued . . .)Image
Read 7 tweets
Jan 27
On this Monday (29th) and Tuesday (30th) the #GlobalGateway 💶🌐#InvestorForum is held in Brussels with signing of new partnerships & major funds for #EU-#CentralAsia 🇪🇺🇰🇿🇰🇬🇹🇯🇹🇲🇺🇿 ⤵️

🔹Geo-Economics?
🔹Why Central Asia?
🔹What Projects?
🔹What To Expect from Forum?

Full Article (20-thread) 🧵⤵️Image
Image
Image
Image
1⃣Introduction ⤵️

China’s 🇨🇳Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has long been viewed as an important source of investment and international connectivity.

Despite providing huge sums of money to willing-partner countries around the world, BRI now faces a string of undesirable consequences ranging from local discontent (e.g. pollution, land possession, and protests) to issues like low labor standards, debt, and non-inclusive growth.

To date, the most comprehensive and granular study of 13,427 Chinese development projects indicates widespread and unsustainable debt trends (e.g. 10% debt rates) at a time in which Beijing 🇨🇳is facing economic uncertainty.

. . .Image
2⃣ In parallel to the BRI story, the European Union (EU) 🇪🇺 has been rolling out its largest-ever foreign investment and infrastructure initiative, known as the Global Gateway🌐💶.

In typical #EU 🇪🇺fashion, this went more or less unnoticed, despite it being worth €300 billion, or the equivalent of #Portugal’s 🇵🇹entire annual Gross Domestic Product.

Since its inception in 2021-2022, #GlobalGateway has focused primarily on infrastructure, connectivity, and investments. It distinguishes itself from BRI by rooting all its funding in strict accountability, debt #sustainability, inclusive #growth, and #green transition.

In addition, it is legally tied to improved labor conditions, tech transfer, and fostering regional integration (e.g. ASEAN, CA), while constructing renewable and independent sources of energy. These concepts aim to give countries more autonomy, improved ownership, stability, and growth based on the #UN’s 🇺🇳 Sustainable Development Goals.

. . .Image
Read 19 tweets
Jul 2, 2023
‘#Turkey/#Türkiye 🇹🇷 in the New European Security Architecture’ is part of @EurLiberalForum’s annual security handbook.

🔟-point 🇪🇺🇹🇷 summary🧵below👇⤵️

*This publication is part of @ALDEParty’s think-tank which provides advise to 🇪🇺 liberal parties & politicians:… https://t.co/4vMFPpjUI2twitter.com/i/web/status/1…




1️⃣ Context: #EU & #Türkiye 🇪🇺🇹🇷 are extremely inter-dependent on one another (e.g. FDI, trade, supply-chains, CU, migration, corridor to Asia, energy transit, renewable needs, technology etc.). This is both well-documented and unavoidable in part due to the 1995/1996 Customs… https://t.co/1CfYHc3yjstwitter.com/i/web/status/1…


2️⃣ Theory: The ‘Weaponisation concept’ popularised by @markhleonard & @MarkGaleotti says that the 1990s-2000s tied the world together through globalisation and made everyone dependent on each other: institutions, finance, technology and many more sectors became internationally… https://t.co/pvlA9c6Vlltwitter.com/i/web/status/1…


Read 12 tweets
Jan 28, 2023
Why are #Azerbaijan #Iran 🇦🇿🇮🇷 relations so bad?

Five 5️⃣ simple facts 🧵 (below) help explain why the 🇦🇿🇮🇷 Azeri-Iranian relationship has deteriorated and what’s really behind the recent attack against 🇦🇿 Azerbaijan’s embassy in Tehran ⤵️ . . .
1️⃣ #Sociologically: Azerbaijan 🇦🇿 & Iran 🇮🇷 are very different societies. Iran’s regime has a hardline, old and extreme interpretation of Shia-religion, while Azerbaijan has a more modern interpretation (gender parity, customs etc). It lay at the root of many differences . . .
2️⃣ #Historically: Iran (& Russia) colonised Azeri and South Caucasian people, while today large Azeri communities continue to live inside of Iran, many of which have strong linguistic and cultural bonds to Azerbaijan and do not accept Tehran’s radical governance-style . . .
Read 11 tweets
Nov 17, 2022
“The Ottomans’ relationship with the Crimean Khans is fascinating” (Quataert, 2005, Ottoman Empire 1700-1922) ⤵️

Why does #Turkey 🇹🇷 defend #Ukraine 🇺🇦 ? Why does Turkey reject #Russia’s 🇷🇺 occupation of #Crimea?

[6-point historical thread 📚🧵] ⤵️
1️⃣ Crimean Khans are “. . . descendants of the Golden Horde (Mongols of Lake Baykal) and vassals of the Ottoman sultans from 1475 until 1774, when that tie was (temporarily) severed as a prelude to their annexation and occupation by 🇷🇺 Czarist state in 1783” . . .
2️⃣ The maternal grandfather of Sultan Süleyman I (Magnificent) is believed to have been Chrimean Mengili I Giray. This helps explain why 16th Century Ottomans allowed for the Khan of Crimean Tatars to potentially succeed an Ottoman dynasty in case of no male heir . . .
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(