ET Money Profile picture
Mar 3 9 tweets 4 min read
#SIP or lumpsum - Which is better?

Probably, most people will vote in favour of SIP.

But, that’s not entirely true.

On many occasions, lumpsum has given better results than SIP.

So, where do you make higher returns?

We analysed the data. Here’s what we found.

A 🧵
We compared SIP and lumpsum returns in #nifty50 over different time horizons.

Consider this example

One person invested Rs 6 lakh 10 years ago.

Another one starts a monthly SIP of Rs 5,000 at the same time (5,000 X 120 months).

Who earns better returns?
What did we find?

The results were mixed.

Of the 14 different periods we checked, SIP did better 7 times.

Lumpsum offered a better rate of return on 7 occasions.

Check the table below to see the findings.
What is the takeaway from this exercise?

SIP and lumpsum are merely methods of investing.

One doesn’t guarantee better returns over the other.

In fact, if you have the #money, it’s better to go for the lumpsum route.

Why? Because you can create a bigger corpus.

Check how 👇
Let’s continue with the same example.

But this time, we won’t just check the rate of return.

We’ll check the final value of the #investment.

Check the table to see how much extra corpus you can create if you invest in lumpsum as against SIPs.
In all scenarios, the end corpus is higher in the lumpsum method.

And this was for obvious reasons.

Why is that, you ask?

In the lumpsum, you start with a much bigger amount which gets more time to compound.
Some #investors are of the view that if you have a large corpus, you should split it into 6 equal monthly installments.

However, this is not a foolproof method.

It may or may not give you better returns, as it all depends on the market movements.
Here’s the summary.

If you have the money, don’t shy away from lumpsum investments.

Your money is better off in equities than in your #bank account in the long term.

And if you have a regular #income & want to gradually create a bigger corpus, there’s no better way than SIP.
We put a lot of effort into creating such informative threads.

So, if you find this useful, show some love. ❤️

Please like, share, and retweet the first tweet.

For more threads, follow us.

Also, click on the bell icon in the profile section, so you don't miss any threads🔔

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with ET Money

ET Money Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ETMONEY

Mar 1
#SBI Mutual Fund has launched a Dividend Yield Fund.

While you must avoid new funds, we thought it’s a good time to look at the Dividend Yield category.

This category has outperformed many equity #schemes (See table)

But should you invest in these funds?

Let’s evaluate.

A 🧵 Image
First, some basics about these funds.

As per definition, Dividend Yield funds must invest at least 65% of their corpus in high dividend-paying companies.

Currently, there are eight funds in this category.

Together, they manage over Rs 10,200 crore. Image
How do these funds define high dividend-paying stocks?

Different funds define it differently(see table)

Nonetheless, they don’t have any restrictions for picking stocks from different sectors or market caps.
Probably, that’s why #NIFTY 500 TRI is the benchmark for most funds. Image
Read 13 tweets
Feb 24
A simple hack helps you save tax on #stocks and #mutualfunds.

Here’s what you do:

- Sell your investments
- Book profits & losses
- Repurchase immediately

This is called Tax Harvesting

A 🧵on how it’s done.
Let’s first talk about the #tax on #equities.

The profit you book is divided into two buckets.

1. Shot term: If you sell within one year (of purchase)
2. Long-term: If you sell after one year

You pay a higher tax for short-term profits and lower for long-term (Check table)
Now, let’s jump to the sweet part - how to reduce taxes?

You pay LTCG tax only when your gains exceed Rs 1 lakh.

So the trick is not to let your gains go beyond this tax-free limit.

How to do it? Sell a part of your gains to book LTCG and reinvest it.

An example will help.👇
Read 14 tweets
Feb 22
.@NipponIndiaMF Small Cap is the biggest fund in its category.

There’s a good reason why investors rushed to invest money in it.

Since the fund started, it has consistently beaten the benchmark by a wide margin (See graph 👇).

Let’s look at its performance and strategy.

A 🧵 Image
Let’s dive deeper into its performance first.

Nippon India Small Cap has a stellar record against its peers, too.

After SBI Small Cap, it’s the second-best fund in the small-cap category when we look at the 5-year rolling returns since 2010. (check image 👇) Image
The fund has a good track record of protecting investors’ downside.

Since its launch, the benchmark has seen negative returns in 19 quarters. The fund has fared better in 18 of them.

Against the category average, it has done better in 10 out of 18 quarters.
Read 12 tweets
Jan 24
Small cap funds are supposed to be volatile.

But @AxisMutualFund Small Cap is an exception.

In 11 quarters when its category was in red, the fund fell less in each one of them.

In fact, there were 3 quarters when the fund beat its peers by 20% (points).

A 🧵on its strategy. Image
Let’s start with its performance.

After @quantmutual Small Cap, Axis Small Cap has been the 2nd best-performing small-cap fund in the last 5 years

Axis Small Cap has beaten its category considerably.

Here are its 5-year returns:

Axis Small Cap: 18.4%
Category Average: 12.5%
Similar outperformance is seen against its benchmark.

Since its inception (Nov 2013), the fund has delivered an SIP return of 21.5%.

Its benchmark #return is 14.5%.

Here’s how a Rs 10,000 SIP would look since the fund’s inception:

Fund: Rs 30.1 lakh
Benchmark: Rs 21.5 lakh
Read 9 tweets
Jan 3
Direct Plans in #mutualfunds completed 10 years on January 1, 2023.

These plans don’t include commissions, and hence you earn more.

But how much more?

We crunched SIP and Lumpsum data for the past decade to figure it out.

The results are surprising.

A thread 🧵
Let’s begin with some numbers.

Say you chose 3 schemes – an equity, a debt, and a hybrid fund.

You have a monthly SIP of Rs 10,000 each in these schemes for a decade.

👉 Your excess returns are Rs 5.4 lakh (or 6.4%) more than the regular plan.
The trend is similar for lumpsum investments.

Say you invested Rs 5 lakh at once in direct plans of each of these 3 schemes.

Total lumpsum amount = Rs 15 lakh

In this case, the corpus would be bigger by Rs 7.9 lakh (or 10.3%).

Check image ⬇️ Image
Read 13 tweets
Dec 29, 2022
Many purchase a traditional life insurance policy and regret later.

The problem: Such plans don’t offer adequate life cover and returns are lower than bank fixed deposits.

What’s your way out once you commit the mistake?

Should you surrender it or continue?🤔

A thread🧵
Depending on the period of holding and terms of policy, you have two options:

1. Convert it into a ‘paid-up’ plan
2. Surrender

Each option may make sense at different points.

Let’s understand them in detail with examples ⬇️
1. Paid-up plan

What is it?

The policyholder stops paying premiums, but the policy remains active.

Also, the insured continues to get reduced insurance coverage and earn some returns.
Read 16 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(