With Justice KM Joseph not being a part of the bench today, sr adv Sanjay Hegde asks if the old bench will be back or the matter will need to be argued all over again. SG Mehta objects to a lawyer questioning bench's composition
A lawyer seeks to appear on behalf of @SanjeevSanskrit & intervene in the case since he was a panelist on a show on #UPSC-Jihad & his comments were mentioned during a previous hearing.
But Chandrachud J replies: "You keep appearing on TV shows only. You don't have to be here."
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The reply alleges an insidious propaganda by political parties, a section of media to malign the Yogi Govt despite a "diligent probe".
This affidavit claims political parties, a section of media is trying to give a communal & casteist colour to #Hathras incident & hence, the #SupremeCourt should monitor the #CBI probe in a time bound manner. This will ensure a free probe besides weeding out false narratives.
About the midnight cremation of the #Hathras victim, UP Govt says she was cremated in the presence of her family members, who agreed to attend in order to prevent further violence. Affidavit adds it was done to maintain law & order.
#Delhi High Court is hearing a petition by actor #RakulPreetSingh against tirade of charges against & 'fake news' against her.
Her lawyer submits she was called as a witness by #NCB & didn't implicate anyone.
"I am a non-smoker, a teetotaller, never did drugs. I have been replaced in a short film because of all this. My reputation is in tatters. All news channels are airing unsubstantiated charges": #RakulPreetSingh to High Court.
ASG Chetan Sharma, for Govt, says she is not an accused as on date & he sympathises with her. "But any observations by this court at this juncture may have a ripple effect. This is a sensitive case."
But HC tells him there has to be some balance, I&B should question channels.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta informs the bench that the channel has now been issued a show vase notice under the Cable TV Act.
SG suggests #SupremeCourt may defer these proceedings till the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting takes a final decision on the show cause notice to #SudarshanTV.
Chandrachud J: We will see about that later
While Mehta points out #SudarshanTV has been given time till Sep 28 to respond, the bench retorts that had the SC not intervened, all 10 episodes would have been telecast.
Ms Alam now commences her submissions against the broadcaster.
Sr adv Harish Salve begins arguing for the petitioners.
The bench seeks to know where is the threat issued by the #Delhi Assembly Peace & Harmony Committee.
Salve takes the bench to the relevant page in the petition.
"This is quite remarkable. Who is this deputy secretary issuing this serious threat. What privilege, whose privilege?" Salve submits before the bench headed by Justice Sanjay K Kaul.
I am an outsider. I am nit interrupting proceedings of your committee. Whether I can be asked to appear or not is for somebody to decide. But if I don't want to appear in a matter that has political overtones. I don't want to come in middle of this. Can I be compelled?: Salve
#SudarshanNews matter commences in #SupremeCourt with sr Adv Mukul Rohatgi mentioning he is appearing for NBF (National Broadcasters' Federation).
Rohatgi informs NBF is the largest body of channels in India, having majority of regional channels as its members. He adds NBF wants to put its views forth on regulations relating to TV channels. Former CJI KS Khehar has agreed to be a part of the NBF's self-regulatory body.
The application contends #SupremeCourt doesn't have jurisdiction to frame guidelines. He adds there are over 1000 reports how media has been reporting about religious issues.