Jon Worth Profile picture
16 Nov, 6 tweets, 1 min read
This week, just has been the case for the past 2 months or so:

EU to UK - this is broadly what we would need to do a Deal. EU stands together on this. A little room for changes at the margin, but take it or leave it.

UK to EU - ummm, ahh, sovereignty, no ratchet clauses, fish.
And sorry, yes, this is flippant. In reality at the working level, there has been a bit of progress, but the central issues are as they've been for ages.

Is the EU intransigent here? A little. But it knows what it cannot compromise on. And it's much bigger than UK is.
The EU essentially knows it can survive No Deal better than the UK can. That its economy will take a lesser hit, and populations in the Member States will not blame the EU but will point the finger at Johnson.
The UK meanwhile, if it believed its own public rhetoric, ought to have walked away already - but it hasn't, because it doesn't (or not completely anyway). This isn't Frost's fault, but Johnson's.
The pros and cons of a deal are known.

How much the EU can move it pretty well known.

So UK Government - basically Johnson - make up your mind and stop prevaricating.

/ends
(Oh and No Deal is not a permanent state anyway - it's a question of how many months of chaos the UK wants to have after 1 Jan.)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jon Worth

Jon Worth Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @jonworth

18 Nov
The logic of No Deal for Johnson

A thread
When the transition period ends in 6 weeks, the UK can move to a thin trade Deal with the EU, or No Deal

Both options are practically fraught
Even a Deal comes with some disruption - especially at Dover. And businesses have to cope with the headaches of leaving the Single Market and the Customs Union

No Deal is all of that, plus tariffs
Read 12 tweets
16 Nov
My timeline is full of earnest think tankers saying thinks along the lines of "Boris Johnson wants a Deal because he wants a success" and "Business / the economy wants a Deal, so Johnson does"

I am really far from sure this is the case

Here's why
A slightly more structured way to put it is as follows:

Boris Johnson wants success
Boris Johnson is Prime Minister
Prime Ministers are considered successful by doing the right thing for the country's economy
A Deal is better for the economy

= Johnson will aim for Deal
But this does not hold

The changes to the WA, and the NI Protocol, that Johnson agreed last year were *more damaging* to the economy than May's Deal

Hard Brexit that Johnson has long advocated is more damaging to the economy than a Soft Brexit
Read 13 tweets
13 Nov
That Johnson - backed by Symonds, and having appointed Stratton - is trying to shape Number 10 for the medium term makes some sense.

And Cain and Cummings going will soothe relations with Tory MPs.
But there are a slew of problems.

First, a decision on Brexit is still needed. A mess in January will happen in any case. It will be even bleaker for Number 10 in a few months than now.

Second, Corona is still not in check - more Tory MPs will rebel if there are more lockdowns
Third, all this heavily briefed new found focus by Johnson on environmental issues - that’s likely a red rag to a bull for Tory backbenchers

Fourth, Cummings gave Johnson protection and some structure. Who will give him that now?
Read 4 tweets
12 Nov
Look, please don't interpret the Cain stuff to some grand plan or foresight or Biden or whatever big trend

Number 10 has two major problems:
- a PM who can't take decisions or structure things
- macho egos
It seems to have all gone like this:
- Number 10 press and comms are a mess
- Johnson likes US system where a spokeperson briefs the press, on the record
- Johnson wants to appoint someone
- Cain wants a lackey, someone suggests Allegra Stratton, and she's a pro. Oddly she wins
- Cain wants Stratton to be answerable to him, she refuses
- Johnson doesn't know what to do, tries to shift Cain upwards to a chief of staff position, unaware how much Cain is hated - even by his own fiancé
- backlash is so strong Johnson can't appoint Cain, so he goes instead
Read 4 tweets
11 Nov
OK, time for a deep breath

There is a new #BrexitDiagram Series 5, V6.0.0 - the first for a month! Which itself is interesting, and shows how little things have moved...

But with the Lords vote on the IM Bill clauses behind us, here is where we stand I think
Headline numbers
(compared with V5.0.0, 30.09.2020)

No Deal at end of the year - 43% (⬇️ 13%)
Deal by end of year - 44% (⬆️ 11%)
Lack of clarity / something else - 13% (⬆️ 2%)
This needs some unpacking

Above all the *order* of what happens next is now crucial - the House of Lords will only conclude on the Internal Market Bill right at the end of November, or early December - so the Frost-Barnier negotiations are now the only show that matters
Read 9 tweets
11 Nov
Let's conduct a little thought experiment for a moment

If mainstream Westminster opinion *is* right, and Johnson agrees some kind of Brexit Deal between now and the end of next week...

And this Deal has commitments on level playing field and governance that Tories don't like...
Then what?

Because the House of Commons does not have a formal vote on the Deal (see this from @matt_bevington ukandeu.ac.uk/explainers/rat… ), what lever have Tory hardliners got?
Do they grumble and fill our airwaves with effluent?

Or do they rebel more forcefully?

The only route I see is they could write letters of no confidence in Johnson to the 1922 Committee... but 55 letters are needed to trigger a contest. That's surely not going to be reached?
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!