Schools or Partying?

On 12/11 coronavirus cases spiked to 33k cases, it remains the only day where over 30k have been reported...

But the partying narrative is part of the agenda to keep schools open 'at all costs'

Please read on, it's going to take c. 10 min to post...

1/
2/

We know .gov have been pushing journalists to infer its was due to pre-lockdown partying

For example @nicktriggle's piece from 16/11, but this appears to be lazy journalism.

3/

If we look at data y swab date, a more worrying picture emerges.

We can clearly see there are TWO days with more than 30k cases.

The first and highest on record is actually 2/11. This is the Monday after #lockdown2 was announced.
4/

👆

These cases were caught around 5 days before the announcement.

So, not partying.
5/

Now look at the pattern emerging.

The first schools on half term (Nottingham, Scotland, Kent) returned on 26/10

There was a spike in cases that day

The rest of the country returned on 2/11

There was a spike on that day – and it’s the highest number of cases on record
6/

There appear to be spikes on every Monday since half term. Could this be a sign schools are driving the epidemic?

We know that 80% plus adults don’t isolate when they should.

And evidence parents send children into school when ill:

7/

There are 9 days over HT & 3 over a weekend

Days where symptoms can start showing

So expect a bump in cases where children arrive at school on a Monday looking sickly and get sent for a test

That bump might be more pronounced after half term – more days to show symptoms
8/

But there would also need to be evidence that children are driving infections.

More than 23% of cases are linked to schools:

9/

Latest @ONS data shows rates in Y7-Y11 are the highest of all ages:



Bear in mind that children being the key driver, or a community reservoir, will raise the average, keeping cases high

.gov really are keeping the schools open at all costs.
10/

Why do I care so much?

Many reasons:

-there is massive disruption to education that could have been planned around

-having a reservoir of cases in the community sustains the UK epidemic

-.gov seems to be lying just to keep schools open and trashing other sectors
11/

As well as @NEUnion, @NASUWT & @EISUnion, many organisations should be shouting down a government obsessed with keeping schools open at all costs.

Just so they don’t cost @GavinWilliamson his career.

@cbicarolyn
@theflva
@nhbfsocial
@_ukactive
12/

Oh, also a bit of self-interest

I am clinically extremely vulnerable & live in a Tier 3 area

I am expected back in a classroom with shoulder to shoulder teens, but I am banned from wearing a mask

@matthancock appears to want to cull me



Bastard.
13/

@Channel4News
@BBCNews
@BBCHughPym
@Independent

Many of us would like to see balanced coverage of the schools issue.

Look at the work @SarahDRasmussen did - calling out @ons for distorting figures.

By the time UK Stats Authority rule it will be too late.
14/

Have a look at the data.

Have a look at the threads referenced.

Ask yourself if you agree.

If you do please re-tweet the first tweet in this thread, perhaps with a comment to encourage others to read.

Thank you.

(end)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Concerned of Bristol

Concerned of Bristol Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ConcernedofBri1

27 Nov
@KatharineDC Here's an example of why @BBCNews is gaining a reputation for bias

Bias is a subtle tool

Either lazy journalism means the writer missed Y7-11 have the most cases of any age (>2%) or they were trying to create the impression of a problem that is overhyped

Bias

1/ Image
2/

Relatively few is wrong

Look at @ONS data: you see only 6th Form - 24 even come close to 2%

NB: These @ONS demographics seem to carry bias too

Why not count all school children?

ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulati…

Look at the Half Term Dips in Y12 - 24!

Universities don’t have HT…
3/

Perhaps the author tried to convey something else & failed

No idea how you would analyse this, but maybe more isolations do occur in students relative to adults who test positive

But this is a symptom of the problem 👇
Read 7 tweets
27 Oct
1/

.@DogLady2020 I just checked back in on the prediction from 21 days ago & the 7 day average is 200 deaths per day

😖

Third time in a row I have been a bit under (181 yesterday, then we had catch up Monday) but a reasonable prediction for 14/11 is 300 - 400 deaths a day

😬
2/

Previous estimates have been based on the 7 day average of cases reported.

Shifting to 7 day average of cases by swab date gives an expected average of 206 deaths/day today - spookily accurate.

WARNING: We don't know the average yet as swab date lags by c. 4 days
3/

We are on day 57 👆

Looking at another measure - the log of cases reported so far 👇 you can see the orange line (deaths by date of death) is higher than the rolling average reported (blue)

This is because fatalities are rising - but note the last 5 days are unreliable
Read 11 tweets
21 Oct
@adamhamdy It looks very much like schools are being used to drive this by the back door.

A bit more thinking to do about 👇

It shows %age rise in 7 day average across UK but you can clearly see spikes a week after schools went back in different regions, then unis

(1/n)
@adamhamdy 2/n

From last night's press conference @BorisJohnson seems to think we just need to try a bit harder to follow rules

However, since mid-July there have been around 15% extra cases each week

This seems to have jumped to more like 25% as schools returned

@adamhamdy @BorisJohnson 3/n

The large spike at the end encompasses two things:

-case backlog being added
-uni return

BUT we seem to have rebounded to around 25% extra cases each week again (early days)

Importantly, it's unclear how much of the sharp fall is unis dealing with 'their virus'
Read 8 tweets
20 Oct
Two things we learned from @BorisJohnson

1. He doesn't understand how infection numbers reduce

"unis did a great job of getting their virus under control"

If true, they did it by locking students in their halls...

🤦‍♀️🤥

#COVID19

2. He doesn't really get exponential growth.

Apparently the R is only a bit above 1 so it's all okay.

It's around 1.3 to 1.5, higher than the lead into this debacle from mid August on. So numbers not going south yet.

🤦‍♀️🤬

Both bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-5…
17.54pm

(2/3)
(3/3)

There is a great primer on exponential growth here:



Please watch it.

More importantly, please get friends, journalists and politicians to watch too.

#JonathanVanTam #JVT said deaths baked in for 3 weeks.

You can expect 160-320 on 11/11 😰
Read 4 tweets
19 Oct
.@WelshGovernment appears to believe older children higher transmission risk for #COVID19

@educationgovuk guidance last updated 1/10 doesn't mitigate this or aerosol transmission- clear its schools' job to assess

🤔

Squeaky bum time for school leaders

gov.uk/government/pub… ImageImageImage
Because Government #dontmentiontheschools you mightn't have noticed 👆

As any of the people below will remind you, @NAHTnews @ASCL_UK @SchoolGovNet @SchoolGov are responsible for school H&S:

@HoppySaul
@adamhamdy
@EdnaKrabapple1
@paysupplystaff
@Kateliveco1G

😷
Expand below to compare over 3 weeks

Year 7-11 children consistently 2nd highest group & still on exponential increase, while unis seem to be getting on top of their outbreaks

Now 1% of secondary children infected with #COVID19

@adamhamdy @ToryFibs: herd immunity by backdoor? Image
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!