What is the reality of living on a PhD stipend for disabled/chronically ill students?
A long thread 1/18
Living on a stipend looked like turning down care, leaving meds at the pharmacy counter, prioitizing some health needs above others. It looks like losing countless hours to phone calls with hospital financing and insurance companies. It looks like refusing to go to the ER 2/18
I wonder all the time if it was worth it to lose doctors, care networks, and treatment options all to go to a top ranking program. In terms of income? No. In terms of benefits? No. In terms of future career options? No. 3/18
I loved pursuing history and disability studies in higher education. I felt so lucky to have the time to read and write and think. I have been so lucky to receive fellowship support. I've been lucky in every single area. 4/18
I've had a kind cohort, caring professors, a supportive advisor, and substantial fellowship support. The problem is that supportive people do not balance out systemic barriers. Those people couldn't grant me medical care or treatment or affordable options. 5/18
I don't have any horror stories from graduate school. And yet it was still a traumatic experience. I still gaslit myself the whole time. Every day was an "if I can just..." kind of day. If I can just work part time I can maybe afford my meds. 6/18
If I can just make more money I can afford an accessible apartment. If I can just get this fellowship I can move to a place with better doctors. If I can just get travel funding I can visit home for care. 7/18
But the reality is that I lived in an inaccessible apartment for five years. Because fellowship support is great, but doesn't pay for accessibility. The reality is that I often left CVS crying while the pharmacist asked me if I knew about good RX. 8/18
The reality is that I drove around campus endlessly looking for handicapped parking spots. And often had to walk far distances with tons of course materials because I hadn't beaten out other disabled people for one of the two spots available in my part of campus. 9/18
The reality is that I struggled with a lack of flexible deadlines in coursework. I struggled with access needs at conferences. I found out that there are no accommodations when it comes to historical field work or archival research. 10/18
Throughout the whole process it was up to me to know what I needed and to advocate for it. And I like to think that I'm a specialist in just that. I've read Universal Design for Learning materials, I've done DEI for a decade now. I have advocated for myself for forever. 11/18
But when you ask a first gen student to advocate for themselves in a system that is totally foreign to them, you will fail that student. That is my lived reality. That no one around me knew what to offer, and I didn't know what to ask for. 12/18
I'm wrapping up for defense now. And hopefully I'll have the courage to document these barriers. To speak candidly. To those who remain in the academy - I hope you can do better for your students. And to students currently struggling - I hope you know this isn't on you. 13/18
I had all the privileges of a top program, a medical school on campus, and a competitive funding package. And at the end of it all, the pro/con list is not balanced. For me, it was a poor investment to leverage my health for a chance to be a part of this system. 14/18
I'm so proud of what I've done. What I've written and created and produced. But I have produced it in the face of entirely unaddressed barriers. And that is my major issue with the #PhD. No one ever took responsibility for my living conditions or my well-being. 15/18
I was supposed to accept these conditions for the chance to be a part of higher ed. It was no one's responsibility to change student health care or demand funding cap increases or to make sure I had an accessible living space. And so I fought and failed alone. 16/18
I want graduate programs to take responsibility. I want profs who benefit from grad labor to question whether it's ethical at all to continue taking students. I want to reimagine programs where the conditions are supportive and even competitive. 17/18
I can't recommend grad school to any disabled or chronically ill student. It's not sustainable unless you have other sources of income or healthcare. Don't gamble your well-being in a system that will exploit you. 18/18 #AcademicChatter#PhDChat#PhDLife#Disability
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
To everyone in #highered acknowledging that the pandemic has put undue stress on students and our expectations need to change - that is how disabled students feel fighting systemic ableism on campus every single term. 1/5
The precarity of being disabled in the academy is especially high for those undiagnosed or seeking a dx as they cannot access formal accommodations without a doctor's recommendation. And yet we often expect them to perform perfectly with no support. 2/5
Universal Design for Learning matters. It can help remove SOME barriers to access for students struggling to secure medical care, accommodations, and belonging on campus. We cannot expect students to perform well while coping with trauma. 3/5
During graduate school I worked a second job as an RA, compensated at $20 an hour with flexible hours. Without that pay I would not have been able to 1. Buy safe allergen free groceries 2. Pay for a car, which I needed for accessible transportation 3. Afford medical care 1/4
I also worked as a research assistant in undergrad, and I made more than $10 an hour back then. When you purposefully pay students low wages you bar first gen students from the field. And you most definitely bar disabled students from the field. 2/4
If you want us there to support diversity measures, pay us wages we can survive on. Disabled students graduate with far more student debt on avg bc they take longer to degree (bc they've been refused accommodations). Why would you brag about making it more inaccessible? 3/4
I hope all profs realize that your chronically ill students are not doing well right now. My hospital is so focused on vaccination and COVID that important tests (one to measure if I'm digesting food, the other to see if I'm getting proper blood flow to my brain) 1/4
Have been scheduled for July. So I'm finishing my dissertation while pretty sick without some vital organs working. And my meds for these issues have been on prior authorization for over a month bc the pharmacy is also trying to figure out vaccination and bc insurance sucks. 2/4
Your chronically ill students aren't getting their normal care. And some may not be able to afford their normal care routines right now bc of the pandemic. The healthcare crisis extends far beyond COVID-19 itself. 3/4
I'm tired of hearing "well people are uncomfortable with disability bc they're not exposed to disabled ppl." If disability matters then invest in us. Make it a point to hire us. Make it a point to give us platforms. 1/7
There are so many of us wedged out of the academy from undergrad to grad school and beyond. So many of us who are highly qualified to teach in disability studies related fields. So many of us that WOULD expose students to disabled scholars/mentors/advocates. 2/7
Fight to add Disability Studies departments, minors, and majors at your university. It infuriates me that roughly 20 percent of undergrads are disabled and they don't get to learn about their culture, history, or people. If I had taken #DisHist and #DisabilityStudies courses 3/7
I can't begin to explain the amount of anxiety and backtracking that I have experienced when I moved for grad school and I lost a whole team of doctors. Doctors who had helped me make sense of my comorbid conditions for 8 years. 1/10
I lost them because I had the audacity to move for graduate school to a part of the country that BCBS New England did not cover. So I started the hunt again. But it was both unaffordable and a waste of time. I needed a GI, cardio, allergist, neurologist, PCP, and PT. 2/10
I was able to get a cardiologist because of an emergency room trip and referral. I wasn't able to find anyone else who treated my conditions at my uni. And I thought fine, I can make do as I did in undergrad by going on Christmas break and summer break back home for care. 3/10
I mentioned I was looking into DEI jobs and a colleague told me "burn out in those jobs is like two years."
I've been in the academy for 10 years as a disabled academic. I hate the term burn out. It doesn't convey the reality that disabled scholars face - discrimination. 1/4
It's about advocating for yourself and others and being told to your face that your needs don't matter and you're not worth the cost. I hate the term "burn out." Let's not use a vague phrase for something far more underhanded and harmful. 2/4
I'm tired of promoting my humanity in the face of a capitalist society that tells me my needs are too expensive so I don't deserve shit. But I don't have the choice to do DEI work. I already have to do that work just to survive in the academy. 3/4