🧵1/ So when I was writing out this thread, I realized that public health vaccination efforts have a big messaging problem!*

[* my response actually branches off into two different threads starting after Tweet 3 - sorry!]
🧵2/ I wrote about the goal of widespread vaccination from a public health perspective...
🧵3/ ...versus the goal of vaccination from a medical perspective
🧵4/ The medical perspective is like blowing up the Death Star. Big show of force to dramatically neutralize the threat...
🧵5/ ... but letting remnants of the Empire like Moff Gideon survive and bounce around the edges of the galaxy plotting The Empire’s resurgence
🧵6/ A public health response to #COVID19 is more ruthless. We plan to troll the far reaches of the universe to hunt down every last one of them
🧵 7/ Personally, I hate #COVID19. I want it gone forever...
🧵8/ I want there to be a @housetv reboot in 2041. And I want House to scoff at the new overeager book-smart resident who suggests #COVID19 as a possible diagnosis. “The only problem is that the #SARSCoV2 virus was eradicated 18 years ago.”
🧵9/ ok, I can tell from the responses from very smart people that my own attempt to speak beyond the extent of my expertise is failing! 😂
🧵10/ My big point is that I’m worried some folks will decide we are done and life is back to normal when we getting to 50% vaccination and they are personally pretty safe from #COVID19 risk.
🧵11/ That will mean continued localized outbreaks for years and #LongCovid misery for lots of folks even if low rates of death.
🧵12/ To have the best chance of getting out of this, I think we need to envision that we are in a new stage: an all-out push to tamp the virus down as quickly and mercilessly as we can stand.
🧵13/ So it’s not normal. But it’s not March 2020 either.
🧵 14/ But this is unprecedented, and it makes sense that people want guidance & a path forward. I think the Biden administration is trying to fill this void in a national vision by focusing on vaccination and in-person schooling.
🧵15/ And it’s going to be contentious. I think public health people largely agree that we need to keep pushing forward with vaccination and strategic mitigation, that the sacrifices now will pay dividends in the years to come.
🧵 16/ but yeah, we disagree around the edges. What specific mitigation strategies should be pursued and where and to what extent? These are live questions that people are watching get hashed out in real-time.
🧵17/ As a scientist, it’s compelling and vital. But as a person who is beat down by the worst year of my life, yeah, I can see how it’s tedious and frustrating. But I truly believe we are close to collective relief.
🧵18/ Even the Rebels disagreed on strategy sometimes. But I just don’t want Moff Gideon to get away when we are so close to cutting off his resources. (Ok, I’ve taken the #starwars reference way too far)
🧵19/ And now the #ID #epitwitter folks can school me on all the concepts I got wrong! 🤦🏾‍♀️ I welcome it. I’m here to learn, just like the rest of you.
20/ And, yes, this kind of stuff does give me pause... But also makes me want to crush this virus even faster and harder.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Whitney R. Robinson

Whitney R. Robinson Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @WhitneyEpi

22 Mar
🧵1/ How one epidemiologist decided to keep sending her children to in-person group childcare during a pandemic, and what happened
🧵2/ The most consequential and difficult decision I made in March 2020, near the beginning of the US #COVID19 outbreak, was whether to keep sending my then 5-yo and 1-yo to in-person group childcare
🧵3/ I’m reflecting on this here because 1) Personal stories help me make better decisions & maybe it'll help others; 2) I think I can bring context, nuance, and compassion to a conversation that gravitates towards extremes, absolutes, and vilification
Read 34 tweets
8 Mar
I’m listening to informative new episode of @inthebubblepod.

It’s about Israel’s vaccination effort and early observational evidence of its effects. As always, it’s complicated. But much good news.

pca.st/podcast/710d44…
2/ Vaccines working great to prevent hospitalization among those vaccinated and strong evidence that vaccinated people much less likely to transmit virus...
3/ but big outstanding issues about “vaccine hesitancy” in minority populations (ultra-Orthodox, Israeli Arab), ethical issues with vaccine passports (govt proof of vaccination required to participate in certain activities of daily life)...
Read 6 tweets
4 Mar
🧵 1/ @TamaraSurin’s smart (and *very* generous) take on recent @JAMA_current podcast on “structural racism”...
🧵 2/ Now here’s my take: I believe that the host, JAMA editor Edward Livingston, inadvertently makes a strong argument against his own thesis!
🧵3/ Dr. Livingston argues that using the word “racism” is counterproductive for addressing “very real” “structural problems in our society”
Read 23 tweets
25 Feb
I’m tired

In December, I wrote in @zeynep’s newsletter, Insight, about vaccine prioritization. I used a well-publicized inequity among #HCWs as case study

Major point: first-come, first served systems put the most advantaged & least at-risk first in line
zeynep.substack.com/p/the-vaccine-…
2/ I’m kicking myself bc I let myself lose track of a shift in my state’s prioritization scheme. As of yesterday, all childcare workers and K-12 teachers in particular are eligible to get vaccinated...
3/ I’ve been trying to help the teachers at my kids’ daycare get vaccinated. Only one is 65 yo+. Several others are just shy of that, Black women in their early 60s or late 50s (amazing women who’ve cared for my children w intention & purpose the past 6 years)
Read 22 tweets
24 Feb
1/ Being interviewed by @CurleyWriter got me thinking more about how age-related social network features affect #SARSCoV2 spread...
2/ Here’s a new pet theory I have for why Florida and California are #COVID19 outliers in different directions (CA worse than expected, FL faring better than expected*):

Differences in typical social networks of older people in each state
3/ We know that parts of California, which suffered terribly in recent #SARSCoV2 surge, have the highest levels of household crowding in the country...
Read 7 tweets
24 Feb
Interesting data from Denmark*

From mid November to mid February, experienced a huge surge then huge fall in #SARSCoV2 cases

Over same period, more comtagiois #B117 grew from <0.1% of genotyped cases to about 50%
I’m not sure what this means. Absolute numbers were decreasing, but country has been in a lockdown. They plan to start easing the lockdown slowly at end of Feb thelocal.dk/20210222/denma…
Also are in early stages of vaccination (like US) but moving deliberately to offer to whole population by mid-summer
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!