🧵DfE has released a new contingency framework for dealing with outbreaks and hotspots in education.
The last one was never used.

Link here
2/Whole principle seems that measures to cut transmission occur after the outbreak.

A reactionary rather than proactive approach to infection.
Takes a minimalist approach
3/To prioritise education they want the minimum number of measures for the minimum amount of time.

"Lift as soon as evidence supports"
What evidence? Whose evidence?

The evidence is saying we should already have these measures in place!
4/ So the plan is,

Wait for an outbreak

Introduce minimal measures
(To reassure parents to keep sending their kids in)

Lift as soon as possible

Rinse and repeat
5/ Talk of collaboration, I notice Heads get no input.
6/ Testing could be brought back on site, acknowledging testing done at home is less reliable.
But considering FDA view on these LFDs this is more like covid theatre than a serious measure.
7/ Masks can be brought back but any decision around this must balance education vs transmission.

Ignores the fact that if we don't manage transmission the students won't be in school
8/Shielding could be reintroduced, but only by national government.
9/If things get really bad then they might even limit residential trips..

All these things are currently recommended by DfE as a third wave sweeps through schools
10/ Attendence could be limited, however it specified that certain year groups in certain setting would still be expected in, however this is designed to be used after an outbreak when multiple year groups are already isolating.

I bet this is never used
11/ These measures in the previous containment framework were never used.
Not in December as Alpha ripped through London and South East and threats of court action were made by DfE
Not in Jan before primary staff walked out on the 1st day back
12/ Doesn't feel like a serious attempt at cutting transmission, window dressing they can point to claiming that measures are in place if necessary.
13/ We have been way to complacent about the long term risk to children from covid.
UK seems more concerned about talking about the harms of vaccines
14/ Also Delta can do something other Covid variants haven't.
It takes your cells and fuses them together into larger virus factories, makes it harder for antibodies to tackle

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Karam Bales

Karam Bales Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @karamballes

18 Jun
Who else is proposing no masks, social distancing or vaccination for students?

GBD are the only ones I can think of
So this is the UKs schools policy ⬇️
GBD vs Semple UK
Read 4 tweets
15 Jun
Herd Immunity 2.0
Fully vaccinate over 40s then let it rip through the rest to reach herd immunity.

Why do you think they won't even allow masks in classrooms?

#edutwitter
#ReleaseTheDataOnSchools
vip.politicsmeanspolitics.com/2021/06/15/sys…
SAGE modelling released after the briefing shows gov have factored in large scale infection of the under 40s and lots of school disruption, so all that concern about loss of learning?
Where has that gone now thousands of students are being isolated?
The plan to wait until school hols before Step 4 shows they recognise the role schools are playing in transmission, and yet they do nothing,

They think its acceptable infection, I think its preventable.

Its going to be "bumpy"
Read 10 tweets
13 Jun
🧵Several @lbc callers today have been quoting disinformation they read in the @Telegraph

The narrative in the article here is wait 4 weeks then let it rip because that will be the sweet spot.

So the idea is to get the over 50s double dosed and then away a Delta wave to spread
2/ Why will we reach a sweet spot in 4 weeks?

I assume that's when the over 50s have been double dosed.

It also means schools will be about to break up, and although the gov pretends otherwise they know schools are acting as Delta hubs.
3/ Been saying for a while I think the government believes the quickest route to herd immunity with what they consider an acceptable death and health toll is
2 jab over 50s
1 jab 18-50s
Natural infection for under 18s

Its a gamble based on impatience and pandering to lobbyists
Read 25 tweets
12 Jun
1🧵A Mad Plan, is this the only way?

If we had an adequate media then everytime a minister was interviewed they'd be asked about when the government will finally invest in ventilation.

All the evidence says this is one of the most important measures.
2.Even skeptics are going to struggle to portray clean air as an attack on our freedoms, if anything we have a right to clean air.The impact of pollution on health and in particular on children is clear

Can anyone remember the last time a minister was asked about ventilation?
3. Can anyone ever remember a minister being asked about investing ventilation in the whole pandemic?

UK government's total failure to address this is stark

So is the failure of the media to hold the gov to account for this glaring hole in their Covid strategy.
Read 9 tweets
10 Jun
So the next question is, did the UK government know?

We've been raising concerns about how unreliable these seem when used in the real world.

Also wondering, did the UK gov produce findings that seemed to match the manufacturers claims that the FDA disputes?
Quick scroll through bookmarked threads....

Boom🧨

Gov claiming they have studies that back the manufacturer

So have FDA missed the Oxford study?
Is the Oxford study wrong?
Is the UK gov misleading?
Have I got it mixed up?

Do other countries use these?
Reading back through my original thread when they announced mass testing, I got sent the link to the Heads test and trace briefing on last day of term, only around 500 attended, most were probably too busy notifying close contacts.

First section was of logistics of mass testing
Read 12 tweets
10 Jun
🧵Concerns are raised around the DfE continuing with experiments to use LFD to scrap isolation when only close contacts are asked for consent.

No suprise Munro pops up to explain that actually it would be unethical not to experiment in schools.

This isn't reassuring. Image
Here's the thread so you can see his arguments made for continuing the trials.

Having read his reasoning, I do have some questions.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(