Vote on third amendment by Russia
Vote on 4th Russian amendment
Vote on 5th Russian Amendment
Vote on following amendments along similar pattern with slight changes in votes for few members...
Amendments seeking to remove substance from the resolution rejected with the same level of support
Once all Russian amendments rejected, Council will consider resolution as whole
There are four possibilities for the 47 States that are member to the Human Rights Council:
Vote Yes
Vote No
Abstain
or simply refrain from voting all together (hence the few blanks)
Now opening general debate on the resolution as a whole
🇧🇷Brazil: stresses linkages betw. right to healthy environment & sustainable dvp as well as existing environmental legal instruments & the principles of international environmental law, regrets absence of ref. to MOI
...
🇷🇺Russia: reiterating position about objection to strengthening linkages between UN agencies and preference for fragmented approach to global governance. Questioning content of the right.
Calls for a vote on the resolution.
Indicate abstaining - will NOT vote against
🇲🇽Mexico: strong intervention in support of the right, focusing on the next steps
🇵🇰Pakistan: recognition as opportunity to galvanize mobilization to address environmental crises, stressing role of the UNGA for political affirmation of the right, importance of R2D
...
🇯🇵Japan: indicates abstention, doubts 54: legal nature of right, joining Russia doing so
🇵🇱Poland: confirms YES vote, suggesting legal definition has yet to come
🇲🇭Marshall Islands: providing small islands perspective= recognition urgent & imperative, asks support from others
...
🇮🇩INDONESIA: indicates YES. emphasis on linkages with right to development and urge to retain focus on these linkages
🇨🇳CHINA: mentions domestic dvp (incl. environmental chapter in own National Action Plan (re: biz HRs resp)
indicates abstention over concerns re: HRC mandate
...
🇬🇧UNITED KINGDOM: refers to hosting #COP26 & supporting action on #HumanRights & #ClimateChange, recognizing discriminatory impacts. Joining YES despite concerns about legal definition!
(well done to all those who helped securer this outcome"!)
...
And here comes the final vote!
43 YES
0 NO

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sébastien Duyck 🌍⚖️

Sébastien Duyck 🌍⚖️ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @duycks

8 Oct
Pay attention: after UN #HumanRights Council recognized with overwhelming majority right to clean, healthy and sustainable environment, #HRC48 is now focusing on next resolution: establishment of a UN Special Rapporteur on #HumanRights & #ClimateChange...
Proceedings in 🧵below
🇲🇭Marshall Islands: introduce the proposal for a new Special Rapporteur on behalf of core group supporting proposal (🇫🇯🇧🇸🇸🇩🇵🇾🇵🇦🇪🇺) and additional 27 co-sponsors: scale of climate harms on require stronger international response
...
🇬🇧UNITED KINGDOM: full support, links with #COP26, need for focus on discriminatory impacts & work in coordination with @SRenvironment
🇺🇿UZBEKISTAN: support for mandate from land locked perspective
🇳🇦NAMIBIA: creation of mandate long overdue. welcome future recommendations
...
Read 9 tweets
8 Oct
📌#HRC48 now considering adoption of important resolution on the human rights of indigenous peoples
Next item will be consideration of historic HRC resolution recognizing the right to a #HealthyEnvironment4All
Tune in now to follow live: ▶️media.un.org/en/asset/k1i/k…
Draft resolution is introduced by @CataDevandas on behalf of 🇨🇷🇲🇻🇲🇦🇸🇮🇨🇭, resolution is sponsored by 4⃣6⃣ States. Describes benefits expected and the massive support behind this proposal: #TheTimeIsNow
Indicates amendments made to draft text to secure broadest consensus...
Brazilian amendments withdrawn: these amendments sought to strengthen references to principles of international environmental law in a truncated manner.
Oral amendment expected to address this in a more balanced manner
Hoping for 🇧🇷support for resolution as a result...
Read 11 tweets
7 Oct
ℹ️Short explanation on process & stakes for universal recognition by 🇺🇳UN #HumanRights Council Session #HRC48 of right to a #HealthyEnvironmentForAll
After more than 18 months of consultations, the resolution will be put forward tomorrow by 🇨🇷🇲🇻🇲🇦🇸🇮🇨🇭 (👏for leadership)
1/6
Recognizing the right to a safe, clean, healthy & sustainable environment wld enable not only tackling the ecological crises upon us but also promoting enviro justice.
We know the benefits of such a recognition: it has been documented at the national level across the world.
2/5
First on rationale: universal recognition of this right wld enable UN Human Rights framework to reflect state of law in vast majority of nations & regional frameworks. Currently UN lags behind, failing to mobilize political focus & resources as needed
The recognition wld help
3/5
Read 5 tweets
14 Jul
🔥🔥Today 🇺🇳Human Rights Council #HRC47 adopted with overwhelming support a resolution on #HumanRights & Climate.
This paves way for continuation of OHCHR & Council’s work on climate - but this fails to constitute a step change in Council’s response to climate crisis
A thread🧵👇 Image
2/ All #HumanRights institutions recognize that climate crisis poses systematic threat to enjoyment of human rights. UN Human Rights Council has adopted 11 resolutions on the issue. Yet these do too little to orchestrate proper response matching the scale & urgency of the crisis Image
3/ The resolution, tabled by Bangladesh, Philippines & Viet Nam, was adopted today after all hostile amendments put forward by Russia were rejected. ALL other states voted in favour of the resolution demonstrating that consensus remains (Russia only abstained but did not oppose) Image
Read 9 tweets
4 Jun
🚨⚠️Growing concerns at ongoing🇺🇳UN Climate Talks that modalities of virtual negotiations constitute huge step back for the right of civil society and #IndigenousPeoples to participate effective in climate related decision making!
more details in thread...
#ParisAgreement #SB2021
2/ Virtual set up cld have been opportunity for inclusive process, yet many decisions prevent participation:
🔇no adequate input in plenary
🤐no modalities for effective input in negotiations
⛔️critical negotiations closed
🤝no opportunities for informal interactions/events
3/ Lack of transparency & participation is serious concern, esp when:
❌ concerns of those representing most vulnerable are ignored
🚓civil society space is shrinking globally & environmental leaders are under threats
⚖️agenda doesnt allow to address issues re: to #ClimateJustice
Read 4 tweets
18 Nov 20
🚨today @ #UNforumBHR, Philippines #HumanRights Commission shared update on groundbreaking investigation into responsibility of #FossilFuels majors for climate harms. release of @CHRgovPh recommendations in Dec
more about investigation: chr.gov.ph/nicc-2/
Key findings 👇1/4
2/ imperative: weaning ourselves off #FossilFuels & incentivizing #CleanEnergy
🧑‍⚖️States must create policy AND legislative environment to compel businesses so they do not compromise climate for corporate profits, incl transparency with regards to FF / clean energy investments…
3/ many potential legal bases to hold #CarbonMajors liable under domestic law:
🛑obstructing transition
🧑‍🔬obfuscating #ClimateScience/misleading public
🔍violation of fiduciary duty towards shareholders
⚖️in some cases: also criminal liability…
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(