Aaron Derfel Profile picture
Feb 6 14 tweets 8 min read
1) Two years into the #pandemic, something odd is now occurring worldwide in the #COVID19 crisis, with the number of global deaths surging while cases seem to be falling. This has not happened quite this way previously. In this thread, I will try to explain why this is occurring.
2) During the first wave of the pandemic in the winter of 2020, #COVID testing wasn't widely conducted around the world. The best indicator at the time was the number of deaths, which quickly skyrocketed. Please see the chart below comparing global cases with deaths at that time.
3) But later on, as countries around the world started testing for #COVID intensively, another pattern emerged. Deaths started to track more closely with the number of new cases, with declared deaths appearing a few weeks after infections were recorded. See an example below.
4) Yet a new pattern has emerged during the latest #Omicron-fuelled wave: #COVID cases and deaths are diverging dramatically. At first glance, it doesn’t make any sense. If deaths are rising worldwide, the number of cases must, too. What’s the possible explanation?
5) The only explanation that I can find is that many jurisdictions around the world have recently decided to test for #COVID a lot less. If true, this would give us a misleading picture of the true extent of the contagion globally. Let me cite a few examples.
6) On Jan. 5 this year, the United States carried out 3.08 million #COVID tests, according to the reliable Our World in Data website. But on Jan. 29, it conducted 972,253 tests, even as its #pandemic death toll climbed upward. Please see the chart below.
7) The situation in Canada is even more dramatic. On Jan. 4, Canada performed 601,278 #COVID tests. Nearly a month later, on Feb. 3, Canadian authorities carried out just 84,728 tests. This occurred as some provinces, like Quebec, stopped widespread screening.
8) A similar drop-off in testing is occurring in Denmark, which is now starting to ease #pandemic restrictions despite a spike in #COVID hospitalizations (although Danish authorities are emphasizing that ICU stays have not spiked). See Denmark’s testing chart below.
9) There are exceptions to this trend of decreasing tests. Russia seems to be testing more recently, which implies its apparently declining death toll may be inaccurate. More transparent Japan has been testing a lot, too, and a result, its cases are tracking well with its deaths.
10) Perhaps one of the best examples of the paradox of dwindling cases and rising deaths is Mexico. In reality, there is no paradox. Cases are probably not dwindling. As the side-by-side charts below reveal, COVID testing has been dropping off in Mexico, while deaths are rising.
11) There might very well be other explanations for what is now occurring globally. But the latest weekly epidemiological update by the World Health Organization does not focus on a drop-off in testing. And our World in Data does not calculate the overall global testing trend.
12) Could it be that the #Omicron variant – previously considered so mild – is much more virulent than suspected and has a much higher fatality rate? I doubt that is the case, although Omicron should never have been described as "mild" in the first place.
13) For now, the most plausible explanation is a drop-off in tests, which we know has been occurring in Québec and Ontario. It’s as if overwhelmed authorities around the world have given up on testing diligently for #COVID as #pandemic exhaustion has set in.
14) But if history has taught us anything (see the Spanish Flu of more than a hundred years ago as an example), now is not the time to ease up on #COVID testing, especially since Omicron and its sub-variant BA.2 are so much more contagious. End of thread.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Aaron Derfel

Aaron Derfel Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Aaron_Derfel

Feb 5
1) Japan — generally lauded for its response to the #COVID crisis — is now in the grip of what it’s calling a 6th wave in the #pandemic. To be blunt, what the hell is now going wrong in Japan and what lessons can Québec draw from the Land of the Rising Sun?
2) As you can glimpse from the chart below, #COVID hospitalizations in Canada are now in decline, while they are climbing in Japan. Toyko’s metropolitan government has ordered hospitals to boost the number of emergency beds to accept patients at night.
3) In an alarming development reminiscent of what Quebec has been going through, the Japanese government is considering whether it should send low-risk #COVID patients back home to “prevent medical facilities from being overwhelmed.”
Read 9 tweets
Feb 4
Alors que nous entrons dans la troisième année de la crise sanitaire, il est devenu évident que certains mots ou expressions ne sont plus utilisés au Québec pour parler de la pandémie. Dans cette enfilade pas si sérieuse, je discuterai de ces mots oubliés.
J'ai décidé de choisir des mots ou des expressions en français uniquement parce que, 1) je vis et travaille au Québec et 2), ces termes semblent plus colorés, même poétiques, dans la langue de Molière.
Je voudrais remercier tous ceux qui ont contribué à cette enfilade psycholinguistique avec leurs suggestions. Je me concentre sur les expressions ou les mots discontinus, pas sur ceux encore utilisés que nous détestons, comme « la lumière au bout du tunnel. »
Read 12 tweets
Feb 4
1) Nearly two weeks after posting the highest rate of #COVID deaths per million population among industrialized nations, Quebec has ceded the top spot back to the United States, as U.S. booster vaccination has stagnated. But this is beginning to happen in Quebec, too. Image
2) Quebec’s booster vaccination program was problematic from the start, as authorities were slow to give a 3rd dose to elderly Quebecers living in their homes. The chart below shows that this tardy decision is likely responsible for the second highest death wave in the #pandemic. Image
3) But as flawed as Quebec’s booster campaign has been, the situation in the United States has proved even worse. At the same time, more and more U.S. states have been lifting #pandemic restrictions, resulting in #COVID deaths creeping up. Please take a look at the chart below. Image
Read 8 tweets
Feb 3
1) Dr. Jordan Peterson (@jordanbpeterson), one of Canada’s preeminent intellectuals, cited a meta-analysis on Tuesday concluding that the average #COVID lockdown resulted in only a 0.2% reduction in mortality in Europe and in the U.S. Is that really true?
2) Given Peterson’s huge audience and his commitment to scientific rigour, it is worth stress-testing this meta-analysis that has appeared in Studies in Applied Economics. That would be part of the scientific method of open and fact-based debate.
3) It’s in that scientific tradition that I would like to report the reaction of various British scientists to this meta-analysis. Courtesy of sciencemediacentre.org, this is what Neil Ferguson, director of the MRC Centre for Global Infectious Disease Analysis, had to say:
Read 10 tweets
Feb 2
1) Quebec’s new chief of public health, Dr. Luc Boileau, asserted on Wednesday he believes the province’s severely weakened health system could handle a potential influx of long #COVID patients. In this thread, I will examine whether this assertion stands up to closer scrutiny.
2) This is what Boileau said in response to a sharply focused question by the @mtlgazette’s @JesseFeith: “I think we are. I think it’s going to be a challenge. I think the more they are vaccinated, in particular with the 3rd dose, the less they are at risk to develop long COVID.”
3) Dr. Boileau may have confidence in Quebec’s health-care system, but it’s been years since he managed the Montérégie health authority. The system today is in much worse shape than when Boileau ran hospitals and clinics on the South Shore 13 years ago.
Read 15 tweets
Feb 2
1) At least two countries in the Northern Hemisphere – Ireland and Denmark – have started lifting #pandemic restrictions despite the more contagious #Omicron variant and the fact deaths are still rising in the latter. In this thread, I will examine the risks of lockdown fatigue.
2) First, though, let us focus on Quebec's latest #COVID death wave, which is stubbornly resisting to subside. In fact, the current wave has surpassed the wave last January, when Quebec still had a curfew in effect at this point in 2021. Please take a look at the chart below.
3) The Quebec government is wary to discuss this, but I submit it must be held accountable on this score. Most deaths are now occurring among Quebecers who were at least 70, who had been living at home, many of whom did not get their booster doses in time.
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

:(