Ghazala Wahab Profile picture
Jun 17 10 tweets 3 min read
A thread on #AgnipathRecruitmentScheme

1. Here is my 'deliberated' opinion. What #Demonitization was to d economy, this would b to d armed forces & India's military preparedness. Here r my reasons:
One: World has moved towards leaner & meaner armed forces. Even within infantry
2. the concept has been of a soldier as a system, a highly trained, tech-savvy, multi-tasking operator. In conventional warfighting, technology is increasingly eliminating d idea of close combat. I am not even talking about PLA's informatised & intelligentised war, which hardly
3. needs humans in direct combat. So compromising on quality for quantity militates against all principles of modern, tech-intensive warfare. It seems tht MoD envisages creating a human line of actual control behind the one tht evaporated in thin air after May 2020. Whatever be
4. the intend, this is akin to treating human lives as fodder. It's inhuman, ill-thought through and disastrous.

Two: A vast majority of young men who join the Indian Army, risking life and limb, do so for job security & in case they die, for security of their families, not...
5. for the motherland. That sentiment is cultivated during training, because d motherland for a villager is the village, not the amorphous notion of a nation, which is a theoretical concept. To expect this person to risk life and limb for merely a temporary experience is...
6. Foolish.

Three: The SSC concept, both for men and women only led to dissatisfaction and disillusionment. The male SSC officers demanded extension of tenure and women fought & won the right to permanent commission. No one wants to commit to a job which can give better but...
7. does not because of the terms of their recruitment.

Four: Even today, d armed forces are struggling to ensure lateral induction of their personnel in the civil domain. Most end up with jobs much below their expectations and abilities. D CAPFs/ CPMFs are already struggling...
8. with unhappy personnel because of extremely slow promotions & stagnant career prospects. They need their own reforms, instead of being saddled with decommissioned #Agniveers, who will come wth diff mindset, training & experience.

Five: #AgnipathRecruitmentScheme won't...
9. solve the unemployment problem, it will only militarise it. The vast number of semi-trained, semi-literate, decommissioned people, bitter because of their experience, would b floating in d society seeking a second career in their 20s.

D only advantage of this idea would be...
10. Savings on money. But then what can be expected when all policymaking in India is driven by oligarchs like Messrs Double A.

Ends.

@PravinSawhney @FORCEmagazine

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ghazala Wahab

Ghazala Wahab Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ghazalawahab

Mar 16
1. Surprised it took so long to make #KashmirFiles. A propaganda film on #KashmiriPandit should have come out long ago. D only post-Independence event to justify victim syndrome among d #knickerwallahs has been d genuine & terrible plight of Kashmiri Pandits. Worse, no one is...
2. Interested is helping the poor among them, both living in and outside the Valley. Their utility is only as symbols of misery. After all, it's common sense that without peace in the Valley, no Pandit would risk life & limb by living in govt designated colonies, irrespective...
3. Of d security assurances. And the only possibility of real peace is through resolution of #Kashmir dispute. The current road-roller approach is worsening the situation. You can't subjugate people forever. And certainly not people who have sympathisers outside. So, if you...
Read 4 tweets
Feb 3
A thread on the #hijab controversy.

1. Until now, I hadn't commented on #Karnataka #hijab row. Conscious tht d issue was abt politics, neither religion nor young girls' right to wear hijab to college, I didn't have clarity of my position. Now I have. But first, a few questions
2. Has there been any incident in any part of India where #Muslim men wanted to attend classes in a particular dress, say a skullcap? Why is the responsibility of upholding religious identity only Muslim women's? Who is telling these women tht their identity & d right to fight
3. For tht identity more imp than their future? Why is no one finding it disturbing tht fathers of some girls r saying tht if college doesn't relent, they will not allow their girls to study further. Let their future b ruined? Y r parents not moved by d sight of desperate girls?
Read 8 tweets
Nov 19, 2021
A thread. Warning: It's emotional. But no drama.

When I started my career, way back in 1994, I wrote a long-winding article on how there can be peace in the Indian subcontinent. Though my knowledge of Kashmir & geopolitics was limited...,
My ignorance didn't come in the way of proposing that national boundaries needed to be flexible, allowing for free movement of people for personal travel, trade and tourism. At age 23, I figured that if Kashmir had open borders, India-Pakistan could be friends...
And with Bangladesh, we in any case had no problem. Nepal was my model, as my school friend--whose father was executing a major MES contract in Gorakhpur--used to drive into Nepal every summer in their own car. I was invited once, but my parents didn't allow me. Anyway,
Read 9 tweets
Jul 30, 2020
So govt supported think tank, gave platform to @China_Amb_India to lambast us. Tell us on r face that our slogan of non violence is pretense. That our brave soldiers died in #GalwanValley not only because they were aggressors but also they couldn't match the PLA. Not only
Retd Indian diplomats & journalists sat there listening to heaps upon heaps of allegations, none mustered courage to ask d Chini envoy which #LAC he was referring to. Mutually agreed 1993 or unilateral 1959? If its 1993, then is @MEAIndia lying abt no violations?
#LadakhBorder
And the brave ambassador also told us with statistics on his fingertips, why any kind of economic war will hurt India more. All the while insisting that Chinese want to build trust and they are never aggressors #IndiaChinaFaceOff
D problem with Indian intellectuals is d same as
Read 5 tweets
Apr 5, 2020
A thread: Shades of bigotry.

1. The relentless online #Islamophia & #Muslims hatred prompted a chat on family WhatsApp group. I said, unlike #IndianMuslims who come across several #Hindus in their lifetime, given d demography, a large number of Hindus have no opportunity...
2. To meet or interact with #Muslims; esp those who come with family traditions of #RSS. Hence, they tend to believe all kinds of propaganda because they grow up listening to that & never get a chance to see that it's all a lie. To this, my sister in law said, but what about...
3. My neighbour. I was speechless. My brother's family has been neighbours with this family for 10 years. They are d closest of friends, eating in each other's homes, women having post-breakfast tea together everyday. Celebrating birthdays/ anniversaries together etc. Yet,
Read 10 tweets
Mar 2, 2020
#Ghetto or Mixed Neighbourhoods. A Thread.

I was born in a Muslim area. However, as soon as my father could afford, he built a house in 'Hindu' area, which was better & more developed. To begin wth, it had sewer line. So now we could have attached bathroom wth flush toilets 1/10
Ours was d only Muslim house here. Old neighbours & well-wishers dissuaded my father, but he aspired for a better quality of life for himself & his family. 1 of my youngest uncles moved in with us. Two of my middle uncles stayed back in d #ghetto. D diff in r lifestyles grew 2/10
In #Nov 1990, after kar sewa in Ayodhya, d mob spilled over in cities of #UP indulging in rioting & arson. My family, divided in a ghetto & an upmarket colony was in a fix. My father urged his brothers to move in with us with their families, assuming our home would be safe 3/10
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(