Nicolas Tenzer Profile picture
Jan 26 10 tweets 6 min read
10 principles for these weeks (recap).
1 In the medium to long term, the main cost would be the non-defeat of #Russia.
It would be terrible for #Ukraine, #Syria, #Georgia, #Belarus, #Moldova, #Africa..., but also for Europe and the world.
It should dictate our strategic goal.
2 In the short term, the worst cost is measured in terms of Ukrainian lives (civilians, military, people in the occupied territories, incl. Crimean Tatars).
This is what must matter to us first.
We must defeat #Russia as quickly as possible with all possible conventional weapons.
3 Western leaders must banish certain words, including:
- escalation risks;
- red lines;
- peace talks;
- negotiations;
- compromise;
- balance;
- architecture of stability...
Words matter.
Narrative matter.
4 We must have a global strategy to counter Russian influence not only in our democracies, but also in the (different) Southern countries: s. recently the declarations of the🇲🇽 president, of the MFA of South Africa, & recurrent issues in other places of Africa, ME, Latin America.
5 If we want to guarantee our security in the future and avoid this perverse game of Russian criminal power, #Russia must lose radically, I repeat.
Until that happens, it will keep its power to harm far beyond Ukraine & keeps its "soft power".
Let's have the world order in mind.
6 We must understand why Putin's 🇷🇺 is an absolute enemy (s. my lastest).
Any trivialization (with the argument that Putin is not Hitler, the Russian war against Ukraine is not the WWII, that Ukrainian genocide Putin is not the Holocaust—so what?) serves the enemy's propaganda.
7 Method
There's an order to be respected: overall vision, objectives that follow, strategy, policies, secondary objectives, means, organization...
Western leaders have not formulated the first, nor the second—and the rest is logically missing.
Still too much day-to-day politics.
8 I already described this needed reversal: we've let Putin be the agenda setter for 22 years. We must now define our own, what I had called OUR war aims.
Beyond the general phrases that don't have the same meaning for all, we're still far from it.
Because of a remenance of fear.
9 Ukraine must win completely and Russia must lose radically in 🇺🇦 and elsewhere: objectives I had expressed at the beginning of this war.
Those who think that they can prevent Moscow from destabilizing the whole world without achieving these objectives are under great illusion.
10 The total victory of🇺🇦will lead to the fall of Putin's regime.
This is our goal: no one's thinking of overthrowing him—Russians will.
Not the apocalypse—some seem to fear it (insane).
Then, we'll have to manage🇷🇺in the long run.
Not easy, but without defeat no hope is allowed.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Nicolas Tenzer

Nicolas Tenzer Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @NTenzer

Jan 24
If this US decision to send M1 #Abrams tanks to #Ukraine (despite some technicalities) were confirmed, it would be remarkable.
It certainly depends on the number.
With 200 or 300 #Leopard2, a real game-changer.
But time is of the essence.
#Thread 🧵
1/6
wsj.com/articles/polan…
First, we, democratic countries, must be clear about our goal: to give Kyiv the means to reclaim ALL the territories invaded since 2014 (including #Crimea).
We need to move from "Defend #Ukraine" to "Make #Ukraine win" and "Defeat Russia".
Let's be straightforward.
2/6 Image
We must throw all our available forces into the battle: heavy tanks, long-range missiles, fighter planes — the only way to end the war as soon as possible.
The combination of these forces (+ military intelligence) will bring victory.
The longer we delay, the higher the cost.
3/6 ImageImage
Read 6 tweets
Nov 26, 2022
Je vais tenter de répondre en plusieurs temps.
Mon propos n'est jamais que la prolongation de mes avertissements depuis plus de quinze ans sur le régime russe.
A mon sens, retomber aujourd'hui dans le "camp de la paix" serait risquer le même type de bévue que celui qui
1/16
nous a conduit au désastre mortel.
Certes, dans chaque camp, il existe des nuances, principalement en termes de réponse opérationnelle à la guerre russe contre l'Ukraine. Mais de toutes les discussions que j'ai eues au cours des derniers mois, je conclus qu'ils existent bel
2/16
et bien dans la plupart des cercles dirigeants occidentaux.
Ceux qui souhaitent la paix (certes, nous la souhaitons tous et il est bien commode de se dire en sa faveur) ne précisent somme toute jamais à quel prix. Sur quoi négocier ? Avec qui ? Que seraient les conséquences
3/16
Read 16 tweets
Oct 23, 2022
To be fair, @EmmanuelMacron doesn't legitimize Putin's war of extermination. Elsewhere, he says no peace should include recognition of a status quo imposed by force.
But in saying this—"Russian power has been nourished by the resentment & humiliation born of the breakup...
🧵
1/9
of the Soviet empire"—, he not only commits a major communication blunder (for that is what will be remembered), but once more misunderstands the nature of the Russian regime.
1 He still does not grasp that...
2/9
the discourse of humiliation is just a ruse of Putin's power that aims at sharing a belief (what I had called in a paper the perception of a perception), exactly in the same way that its use by Hitler (the humiliation by the Treaty of Versailles, the "stab in the back")...
3/9
Read 9 tweets
Oct 23, 2022
I have difficulty understanding the intent of this message in terms of communication and substance.
A short thread on this.
Let's talk straight.
🧵
1/7
1 In terms of substance, the question is not whether or not to isolate Putin, but to ensure that the Russian regime loses the war, is put out of action, which implies its disappearance—I certainly understand that @MinColonna can't say this explicitly.
2/7
tenzerstrategics.substack.com/p/what-would-t…
2 Moreover, to think that talking to him could change him is the same illusion that has prevailed in recent years.
To send warning messages is certainly something else and could make sense. The US did. Has nothing to do with the isolation narrative.
3/7
tenzerstrategics.substack.com/p/ukraine-the-…
Read 7 tweets
Oct 1, 2022
1 Putin's #Russia is the #enemy, the absolute enemy, not by nature but because of the threats it poses to the whole world.
Since too long.
Let's declare it so for good!
He's the total #evil, personally, and—most importantly—politically.
Short #thread🧵
tenzerstrategics.substack.com/p/what-does-vl…
2 #Russia must be defeated totally, radically, absolutely, i.e. strategically.
It must be put out of action.
Its troops must be expelled from #Ukraine, from #Georgia, from #Belarus, from #Syria, from #Africa.
For the sake of humanity.
Our goal.
tenzerstrategics.substack.com/p/six-months-e…
3 Putin's speech is irrelevant. So let's stop giving it a value it doesn't have.
He repeated what we've known for 23 years about this regime. All these threats are old.
Some did not want to see it. Their fault is immeasurable.
This regime should have been destroyed long ago.
Read 6 tweets
Sep 30, 2022
Merci pour ce message qui témoigne de votre intérêt pour mes longs papiers sur #TenzerStrategics (ce qui fait la spécificité de ce blog).
Vous n'êtes pas la première à me le demander (et merci à mes abonnés en forte croissance à travers le monde).
Quelques éléments de réponse.
1 Chacun(e) peut utiliser le cas échéant un logiciel de traduction.
2 Mon public n'est pas essentiellement français (d'où le choix de l'anglais, langue de fait universelle qu'on le veuille ou non).
3 Je n'ai pas d'assistant(e) - cela explique aussi que je laisse de nombreux...
messages sans réponse (je ne lis pas toujours mes DM ici et l'équivalent sur les autres RS).
4 Sous réserve que cela soit techniquement possible d'avoir deux blogs sur substack, ce n'est pas impossible non plus, mais c'est un lourd travail quand même.
5 Combien seraient prêts...
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(