Thread by @Prof_Kennedy

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @DouthatNYT Insightful @DouthatNYT, approaching that #KnowledgeCulturalSociology in which we ask how to name global transformations nytimes.com/2022/02/26/opi… Better to go 1 more step: does this Huntington revision risk legitimating the evil Putin, Modi, et al rain down on "their" peoples? Yes.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @DouthatNYT More #KnowledgeCulturalSociology on naming our epoch: Closer than @DouthatNYT (above), Ivan Krastev nytimes.com/2022/02/27/opi… evokes Enzensberger - "violence has freed itself from ideology". At least it has for Putin. After Putin's defeat, may we retreat from his special Hell.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse More naming our epoch by @damiencave nytimes.com/2022/03/04/wor… declaring response to Putin in Ukraine its switch. @BorisJohnson authors the heroic role every leader believing in #UKRSovereignty ought. nytimes.com/2022/03/06/opi… But in action? Will speech be prologue? Or substitute?

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse Insightful @DouthatNYT elaborates a conservative position on gradually resisting Putin. nytimes.com/2022/03/05/opi… I get it, cautious as it is, but note what it never mentions: creativity of Solidarność in 80-81. One might think more creatively as @rshereme
facebook.com/583997548/post…

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @DouthatNYT @rshereme Not quite renaming our epoch, but Bob Gates pens a piece that deserves not only policy makers' engagement but a deeper #KnowledgeCulturalSociology washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/… for its assumptions about power in the world and the consequences of its variable address. #PKJ

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @DouthatNYT @rshereme Ukrainians grow impatient with Western caution, allowing them to die while the Americans et al declare they don't want escalation. Some call that evil. facebook.com/10000124079261… When combined with the smugness of knowing better from the cores of empires, it's even worse.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse My only hope, @IgnatiusPost, is that this avid declaration of resistance to #USNATO participation in assuring a #NoFlyZone is part of #InfoWar, distracting while washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/… Ukraine's allies support in ways similar to what @rshereme facebook.com/583997548/post… proposes

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @IgnatiusPost Almost insightful @DouthatNYT: establishing 19th-21st c analogies nytimes.com/2022/03/12/opi… worthy of #WorldSystemsTheory engagement. Once I may have scoffed at this parallel, where leaders "aim for a real public legitimacy for imperialism, conquest, autocratic rule." I was wrong.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse Thoughtful critics of autocracy fr @IWM_Vienna networks discuss how Great Russian ideology shapes assault on Ukraine. nytimes.com/2022/03/16/wor… But how does that ideology inflect action? @IVejvoda proposes intriguing contrast btwn cynical Milosevic & fanatical Putin. More please?

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse Ukraine's example, inspiration moves @KoriSchake to write, "This is what free societies converging on an idea looks like. & the idea is this: Resist Putin's evil". theatlantic.com/international/… #PKJ also expresses that, but attend to what @CharlesMBlow writes today as well.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse While @POTUS said it off the cuff, a more official declaration ought be coming. Putin et al are war criminals. understandingsociety.blogspot.com/2022/03/russia… Consider the case @dlittle30 makes here. I know: declaring such makes him unlikely to take an offramp toward peace. He's not taking it anyway.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @POTUS One might, & ought, challenge with truth #PutinLies about fighting Nazis in Ukraine nytimes.com/2022/03/17/wor…, but as we know from scholarship on #TrumpLies #MagaMythos, etc. such speech is not designed to approximate reality but generate fantasy to mobilize disruptive action.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @POTUS I've always appreciated @Schwarzenegger in films, and while we've not always been in political alignment, his message to Russians is among the most compelling I have seen. I was moved. I hope Russians of good will, and good hearing, might be too. #Нетвойны

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @POTUS "The war is reducing the distance btwn famous & ordinary Ukrainians because so many non-celebrities are making heroic sacrifices" said @avalaina - "people focus on issues of life & death that eclipse focus on fame." nytimes.com/2022/03/19/wor… Rest In Power Heroes of Ukraine.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @POTUS “I never thought I would be ashamed of Russia. We may not be at the epicenter of the military conflict, but we cannot remain indifferent to this global catastrophe.” offered Ballerina Olga Smirnova nytimes.com/2022/03/16/art… #Нетвойны #CelebritySolidarity can matter @DaniilMedwed.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @POTUS 1/ Naming #InfoWar implies equivalence, but it's not. #PutinLies have been carefully cultivated & curated to realize their effect in Russia itself, with #UsefulIdiots like Tucker Carlson amplifying Russian disinformation. nytimes.com/2022/03/20/wor… Thx @stevenleemyers #TruthMatters

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @POTUS 2/ When I proposed in here that Putin lost the cultural political war, I referred to the few beyond Russia who believe #PutinLies. But this real war cannot be stopped without defeating Putin's armed forces & his public support. Truth + @Schwarzenegger + ?

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse 3/ As my @WatsonInstitute colleague @Timothy_Edgar
notes, nationalinterest.org/blog/techland-… one reason #Ukraine is winning the #InfoWar beyond Russia is bc it's been able to defend its internet infrastructure.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 4/4 Those mocking #TikTok don't have the imagination to see its potential theguardian.com/technology/202… esp for mobilizing Russian youth to embrace #Нетвойны. It's true we don't have right theory/practice yet but learn from my @BrownSociology student I do.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 5/4 This washingtonpost.com/technology/202… is a more informative account of who on #TikTok is doing what re #Ukraine. It only makes developing a stronger #KnowledgeCulturalSociology of the medium & its theory/practice more important.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar A tough essay to write, but @HayleyHPhelan
manages to incorporate #SuperheroSociology #TikTokSociology #InfoWar #CelebritySolidarity & #UKRSovereignty nytimes.com/2022/03/26/opi… in thoughtful & respectful fashion. Kudos.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 1/ Debates about Huntington's appropriateness endure bc it's such a sociologically sloppy approach; @DouthatNYT reconstructs it to be simultaneously more sensible but also appealing to his work in challenging his detested "wokeness". nytimes.com/2022/03/30/opi… I prefer another take

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @DouthatNYT 2/ Instead of thinking civilizationally, contrast contests among hegemonic & counterhegemonic cultural schema. We then move away from imposed holisms that erase struggles from our theories of social change, & restore white supremacy to its deserved centrality among colonizers.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @DouthatNYT 3/ Centered in Ukraine now is the contest btwn Russian imperial power & other struggles for sovereignty animated by nationalisms of various sorts. This can be theorized in religious terms, but as Ukraine demonstrates, need not. Cultural fusions of all sorts are possible.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 4/4 Democracy is remarkably adaptable, & can serve both as instrument of governance/identification, like what @DouthatNYT marks in Dems' talk, or a resource in struggles #SeekingJustice. His reducing struggle for racial justice to wokeness reflects his place in the contest.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @DouthatNYT 1/ Putin's war on Ukraine is eventful (in #SewellianSociology sense) in so many ways, even for reshaping US polity. Bi-partisanship is certainly apparent in support for Ukraine, with the #GOPoT wing noticeably out to lunch with Orban et al. But cultural schema need be clarified.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 2/ Surveys indicate GOP supporting more aggressive Ukrainian support than Dems, w independents closer to former. nytimes.com/2022/03/30/opi… @Edsall's wariness of tougher replies to Putin are evident in his characterization. But I wonder the gender/partisanship generalizing is right.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 3/ Extending @Edsall logic, one might call Germans, French, Brits, & even Orban more akin to Biden et al, while Poles, Lithuanians, Latvians, and Estonians more like male GOP, with the latter more sympathetic to #NoFlyZone etc. But are these psychological dispositions? No.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 4/ These different standpoints are not rooted in psychological dispositions but in historical experiences which of course are also gendered. Recognizing Putin's invasion of Ukraine, as @KarolinaWigura & Kuisz do, nytimes.com/2022/03/25/opi… is a reflection of the region's experience

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @KarolinaWigura 5/ Use of force can be about recognizing reality, as defending Ukraine, but also expressions of #UbermenschEscapism & distractions from reality -- recall #BuildTheWall. The #MilitarismDistinction is worth parsing when we engage in generalizations about different kinds of force.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @KarolinaWigura 6/ Struggles for #UKRSovereignty are transformative. To defend it w/out nuclear escalation is to change articulations of force in the world, diminishing #TrumPutin type appeals & restoring courage & strength to a value across genders. france24.com/en/live-news/2…

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 7/ Putin's victory would, however, vindicate the hyper-masculinist celebration of brute force, the freedom to dominate others rather than to be free of that domination. We ought know that distinction in the US nytimes.com/2021/12/17/opi… as @jbouie has elaborated.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @jbouie 8/8 #UKRSovereignty is not only about defending a rule-based global order & democracy's value, but rearticulating on a global scale what #FreedomMeans. Freedom from domination offers a frame w which a new hegemony can be built, leaving Orban #GOPoT et al in the dust. With Putin.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @jbouie 1/ Tis right to address, after its accomplishments in these first 5+ weeks of Putin's invasion, the solidarity around Ukrainian refugees and that which is going to be needed in the future alongside previous treatments of refugees from other wars & crises. nytimes.com/2022/04/01/opi…

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @jbouie 2/ Most obviously & immediately, numerous commentators have contrasted the treatment of Ukrainian refugees with those from Syria and Afghanistan among other places since 2015.
Recognizing global racism in the outcomes of this century's wars is critical. But we need context too.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @jbouie 3/ The most immediate precedent for what we witness now was in the fall when the weaponization of migrants and refugees from Syria, Afghanistan & other conventional colonial contest realized what I thought would be its most evil expression.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @jbouie 4/ That context helps to explain the current conjuncture's embrace of Ukrainian refugees. It's not just racism, however. It's also how the weaponization of migrants figures in the struggle to defend sovereignties from dictators' assault. Contrast November & February.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar 5/ Lukashenko, with Putin's backing, sought in 2021 to disrupt European support for the democratic movement in Belarus. Poles saw that weaponization of migrants as the most immediate assault on their sovereignty, even while solidarity w/ @Tsihanouskaya et al remained.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @Timothy_Edgar @Tsihanouskaya 6/ But that response to Lukashenko diminished, properly, the sense that Poles supported any kind of universal values associated with democracy and human rights. Their same struggle to defend their sovereignty today casts a different light.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall 7/ On 3/15/22, Warsaw Mayor @trzaskowski_ spoke to
@morningmika @MSNBC declaring that Ukrainians fight for Poland's, Europe's, freedom. He said Kyiv's mayor,
@Vitaliy_Klychko, told him "by caring for our families, we can focus on fighting". facebook.com/1068681456/vid… Solidarity.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @Vitaliy_Klychko 8/ But even in this 2022 context, the surge of refugees from a war fought on behalf of European freedom could realize the same destabilizing effects previous more explicit weaponizations of migrants sought. These cautions nytimes.com/2022/04/01/opi… are critical, but hardly suffice.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @Vitaliy_Klychko 9/9 This set of contradictions was clear last year , where democracies & autocracies are mutually implicated as vulnerable populations in movement suffer. We need deeper thinking & transformed policy & practice to meet this contradiction's latest expression

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @Vitaliy_Klychko Tis remarkable, pathetic and dangerous what these #TrumPutin Americans try to do to carry forward the #TrumpLies about Putin in the wake of his criminality. politico.com/news/magazine/… May the #ResponsibleReoublican find some spine here, and then run with it.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @Vitaliy_Klychko Putin not only assaults #UKRSovereignty & commits genocide, but also destroys what appeared once to be a certain spiritual unity among the Orthodox. themoscowtimes.com/2022/03/15/ort… Putin does this w his accomplice Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirill. Theologians declare it ethno-phyletism.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC Hearing @ZelenskyyUa address UN Security Council stirs outrage of what Putin & his forces have done. Not only for Ukraine but for the world. "Show all the other potential war criminals in the world how they will be punished; if the biggest one is punished, then everyone will be."

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC Further fr @ZelenskyyUa - Russia's leadership feels like colonizers..they need our wealth, our people.. they abducted more than 2K children.. The UN System must be reformed immediately.. to stop (Russian) massacres from long ago & then perhaps there would not be war in my country

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC Finally, "the power of peace must become dominant". @ZelenskyyUa has spoken in a most compelling way. But what might be done when UN rules, and the distribution of force, and the brutality of Putin and his Russian forces, destroy the vision of peace.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC Yes, @ZelenskyyUa challenges the value and function of the UN when one of its Security Council members is the greatest threat to the very existence of Ukraine. nytimes.com/2022/04/05/wor… Russia's UN Ambassador, in response, lied through his teeth.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa As I prepare to teach #PKJ about technology, militarism & security, and as across this term Russia's invasion of Ukraine has been the touchstone which to figure the importance of #KnowledgeCulturalSociology in #GlobalSocialChange, I make these points in today's conclusion. 1/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa There are today more means of inter-imperial, inter-state conflict available than ever before: financial, cyber, infowar, etc. all at potential degrees of destruction for which we are hardly prepared. 2/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa At the same time, it is possible for actors in that contest to break with conventions of appearing non-violent and use force to assure desired outcomes. Putin did just that, having an ultimate threat, in nuclear weapons, to enable impunity of more conventional forces’ assault. 3/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa Extreme war in this context is causing all sorts of consequences beyond its immediate forms of destruction – wild and intense flows of population, drastic shortages of food, terrific fluctuations in global prices, interruptions of supply chains, and so on. 5/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa The implications of these relatively remote consequences of war are even more uncertain; will the results of this contest lead to an increase in militarism and violence or some kind of new solidarity based on an awareness of the disaster realized, or averted? 6/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa The investment in war technologies and products grows dramatically, but it is still restrained in a number of ways. Still, it's clear that these expressions of militarism/security will be even more prominent in the world after this invasion's provisional resolution. 7/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa Assumptions about how non-lethal kinds of investments to assure peace are shaken; markets do not constrain, multilateral organizations don’t constrain, even kinship ties don’t limit the potentials for violence in this world in which we live. 8/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa Willingness to exercise brute force with sufficiently lethal technologies is leading to a surge in militarism, alongside a surge in the cultures accompanying, including #UbermenschEscapism. But that trajectory remains uncertain. 9/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC There's still a chance that Putin, Trump et al practiced in such brittle hypermasculinity may just be defeated by those who value cooperation, collaboration & peace, even while they also have assumed the necessary mantle of warriors to defend homelands. @ZelenskyyUa 10/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC @ZelenskyyUa That outcome is still unknown… and part of what this struggle is all about. It's not only Ukraine vs Russia, democracy vs authoritarianism, international law vs brutality, but a contest shaping global #AlternativeFutures whose destinations are still unclear. 12/12

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @MSNBC A fitting sequel to the 12 tweet thread preceding: @CharlesMBlow recalls the time of existential uncertainty shrouding his youth. I remember it too. nytimes.com/2022/04/06/opi… And we can both anticipate its return. With terrific remorse. With even more anxiety.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika With @lylegoldstein @WatsonInstitute watson.brown.edu/events/2022/cr… Nicolai Petro addresses "non-military aspects" of Ukraine. This event is available online and begins now.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @lylegoldstein Petro argues there are 3 conflicts within this current crisis: a) from Brzezinski-inspired US interest to pull Ukraine from Russia; b) among elites within Ukraine; & c) regional contest btwn west & east stoked by foreign contests. 2/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @lylegoldstein Drawing on various pieces of evidence, from polls & elite statements, Petro declares that there is no such unity of Ukraine against Russia, and rather that the contest still cuts through Ukraine itself, and rather favors restoring #UKRSovereignty & agency for Ukraine itself. 3/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @lylegoldstein Petro's solution? "Cultural Autonomy for Political Loyalty" & political reconciliation btwn regions, rooted in a common vision of the future, repudiating an "integral nationalism" he finds to have defined post-Maidan Ukraine. Empathy for the other side is the start of dialogue 4/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @lylegoldstein Petro's mechanism? a "truth and reconciliation" commission, a public catharsis that removes hatred and leads to social healing, returning to a more Ukrainian liberalism, rooted in 19th c Ukrainian/Russian history, to supplant Ukrainian nationalism tied to cultural homogeneity. 5/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @lylegoldstein Recalling an array of Ukrainian leaders who appeared to compromise Ukrainian nationalism in order to enable the nation's survival, Petro believes a more moderate nationalism could help by embracing its diversity. 6/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @lylegoldstein I appreciate a vision of truth & reconciliation, but I proposed to Prof Petro that his presentation would alienate many Ukrainians by implying that post-Maidan was defined by integral nationalism. I asked if he knew Mychailo Wynnyckyj. blackstonelibrary.com/ukraine-s-maid… is good reading. 7/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @lylegoldstein Prof Petro's account also lays at the doorstep responsibility for Russia's invasion Poroshenko's address of civil strife in Donbas. Following that, some in the room wondered if the most sympathetic audience for this argument would be in Russia, not in Ukraine. 8/8

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @lylegoldstein A fine essay explaining why a) expertise in polling is critical for interpreting surveys, esp in conditions like Russia & b) how echoing Putin language is so dangerous for legitimating his invasion of Ukraine newyorker.com/news/news-desk… thx @yaffaesque 1/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika As @abessudnv said, “we should remember what people have in mind when they say they support what is happening in Ukraine.” @yaffaesque: Polling signals is "a person’s willingness to post antiwar content or to attend a protest" not what they believe. newyorker.com/news/news-desk… 2/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika Good @yaffaesque (h/t @ASAnews) interviewed #SocProf Greg Yudin. Yudin also wrote a critique of Putin's war opendemocracy.net/en/odr/russia-… & engaged in its protest before being beaten by Putin's thugs. jordanrussiacenter.org/news/why-no-ma… I appreciate his reflections here. #KnowledgeActivism 3/3

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika @yaffaesque @ASAnews "building paranoia & polarization in Russian society. Citizens are denouncing one another in an eerie echo of Stalin’s terror, spurred on by vicious official rhetoric from the state & enabled by far-reaching new laws that criminalize dissent." nytimes.com/2022/04/09/wor… #HellSpreads

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika I appreciate how @Max_Fisher spells out the challenge of #SeekingJustice around Russia's #WarCrimes in its assault on Ukraine. nytimes.com/2022/04/10/wor… along with other articles illuminating, as grid.news/story/global/2… by @joshuakeating

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika So much power in this interview with @Klitschko & @Vitaliy_Klychko Not only are these great boxers & political leaders putting lives on the line to defend Ukraine, but they articulate compelling messages to move those beyond to #StandWithUkraine.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika I appreciate how @Zourabichvili_S speaks @MSNBC about Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the importance of coming to #StandWithUkraine. Esp that Putin's goal is unclear, & wrong to assume, now, he has one. Rather, we should see this as a Russian "habit" or "tradition" of such assault.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @morningmika Thx to @lesiavasylenko for telling @yasminv the depth of #UKRSuffering: 179 children killed in 46 days. Know particulars. 3 year old child killed by shrapnel. Russian soldiers rape boys and girls alike. #WarCrimes proliferate but consider guilt of those who see but do nothing.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ Thx to @HagarChemali @Morning_Joe for drawing the contrast btwn Obama's infamous red line re Syria's chemical warfare, something she knows well, & @POTUS's vague comments around proportionality of response to Putin's criminality. More comparisons please; they are critical.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @POTUS The #CulturalPolitics & #InfoWar conducted in Ukraine's defense from Russian invasion are remarkable nytimes.com/2022/04/13/us/… at both technical & meaning-filled levels. After this war, #EpistemicSecurity will be more critical than ever. #TruthMatters. So do its vehicles.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @POTUS Of course one consequence of his evil war and the global solidarity mobilized against Putin and his enablers is the exodus of those knowledge workers who belong more to #WorldSociety than to a criminal Russia. nytimes.com/2022/04/13/tec… #RussianCatastrophe

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @POTUS Putin's assault has moved, as of 4/12/22, 4,656,509 people to flee since 2/24/22 his criminal invasion. data2.unhcr.org/en/situations/… Polandhosts 2,669,637; Romania709,249; Hungary434,342; Russia 433,083; Moldova 415,850; Slovakia
323,020; Belarus 21,852.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali In #PKJ we’ve been engaging #genocide historically, comparatively, sociologically (w @martinshawx et al) but also contemporaneously w regard to Ukraine. @POTUS just distinguished its sociological & legal sensibilities.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali I'm with @chucktodd today: although @POTUS performs a gaffe, it is more than that. It is a signal to Putin and Russia. If this is legally recognized as genocide, as Biden believes with his own sociology, the world is obliged to halt Putin, as his troops maneuver to destroy Donbas

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd @POTUS Naming things as they are is not only critical to resisting evil. It's also the first step in sociology. To identify Russian actions as genocide carries terrific consequence. #KnowledgeCulturalSociology

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd "Freedom must be armed better than tyranny". Compelling communication from @ZelenskyyUa: #ArmUkraineNow. With what #WarTechnologies? It's quite specific and laced with moving accounts of what #FreedomMeans.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd About the time @ZelenskyyUa makes that extraordinarily compelling please for more #WarTechnologies, Russia lost their Moskva (to a UKR strike?), nytimes.com/live/2022/04/1… its Black Sea fleet flagship & assailant of #SnakeIsland. #SymbolicPower

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd @ZelenskyyUa More on Moskva's sinking nytimes.com/2022/04/15/us/… a) US confirms it resulted from UKR missile strike; b) explains its military consequence, eg making amphibious assault on Odesa more difficult; c) represents shift in #WarTechnologies toward "ship-killing missiles" -- Neptunes.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd @ZelenskyyUa "Thank you for not killing us" offered Maryna Hanitska nytimes.com/live/2022/04/1… in an expression of resistance to the evil of #PutinRussia's "brutal, sadistic, ill-disciplined & juvenile" troops threatening to murder residents in a mental health facility. #WarCrimesInUkraine

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd @ZelenskyyUa Brutality & extraordinary violence is part of all wars, but it runs deep in Russian military where it is not punished. Too many survivors attest to this criminality. But how far does responsibility extend? nytimes.com/2022/04/17/wor… Into Russian society itself? Or is this #infowar?

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd @ZelenskyyUa Among #WarConsequences has been to make the entire, esp Western Black Sea, more dangerous as mines drift, even toward the Bosphorus. voanews.com/a/amid-russia-… Whose mines, with what purpose, remains debated, as itself part of #InfoWar. #WarTechnologies

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd Russians are not the only military to use banned weapons, as Ukrainian forces also use cluster munitions against those who have invaded their country nytimes.com/2022/04/18/wor… @marywareham must be critical, calling the use of these #WarTechnologies "dismaying" but not outrageous.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd @marywareham "West is focused on sending longer-range weapons like howitzers, antiaircraft systems, anti-ship missiles, armed drones, armored trucks, personnel carriers & tanks" nytimes.com/2022/04/19/wor… upping the #WarTechnologies ante. Risk? Moving a wider war? Or not enabling #UKRVictory?

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @chucktodd We have witnessed too many instances of #PutinRussia's #WarCrimesInUkraine to be shocked anymore nytimes.com/2022/05/13/opi… but @pavlokovtonyuk shows how psychological terror & assaults on health care combine with horrific effect.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali Recalling @fotoole & reading @Milbank's appropriately ominous warning washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/… I struggle with how the #SelfFulfillingProphecy works in this #CivilWar context. #KCS

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali Referencing my late @UMSociology colleague Phil Converse, @Edsall marks how far we've come from the 1960s when ideologues were a distinct minority in the US electorate nytimes.com/2022/05/25/opi…. Today #PolarizationRules but how that happens is contested 1/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @UMSociology Contests: are elites or also publics so polarized? Is it affect or policy/ideology driving #PolarizationRules in publics? Is it sorting? ideological constraints? However, over last 40 yrs individuals have become more ideologically consistent, leading to affective distance. 2/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @UMSociology It matters too who runs: “when costs of running for office are high or benefits of holding office are low, more moderate candidates are disproportionately less likely to run.” Hence the vicious circle enabling #PolarizationRules. Thx @Edsall nytimes.com/2022/05/25/opi… 3/3

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali Continuing rvu of #polarizationrules nytimes.com/2022/06/01/opi…, @Edsall addresses heredity, noting @WatsonInstitute Rose McDermott's work which found that about 60% of the ideological differences among folks "is genetically influenced.” He quotes her to explain what she means. 1/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali Many #KnowledgeCulturalSociology issues involved in this rvu, & larger #NatureNurture debate. Translating ideological contentions into enduring propensities like conflict/cooperative dispositions, as well as invoking genetic causalities in public culture itself, invite #KCSo 2/2

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali "The only issue, come November, is which suite of #TooFar issues has the greatest sway." nytimes.com/2022/06/01/opi… @CharlesMBlow shows, again, his #SocProf inclinations by naming an ideological condition defining our times. Backlash is another expression of #PolarizationRules.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali Drawn back to this @Edsall discussion of @SBUPoliSci's Huddy & Willman: “Openness to experience consistently boosts feminism.” A predilection for authoritarianism, in contrast, “consistently lowers support for feminism”.. nytimes.com/2021/10/27/opi… even while paradoxes proliferate.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @SBUPoliSci "The explosion of defiant, desperate feminist energy that was #MeToo has now been smothered by an even fiercer reaction... Now that Heard has been destroyed for identifying as a survivor, other women will think twice." nytimes.com/2022/06/02/opi… Thx
@michelleinbklyn

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @SBUPoliSci This verdict reinforces translations, where "creeps are treated as martyrs, and every loudmouth is a free-speech warrior (becoming) famous men with lucrative sinecures on cable news..." nytimes.com/2022/06/02/art… Thx @aoscott for illuminating #CancelCulture backlash depravities

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @SBUPoliSci Back to #PolarizationRules @Edsall makes an invaluable contribution nytimes.com/2022/06/08/opi… esp for those who like to talk about extremists "on both sides". Drawing on pundits & academics both, those w critical sense deny the equivalence of #MagaMythos extremists & the "Squad" 1/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @SBUPoliSci Yes, "both sides" challenge their party leaderships but #MagaMythos folks are "bullies" w/out real policy agendas believing more in themselves & their social media than in govt; the Squad has meaningful policy goals bc they find the State plays a critical role #SeekingJustice 2/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @HagarChemali @SBUPoliSci Here's a dilemma: does the Squad "damage" their party more than #MagaMythos extremists damage GOP? #RuthBlochRubin marks @POTUS responsibility here but notes commonality of such Squad criticism. But if extremists don't damage #GOPoT what does that say about its place among US? 3/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ Heed conservative @NormOrnstein who, @Edsall reports, finds @AOC smart & Squad w/out authoritarian views, but that #MAGAMythos folks embrace #TrumpLies & believe US to "need a caudillo" nytimes.com/2022/06/08/opi… 4/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @NormOrnstein Appreciating @ed_kilgore's nymag.com/intelligencer/… @Edsall references his account of the #MagaMythos group as "experienced ideological extortionists answering to gangster leadership of Trump". 5/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @NormOrnstein My take: both "Squad" & #MagaMythos embody their publics, but @AOC @AyannaPressley et al offer progressive policy options while respecting their party & the democratic process. #GOPoT seeks to elevate their own celebrity, democracy be damned, & risk US all in the process. 6/6

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @NormOrnstein @AOC More great assemblage by @Edsall on #PolarizationRules but this time going beyond social media's harm to consider its (fewer) benefits and the mechanisms by which it realizes its partisanship, notably to #GOPoT benefit nytimes.com/2022/06/15/opi… A very useful article. Read it.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @trzaskowski_ @NormOrnstein "Voters subject to oppression have only two choices: the benevolent captors (Democrats) or the cruel captors (Republicans)." nytimes.com/2022/07/10/opi… "Helping to ensure @POTUS's re-election becomes an act of self preservation." Pragmatism w awareness. Thx @CharlesMBlow

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt "We are ruled by a gerontocracy. @POTUS is 79. @SpeakerPelosi is 82. @LeaderHoyer is 83. @SenSchumer, is 71. Often, it’s not clear if they grasp how broken this country is." nytimes.com/2022/07/11/opi… Harsh if truth from @michelleinbklyn, for me 2b read alongside @CharlesMBlow above

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @LeaderHoyer @SenSchumer @michelleinbklyn Dread over US future brews. @Yascha_Mounk lays out why: Trump, esp in power, is dangerous, requiring a resounding if unlikely Dem victory in 24. persuasion.community/p/mounk-americ… Shouldn't we move solidarity in the face of disaster? Figuring how is the key q but his "realism" seals dread

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi W @Yascha_Mounk @Morning_Joe, @ruthbenghiat marks a critical Trump element: he "changed people's perception of violence... as righteous & morally acceptable.. w an emotional retraining at his rallies". On #January6th he sent them off to the Capitol. Please note that @RepRaskin.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @ruthbenghiat @RepRaskin Another critical point from @ruthbenghiat: as Fascists with their Brownshirts, Trump et al have mobilized a paramilitary wing (Proud Boys etc) and even ordinary citizens to exercise that violence, a vigilante justice, to assure authoritarian political culture thru #GOPoT rule.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk "To reduce the threat of political violence, @KurtBraddock says, the first step is to call out the disinformation online and in right-wing media" science.org/content/articl… Recall too #CivilWar Thx @rpocisv h/t @SominiSengupta

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @rpocisv Most in #SocTwitter would not imagine gender gap to be about differences btwn men & women as much as how gender ideology works in shaping various politics & practices nytimes.com/2022/07/20/opi… @Edsall draws on polisci & psych to establish this. #SociologyMatters, but distinctively?

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @rpocisv @Edsall Many in US buy "into an apocalyptic vision of America that bears no relationship to the reality of how the other half thinks.. this dystopian fantasy (has already led) to political violence & attempts to overthrow democracy" nytimes.com/2022/07/25/opi… So #TrumpFantasy molds politics

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @rpocisv Do we overestimate ideology's power to overrule love & care? I am glad that @CongressmanGT does not allow GOP disdain for #LGBTQ+ people to get in the way of supporting his gay son's marriage. washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/07… I wish GT strength in moving love ahead of politics in policy.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock Being in NC 1975-86, I have special affection for the state, & special distress when I learn of the vitriol dripping from the lips of Senate-seeking residents filled with hate & resentment americanindependent.com/meet-anti-lgbt… So grateful for public figures like @CheriBeasleyNC. h/t @Timodc

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @CheriBeasleyNC @Timodc In this 🧵 dedicated to #PolarizationRules I focus on US, but much can be learned by comparing one nation's dynamics to another's. nytimes.com/2022/09/21/wor… Italy intrigues, especially as it wrestles with its explicitly fascist shadow & fantasy's liberation from that burden. 1/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @CheriBeasleyNC Intellectual @umbertocroppi has proposed that the Italian right and fantasy fans share a “vision of spirituality against materialism, a metaphysical vision of life against the forms of the modern world.” nytimes.com/2022/09/21/wor…, with migration apparently one of those forms 2/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock W colleagues like @KubikJan & @JaremaPiekutows I look forward to comparisons -- contrasting traditional vs fantasy grounds for #MythosPower, whether migrants are inevitably cast as enemies or might be loved as Matthew 25:40, & whether patriarchy must dominate in such cultures 3/3

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan @JaremaPiekutows With #EpochEnd in mind, my colleagues and I discuss policies, practices and imaginaries in the world historical context of Russian invasion of Ukraine & #covid19. Live-streamed. Looking forward!

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan @JaremaPiekutows Our first speaker, Harald Wydra polis.cam.ac.uk/Staff_and_Stud… focuses on the limits of state action... beginning with the #KosovoPrecedent in Russian state policy in its own transgressions of national borders.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan @JaremaPiekutows In his discussion, Prof Wydra properly focuses on frontiers, contrasting walls, open borders, and flexible boundaries, the effect of Russia's policies notably today with its treatment Ukraine's boundaries but not so limited... statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan @JaremaPiekutows Intriguing: globalization does not just open boundaries but it also blurs limits on state action... observes Professor Wydra. Liberal internationalism, as NATO support for Kosova, is not a promise but a threat for some, notably Serbia and Russia. Red lines for state action blur.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan @JaremaPiekutows Liberalism has not resisted its own imperial qualities, Prof Wydra observes, notably with drones as acts of counter-insurgency. With climate change, war & their refugees, state actions are also limited. #Covid19 also creates (invisible) enemies impinging on sovereignty as such.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan @JaremaPiekutows Finally Putin: envy of status and power of Russia's rival, already exemplified by America in its 19th c Monroe Doctrine. US is its rival, but also Russia's model; Hitler's example in Sudetenland, is also Putin's in Crimea, hoping for appeasement in light of fears of Evil expanded

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan @JaremaPiekutows Should we not consider limits, Prof Wydra asks? Civil War might be the worst of all kinds of war, & it is apparent in more spaces than we typically acknowledge. Drawing on Camus, what is the spirit that might unite the West, but escalate the conditions in which nobody wins.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan @JaremaPiekutows Drawing on JPII - "conquer evil with good", then Sakharov, which to prefer? domination by another system or complete annihilation? We must search now for spirits that might offer hope. So concludes Prof Wydra. Consider previous 6 tweets too. 7/7

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan Our next speaker in statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/: @jgotkowska addresses scenarios for war's end & European security architecture.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan Reviewing general sense of need to support Ukraine in victory, but France, Germany, & other allies have different emphases & strategic goals in war's end. Security not only of Ukraine but also EU's eastern flank is being decided in this war, offers @jgotkowska

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan Among other game changes in this new security architecture, Poland may have a new more prominent place in its definition, offers @jgotkowska, alongside a European pillar in NATO. Of course all depends on #WarTrajectory in Ukraine. 3/3

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan Our next speaker Oystein Tunsjo @IFS_Oslo brings China into the discussion, noting the polarity btwn US & China, & Putin's failed promise to Xi to conduct a swift operation in Ukraine, but continuing the strategic alliance mostly as a big petrol station exporting oil & gas.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan Unprecedented shift in power as China rises to be superpower rival to US, as Europe moves to periphery of geopolitical contest, says Øystein Tunsjø @IFS_Oslo, anticipating military contest over Taiwan, distracting US from European defense. Europe needs prepare for next war 2/2

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @KubikJan We are fortunate to have @Pawel_Musialek as our moderator in this discussion. statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/ Thank you.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock Our next speaker is @OlafOsica, drawing our attn to how #Covid19 has changed our sense of mobility & space; the recomposition of Europe's east, notably around Russia's imperial decline, along with alliances made only of lip service; & last, consolidation of West, a @POTUS effect.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Our next speaker streamed from NY, @DrPippaM, frames her remarks around superpower rivalries with this time being the true end of the USSR. 2022's war, however, may have begun in January warsawinstitute.org/russia-cripple… This war must end in diplomacy, not crushing defeat for Russia.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica concluding statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/ with particular mechanisms for developing a grand strategy for a post-war circumstances, @DrPippaM emphasizes Marshall Plan, people to people, but also deconfliction superpower channels among other issues. 2/2

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica We are back to livestream statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/ in the conference, as @JaremaPiekutows introduces the session in which Katarzyna Kasia, Wolfgang Palaver and I offer our own contributions.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Beginning our session, @WolfgangPalaver contrasts closed and open societies by elaborating approaches by Henri Bergson & René Girard to their origins and possibilities. We need solidarity on the local, and on the global levels.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Continuing w McLuhan's optimism about electronic communications & the global village, the rise of envy and resentment is also there. It "ensures maximal disagreement" with more spite and envy, even enabling the emergence of the anti-Christ more readily offers @WolfgangPalaver 2/2

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica @WolfgangPalaver Following my own presentation, Katarzyna Kasia utp.berlin/dr-katarzyna-k… properly focuses on climate catastrophe, in which we already exist, & the effects of #Covid19 on it, & technology's value, even if unequally distributed, thru the pandemic.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica @WolfgangPalaver In Poland & more broadly Russia's invasion of Ukraine came to supplant #Covid19 in our epoch ending imagination, Prof Kasia offers. But in light of all this crisis, we need hope through a deeper revolution around post-humanism in collective responsibility & worldly fragility. 2/2

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica @WolfgangPalaver Monika Kostera author of empik.com/after-the-apoc… offers the first comment following scheduled presentations, drawing on her collaboration with the late Zygmunt Bauman, about the idea of interregnum.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica @WolfgangPalaver As promised during the presentation, I have posted the paper academia.edu/87137140/Viole… on which my powerpoint presentation academia.edu/87136128/Viole… was based.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Beginning our afternoon session statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/ on new economic policies, @piotrarak, author of virtualo.pl/ebook/pandenom… takes off from his address of neoliberalism / Washington Consensus after 1989, and its end, beginning with the 2007-08 financial crisis.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica The state becomes more prominent in the last decade, however, thru a) growing military spending; b) economic sanctions on an unprecedented scale; and c) using fiscal policy to address inflationary situation, notes @piotrarak, but #Covid19 has been the most proximate cause here.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica In war greater portions of state revenues can be directed toward military actions, but also managing crisis mobilized by energy politics tied to Russia's invasion. Coming decade will see higher state spending, with Middle East being more prominent trade partner - @piotrarak 3/3

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Next statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/, @JEmilewicz notes that no states questioned importance of state spending during #Covid19 -- in fact, speed & scope of Polish action was unprecedented, & successful. Before the war, the Polish economy was in fact booming. Strong state is sign of times

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Also remarkable is the number of Ukrainian migrants to Europe, esp to Poland, with 1.5 million newcomers, reminds @JEmilewicz. 1) Poland provided ID #s enabling kids to go to school, people to labor market & health services, transportation.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica 2) Drs & nurses, among others, were given right to practice, w/out effect on joblessness: 4.6% unemployment rate is nevertheless the lowest in Poland since 1919, and second lowest in Europe now. 3) Ukrainian children were given school access too, reminded @JEmilewicz.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica 4) @JEmilewicz: Ukrainians had come to Poland since 2014, providing a social foundation for 2022 refugees, associated with very positive opinion toward them. 5) Finally, there are no refugee camps, with people often living with Polish families. They support, not disrupt, economy

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Poland is discovering the power of state interventionism in this context, ever more necessary in war times. Thx @JEmilewicz 5/5

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Glad to see Michal Sutowski @krytyka moderating this session

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica @krytyka Next, Janina Petelczyc krytykapolityczna.pl/bio/petelczyc/ discussing social security system, with Ukrainian workers contributing to state capacities. But they are paid less, & migrants from places other than Ukraine are not so welcomed, reminding us of the Polish/Belarusian border.

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica @krytyka Prof Petelczyc reminds us of how pension funds are investing in funds that are worsening climate change, recommending that Poles know more clearly how their pensions are being invested. She recommends we consider reclaimfinance.org/site/ as an example for how pensions work 2/2

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica @krytyka Online #JeffreySachs marks disruptions shaping #EpochEnd. Short term, we can already see economic contraction. Aggregate demand side policy can't be used to address stagflation. Rather need to address supply side, but they come from pandemic & war. statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica @krytyka Esp w climate change supply side shocks to global economy will continue, w short-term oriented politicians trying to hold onto power w/out longterm thinking. #JeffreySachs recommends easing geopolitical tensions + long term development strategies like europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headli… 2/2

@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @POTUS @SpeakerPelosi @Yascha_Mounk @KurtBraddock @OlafOsica Huge appreciation to @KedzierskiMarc for this conference, with evidently great discussion on this first full day of the workshop. statelimits.uek.krakow.pl/stream/