1/10 n fact, the agreement, which at first glance appears to be to Russia’s advantage, is—in its own way—beneficial to all parties. My take of the #NordStream-2 deal carnegie.ru/commentary/850…
2/10 Given Germany’s determination to get the pipeline completed, and Russia’s ability to do so, the agreement has given Russia the chance to do just that without coming under additional pressure, while allowing Germany to do it with the U.S. blessing rather than going against it
3/10 The Biden administration, faced with a done deal, managed at the last minute not to be left standing on the sidelines, but to step up as a friend to some of its allies and a guarantor of the interests of others bit.ly/2VjXuec
4/10 The gas pipeline would have been built and Germany would have tried to ease the situation for Ukraine in any case, but now the United States is the co-author of that effort bit.ly/2VjXuec
5/10 Finally, Ukraine, which could easily have been left with nothing but vague promises, has a written agreement between its allies, half of which is devoted to Ukraine, and which includes specific figures bit.ly/2VjXuec
6/10 There’s no denying that Nord Stream 2 will strengthen Gazprom’s negotiating position. In 2020, 55 billion cubic meters of gas was shipped to Europe via Ukraine: precisely the volume that Nord Stream 2 will add to Russia’s current transit capacity bit.ly/2VjXuec
7/10 But if, on the other hand, Gazprom is going to increase its gas supplies to Europe to 200 billion cubic meters or more, as it hopes, it may be in need of the Ukrainian route as well bit.ly/2VjXuec
8/10 he U.S.-German agreement on Nord Stream 2 can only really be understood amid the context of the transition over to green energy that the EU and United States plan to implement during the next fifteen to twenty years bit.ly/2VjXuec
9/10 That transition should balance out the advantage that Russia has gained just now, and provide the West with new ways to stay competitive. As for Ukraine, the West is trying to compensate it by including it in the Europe-wide energy transition bit.ly/2VjXue
10/10 Russia can either prepare for this new format of relations or, as it has done so far, bank on the green plans of its rivals ending in failure bit.ly/2VjXuec
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/8 When Russian President Vladimir Putin attended the summit with U.S. President Joe Biden in Geneva this week, he was representing a new Russia. My take of the Geneva summit in a broader context carnegie.ru/commentary/848…
2/8 The new Russia is no longer developing by building Western institutions. Russia will no longer be evaluated according to external criteria. This is why plans for the summit had no impact on the regime’s treatment of the opposition or independent media bit.ly/3q56gs1
3/8 All of Biden’s attempts to shame Putin for the tribulations of Russian opposition were stonewalled with a lack of understanding and counter-accusations. For Putin, there is no longer a system of coordinates in which those reproaches carry any weight.bit.ly/3q56gs1
THREAD 1/ The police officers who planted drugs on the investigative journalist Ivan #Golunov back in 2019 have been sentenced to 5-12 years in prison and ordered to pay Golunov compensation of 5 million rubles ($68,000). The severity of their sentences is important.
2/ We live in a society that believes that someone who was framed by the security services is lucky that they backed down. People say, “You’re lucky they didn’t put you in jail,” and see that in itself as a victory for the victim and punishment for the perpetrators.
3/ Unfortunately, the security services also think like this: that it’s punishment enough that their operation to frame an innocent person failed, and that person has been amply rewarded by getting off lightly.
2/6Trump may have been considered a pro-Putin president, but it is Biden who has actually done several things desired by Russia: he extended the New START treaty, returned to the Iran deal, and shifted the U.S. stance toward the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline bit.ly/3fahJmm
3/6 Biden is obviously not doing these things to curry favor with Russia, or because he likes Putin. They have been achieved because, unlike Trump, Biden promised he would consult with America’s European allies bit.ly/3fahJmm
1/7 Putin clearly wants to make use of the chance offered by Biden: he remains sure of his diplomatic charisma and his ability to find mutual ground. My take of recent escalation and deescalation carnegie.ru/commentary/844…
2/7 n addition, the Kremlin is confident that the United States and the West in general have no other option but to engage in dialogue with Russia bit.ly/3xCGYVh
3/7 Moscow has put forward arms control, the pandemic, and climate change as possible areas of cooperation, and refusal to cooperate on these issues would undermine the idea of a U.S. foreign policy built on principles and global responsibility bit.ly/3xCGYVh
1/9 THREAD on spring deescalation: Putin’s national address focused on social support & infrastructure, not military, ideological or geopolitical issues. There was nothing for critics to seize on. It wasn’t really about domestic policy either though, over which questions remain.
2/9 Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu has ordered Russian troops to be pulled back from Russia’s border with Ukraine, where they had been massing for several weeks.
3/9 The imprisoned opposition leader Alexei Navalny has been moved to a hospital: first to a prison ward, then to a regular hospital in the town of Vladimir. It’s likely he will be seen by his Moscow doctors, who are calling on him to end his hunger strike.
1/8 It appears that leaders on both sides of the #Russia -#Ukraine border capitalized on the tension there to make contact with the new U.S. administration. My piece about recent events around #Donbasscarnegie.ru/commentary/843…
2/8 The current picture bears a lot more resemblance to the eve of Russia’s five-day war with Georgia back in 2008 than it does to events in Ukraine in 2014 bit.ly/3esaJj5
3/8 If the previous escalation was preceded by pro-Russian mobilization in the east and south of Ukraine, giving it the appearance of a civil war, then the current tension looks a lot more like maneuvers ahead of a conventional conflict between two armies bit.ly/3esaJj5