Erik Zimerman Profile picture
Apr 3 14 tweets 7 min read
#Mariupol has fallen. There remain pockets of resistance. Thermal satellite data tells the story. Fading dots are days old hot spots, bright ones are from the last 24 hours. As we had expected, the fighting moved to the that hotel area in southern edge of the west bank. The last
intense shelling there was on the 30th. It seems to have been clear by the next day or two. April 1st saw a complete lull in artillery fire as forces consolidated the linkup, cleared out taken areas, and repositioned to attack remaining Ukr held pockets. We see no shelling in
#Azovstal industrial for many days now. It is likely clear from any active resistance positions, and the main roads have been in RU hands (including for obs. to west bank positions). We saw infantry forces fight & take the outskirts. However, we are likely to see evidence of
#Russian, #DPR and #Chechen forces (esp. the latter, they like to film themselves!) in #Azovstal proper, as they clear it thoroughly, seizing HQs, fortified positions & perhaps leadership prisoners along the way. We may see some interesting things found in the industrial complex.
Yesterday we saw artillery data move to near the port in the southern pocket, & two residential areas in the northern pocket, outside the large industrial area, including 1 along a main road, It is possible the northern group represent artillery positions shelling the southern
group because they match in number/time & no artillery can be seen outside the city for this date as with other dates. This would indicate #Russia already moved most of its heavy artillery used in the battle for the city elsewhere, and the last shelling is being done with smaller
pieces with shorter ranges. The thermal data near the port in the south has been inching eastward daily, so we may expect an assault on the port itself soon. Shelling has finally ceased along Tahanrozka road (E58), so that the large #Livoberezhnyi district is finally cleared &
in RU / #DPR hands. It is a large and dense district that required many days of clearing operations, after the main strategic areas & roads had been taken. The #Ukrainian hold on the city is finally broken after a very brave resistance. There remains only isolated pockets without
the possibility of victory. There remains some Ukr forces in the northern industrial sector & its adjacent residential areas (now being shelled), some HQ elements likely simply hiding in #Azovstal, and some additional forces around the port area in the south. Russia now controls
main roads through #Mariupol so the logistics connection exists. The airport is in RU hands as well, and what remains is the port & the last areas which will allow a rail link through the city, critical for supplying forces in the front. #Zelensky's govt made it very difficult
for the defenders to surrender (see my earlier post on that), even when the battle had been decided, but amazingly did send helicopters on near suicidal missions to get the #Azov leadership out of the city. Three of those were shot down, two fully loaded & on the way out.
#Azov's deputy commanders was among the dead found in one crash site (2nd chopper crashed in the sea). Very graphic images of this crash site and his body have circulated, along with rumors that french & foreign intel agents were also among those Kiev ordered evacuated. A lower
ranking #Azov commander posted a video message claiming all of that to be Russian propaganda. The #Azov leaders would never abandon their men he claimed. For their leaders to refuse the men the option to surrender, to order a fight to the death, to fail to come to their aid, and
then to flee in secret is not the most honorable of behavior, & one can understand why they refuse to believe it (or wish their men to refuse to believe it). But I am not surprised. Soon we will see who if any among them stayed with their men and chose to go down with their ship.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Erik Zimerman

Erik Zimerman Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ZimermanErik

Apr 5
Must say Chuck makes pretty flimsy points for such a conclusive statement, declaring the #Ukrainian surrender fake. Western media already repeating of course. Let's take a look at them.

1. Soldiers would proudly wear green beret (black/white shirt) in combat.
This is nonsense. Image
These are ceremonial uniforms, not battle fatigues nor even everyday field uniforms. Wearing beret in combat is the exception not the rule, certainly not after 1 month of urban combat. I have never worn my red paratroopers beret in the field much less in combat. ImageImage
2. Unsearched pockets / vests.

This is a better point but ultimately is evidence for the reality and not staging. While a special forces team will quickly & thoroughly search a single prisoner they captured on a mission, mass surrenders in a war situation can work differently.
Read 20 tweets
Apr 5
#Bucha on March 14th and March 10th (cloudy). Some bodies are clearly not visible, especially around the roundabout. This area was the front line between #Irpin & Bucha for a long time. Note the thermal data for the week of Mar 17th. Ironically dead on the Irpin side would point ImageImageImage
more to Russian fire than dead on the Russian front line which all things being equal, point to Ukrainian fire. People going about their business & on bicycles seems to indicate all was relatively normal, and fire (ie sniper fire) from the opposite front could suddenly hit them.
The Ukrainian inexperienced soldiers, seeing movement in the enemy front, likely thought they were enemy forces and were excited about eliminating enemies when they were actually hitting folks on bicycles. In any event, while it certainly warrants objective investigation, the
Read 5 tweets
Apr 4
Western reporting has the #Kherson region more or less like this, w blue areas having been retaken by #Ukraine. Most reporting has been falsely indicating #Russia was losing control of #Kherson itself. The red line corresponds more closely to the front thermal imagining tells us. ImageImage
What is clear is also the lack of intensity in the fighting which means Russia withdrew and repositioned rather than being pushed back by Ukrainian counter offensives. Russia faces the formidable #VitaliyKim, who is more of what #Zelensky is pretending to be during this conflict.
Despite this charismatic opponent, It is in the Kherson region where Russia can still score its greatest feats. The drier flat terrain is made for armored drives. It had seemed that Russia chose to withdraw east of the river in Kherson oblast, but this may be false reporting.
Read 4 tweets
Apr 4
Con't this prev thread.

Additionally, the increasing air superiority Russia enjoys in the east makes it difficult or impossible for large Ukrainian formations to move around in the east. Blown rail lines, bridges & incoming muddy season makes supply in the east difficult.
Russia has reversed many of its problems and heaped them on Ukraine by this withdrawal. It can regain the initiative and if it uses it intelligently, can deliver what is seen as a clear victory. However, it remains to be seen how drastic its withdrawal would be. Given the little
information available to me, compared to the Russian command, I would make this a fake withdrawal from the east bank. A sign that this at least being considered was the recent conquest of #Slavutych. Amazingly, the troops coming out of Belarus on the east bank could only approach Image
Read 14 tweets
Apr 4
Despite the fact that the much publicized #Ukrainian counter-offensive did not amount to anything, & the nearly equally reported encirclement of #Russian forces in NW #Kiev was completely false (as I estimated), the Russian forces have been withdrawing speedily from the area. Image
While the western media is conflating the 2 events, one actually delayed the other. #Russia announced the end of phase 1 & change of focus over 10 days ago. However, the Russian troops could not begin their withdrawal until the Ukrainian offensive was stopped. This is what
occurred and only after the failed offensive ran out of steam, did RU forces withdraw in good order. This is a complex & risky maneuver in itself, and it was done without units collapsing or being encircled. We also haven't seen equipment in significant amounts being left behind.
Read 25 tweets
Mar 25
A word about #Kiev in its treatment of #Mariuopol. Without rehashing details previously covered, it is clear that the fall of the city is imminent and that the regime in Kiev has neither the ability nor the intention to try to come to its aid. No offensive is coming to break the
siege nor are any reinforcements and supplies on their way. The defense of the city by #Azov, #Ukrainian National Guard, Army & Naval infantry units has been heroic in its intensity, doggedness and bravery. Putting aside the legitimacy, virtue & honor of all their actions during
the siege, and all the motivations for such staunch defense (of an intensity unseen elsewhere in Ukraine), also putting aside any & all ideologies any of the defenders may have (ie #Azov & right sector national socialism), the bravery of the defense thus far is unquestionable.
Read 19 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(