1/🧵 A personal story of misjudgment as a physician.
Years ago, when I was a young doctor, I had a patient in the ICU on a ventilator who was doing so poorly, day after day, that I was certain he was going to die.
I confidently told the family he was going to die.
2/ The family members all gathered and were extremely distraught. They listened and trusted me.
3/ For many years to come, I received Christmas cards from this man.
It was extremely humbling.
Until I learned, this happened many other times in my life as an ICU doctor.
Sometimes I was off by just 2 weeks, sometimes 2 months, and other times by 2 years.
4/ I no longer predict how long someone will live.
Instead, when the family or a patient inevitably asks me this question, I “flip it.”
I admit that I honestly don’t know how long s/he will live.
Yet for those severely ill, I prepare them for how quickly death ‘may’ occur.
5/ This “flipping it” both maintains #hope & also helps people become realistic about how sick someone is so that they can mentally prepare and communicate appropriately with one another.
6/ I’m amazed by the number of things during the dying process that often happen in someone’s life to bring long-awaited healing (even without cure) for patients & everyone in their love circle.
To me it’s evidence that we are all greater than the sum of our parts.
7/ During people’s dying process – be it hours, days, months, or years – people deserve to have dignity respected & the entire process honored.
In accordance with many patients’ wishes, we regularly remove ventilators & other life support as part of the natural process of dying.
8/fin
My “Christmas Card” patient never once chided me for predicting (wrongly) his death.
Instead, we became very close. He helped me shed bad prognostication habits & more than a smidge of pride.
Our patients lead us.
I’d love to hear any lessons you have on this topic.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
2/ As part of its efforts, the White House said in a statement that Biden will push to accelerate a $1.5 billion study started last year by the National Institutes of Health to follow 40,000 individuals with and without long Covid to try to better understand the condition.
3/ Biden also proposed spending an additional $25 million on a $50 million study started last year by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to understand the risk factors, mechanisms of action and characteristics of long Covid, the White House said.
2/ We all want to relieve the suffering when people are dying of failing kidneys, lungs, hearts.
Transplant can be a great solution.
As a transplant physician myself, I directed lung transplantation at #Vanderbilt.
I worry this new approach is a breech of the dead donor rule.
3/ The “dead donor rule” (DDR) says donors must be determined dead according to established legal/medical criteria PRIOR to procurement of vital organs.
3/ I am drawn in by my patient's weakness, perhaps because I see even greater weakness in myself.
The person in front of me needs the help I can provide by mustering #compassion, the same compassion I seek from others for MY foibles, deficits & inabilities.