🧵 [1] ALERT: Kremlin-controlled #Gazprom informed #Polish & #Bulgarian officials that it suspended natural gas deliveries to both countries, once again demonstrating how #Moscow continues to weaponize energy against Europe.
[2] 👀 First, the latest flow rates reported by the EU @ENTSOG natural gas network flow transparency portal. According to ENTSOG, Gazprom physical flows at the Kondratki entry point to the Yamal transmission pipeline at the Poland-Belarus border is near zero:
[3] 👀 Meanwhile, @ENTSOG shows the gas flows across at Strandzha-2 interconnector, the entry point of Gazprom’s #TurkStream2 pipeline to the Bulgarian gas transmission system operated by #Bulgartransgaz sharply decreasing in last few days:
[4] The supposed justification for cutoff by #Gazprom is refusal by Polish & Bulgarian energy entities to pay for gas deliveries in Russian roubles per a decree by Vladimir Putin on 23 March, requiring such a payment scheme from “unfriendly countries.”
[5] Poland’s state owned gas entity, @GK_PGNiG, issued a statement today confirming the “decree” by #Putin is not covered in the current Yamal gas transit contract & thus no justification for PGNiG to comply & has no payments due to Gazprom at this time:
◾️To attempt to prop up rouble value by intimidating other #European gas buyers to settle energy payments in the Russian currency.
◾️To reinforce EU concerns over broader Russian energy cutoffs to deter nations from supporting #Ukraine.
[7] For #Poland itself, short & long term energy security impact is blunted by Polish policy actions. Immediately, with the end of the heating season & Poland’s 3.5 bcm capacity storage is 76% full, Warsaw won’t need to cut domestic energy consumption.
[8] Longer term, Poland has already committed to ending imports of Russian gas by end of 2022, when its long-developed diversification project - the Norway-Denmark-Poland #BalticPipe project comes online coupled with its LNG capacity at its Swinoujscie terminal.
[9] Bulgarian officials stated short term energy restrictions aren’t likely. But impact of these cutoffs to downstream customers is still unclear. Ex: #Germany gets gas via Yamal but gas still flowing via #NordStream1 & via 🇺🇦. But regional security of supply issues could arise.
[10] Which brings us back to the beginning of this thread:
Just as it has for many years, the #Kremlin is weaponizing energy in order to coerce political concessions from European democracies, in this case to deter them from supporting Ukrainian sovereignty as Russia attacks 🇺🇦.
[11] This is exactly why analysis arguing why the Kremlin-backed #NordStream2 pipeline was such a “bad deal for Europe” (as @POTUS@JoeBiden first stated in 2016) & needed to be stopped via sanctions & EU regulatory action is once again validated.
[12] Thankfully, months of US & EU diplomacy (led by @amoshochstein) worked to identify immediate-term substitute gas volumes from global LNG suppliers for such a scenario, underscoring the vital need for energy security to be a central component of national security strategies.
[13] Beyond the immediate-term, this weaponization of natural gas exports by the #Putin regime further underscores the necessity to take action *now* to both end EU imports of Russian oil/gas & invest in diversification infrastructure at a wartime level of effort and speed.
[14] How? Check out a report that I’ve coauthored with many leading experts from the International Working Group on Russia Sanctions, coordinated by @FSIStanford@McFaul outlining an urgent comprehensive energy sanctions package on the Putin regime. @CEPA
[15] Some highlights of urgent #Russia energy sanctions measures suggested to be taken in the Working Group report, include:
[16] Expanded oil and gas sanctions, including a full embargo as soon as possible on Russian hydrocarbon exports to global democracies:
[17] Holding the EU to its commitments to reduce & end natural gas imports from Russia, as well as establishing near-term dates to end Russian gas export to the EU via the #NordStream1, #TurkStream2, & Yamal-Europe pipelines & energy security infrastructure development:
[18] Use all EU- & national-level legal mechanisms, including regulations within the EU Third Energy Package, to terminate any partial or majority ownership positions currently held by #Russian state-owned-enterprises in critical #European energy infrastructure installations:
[19]🚢 Increase sanctions to limit the ability of the Russian shipping sector to export hydrocarbon & other critical resources to global markets, by sanctioning Russian shipping majors, as well as increasing sanctions on international insurance & maritime certification providers:
[20] Sanction all members of governing boards of Russian state-owned enterprises, regardless of citizenship, & pass measures to make it legally impossible for former Western government officials to work for Russian state-owned enterprises:
[21] These steps might not sound easy, but Ukraine defending the west from authoritarianism isn’t easy either!
It’s what’s needed to finally break the Kremlin’s energy leverage over Western democracies & urgently support Ukraine to win its fight against Russian aggression. [END]
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🧵
🇺🇸🇪🇺🇺🇦
[1]JUST OUT: Report that I’ve coauthored with the recently-formed International Working Group on Russia Sanctions, coordinated by @FSIStanford@McFaul outlining an urgent comprehensive sanctions package on the Putin regime.
[3] The Group placed an outsized focus on measures that will rapidly & drastically reduce the Kremlin’s ability to continue its criminal war of aggression against Ukraine - targeting Russian hydrocarbon export & banking sector, as well as tightening critical tech export controls.
[2] Recently my @DUCIGS Space Diplomacy Lab Co-Director Prof Giovanni Zanalda & I hosted a roundtable focused on space issues posed by 🇷🇺‘s war on 🇺🇦 & long-term space security challenges w/ space media leaders @LorenGrush, @RaminSkibba & @Jeff_Foust:
👇👇
[3]🚀Recall in Nov, during Russia’s military buildup around Ukraine, the Russian military launched a reckless direct-ascent anti-satellite test, that created a major space debris event & endangered US, EU & Russian personnel on International Space Station
[1] 🚨THREAD🚨 According to @NesteGlobal, Russian Urals crude oil continues to crater in price compared to the Brent crude benchmark. Trading at -$5.65 per barrel on 5 day average.
What does this mean? And how can corporate responsibility urgently support Ukraine? Please read👇
[2] Energy traders still assess sanctions & reputational risk of importing Russian oil, & are avoiding oil tanker calls at Baltic & Black Sea Russian ports due to security & sanctions risk.
Turkish owned ship was struck by a shell in Black Sea today.
[3] This has led Russian Urals oil price per barrel to hit “lowest ever level relative to Brent” at -$11.23 per barrel as of a few hours ago according to S&P Global Platts:
[1] 🇺🇸🇩🇪🇪🇺🇺🇦 Germany’s announcement it has suspended certification of Kremlin’s #NordStream2 pipeline was an urgently needed step given Russia’s overt invasion of Ukraine’s Donbas region. Welcome & long overdue.
[2] Suspending the certification process for #NordStream2 should be seen as a first step by Berlin in deterring further Russian military action against Ukraine, followed by further action to block the pipeline for good.
[3] Berlin should next seek sanctions at the EU level ensuring that the Kremlin-backed #NordStream2 can never come online and be allowed to do lasting harm to European energy security and Ukrainian national security interests in the process.
🇺🇸🇪🇺 [1] With Washington once again focusing on policy options to stop the Kremlin-backed NordStream2 pipeline this week, my attempt at a (hopefully thoughtful) thread to help provide context:
[2] The framing of NordStream2 sanctions has suddenly (and unfortunately) become partisan, but in fact, opposition to NS2 has been bipartisan since 2015, and support for sanctions has been led by Democrats and Republicans since 2017.
[3] The US has opposed #NordStream2 on bipartisan basis since 2015. Congress has passed both discretionary (2017 CAATSA) & mandatory (2019 & 2020 NDAA) sanctions to stop #NS2 on near unanimous basis. In 2016, VP Biden was first prominent senior official to publicly oppose NS2.