Share this page!

Alberto Alemanno Profile picture
Twitter logo
Aug 28 • 26 tweets • 13 min read
🚨 Breaking: European judges challenge the EU approval of #Poland’s recovery & resilience plan before EU General Court just a few months before elections in the country

Here’s a🧵 on why, how and what of this unprecedented development #ruleoflaw #RPP
Why?

4 associations of European judges intend to defend the interests of the judiciary which they represent & their members including Polish judges subjected to disciplinary proceeding, sanctions & involuntary transfers, in breach of EU law & the #rule of law itself
How?

The judges’ associations argue that #ruleoflaw “milestones” fall short of what is required to ensure effective judicial protection and disregard the judgments of the CJEU

They want Council’s decision to be declared nul & void thus preventing transfer of #RPP funding
What’s at stake?

The transfer of 23.8 billion euros of non-repayable support and up to some 11.5 billion euros of loan support (before 🗳). This is the first & only legal challenge questioning legality of Council implementing decision approving #RPP
So what?

While the filing of this legal action does not automatically suspend the effects of the Council implementing decision, the plaintiffs may lodge request for interim measures asking for such a suspension to be decided by the President of the General Court #ruleoflaw
This legal action was prepared - on a pro bono basis - by @GoodLobbyProfs, an initiative of 60+ academics from all over Europe acting as a rapid response mechanism to uphold the rule of law across the continent

Congrats to
@DanielSarmiento @ProfPech @JMorijn @zatschler & co.
For some initial coverage

politico.eu/article/europe… #RuleOfLaw #poland @GoodLobbyProfs @TheGoodLobby
For coverage in French language lalibre.be/international/… @UdrescuMaria @lalibrebe
and in Polish dw.com/pl/kpo-s%C4%99… @TomaszBielecki
More coverage in Polish oko.press/cztery-organiz…
and in Switzerland swissinfo.ch/eng/european-j…
more in Poland wyborcza.pl/7,75399,288398…
and @Reuters reuters.com/world/europe/p…
and in Dutch fd.nl/politiek/14497…
And in French lesechos.fr/monde/europe/p…
And in the bubble euractiv.com/section/politi…
And @POLITICOEurope POLITICO Brussels Playbook: RULE OF LAW politico.eu/newsletter/bru…
And in Spanish elpais.com/internacional/…
barrons.com/news/judges-or… @AFP
And @euronews goes multilingual euronews.com/my-europe/2022…
Full coverage by @ShonaMurray_ on @euronews

euronews.com/my-europe/2022… #poland #nextgeneration #ruleoflaw @GoodLobbyProfs
And here’s @euobs ’s take on European judges’ unprecedented legal action against the 27 governments of the Union euobserver.com/tickers/155885
and in German: EU-Rat wegen Genehmigung von Polens COVID-Milliarden verklagt

de.euronews.com/my-europe/2022… @GoodLobbyProfs @TheGoodLobby
and in Latvian lsm.lv/raksts/zinas/a…
and in French fr.euronews.com/my-europe/2022…
and in Romanian g4media.ro/consiliul-ue-d…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
　

Keep Current with Alberto Alemanno

Alberto Alemanno Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @alemannoEU

Alberto Alemanno Profile picture
Jun 20
The outcome of the French parliamentary elections is highly consequential for both France’s and Europe’s future. Here’s why 🧵

SPOILER: Macron will eventually have to pick either the left or the right!

#electionslegislatives2022 #France #ElectionsLegislatives
1. Macron’s presidential coalition (Ensemble!) came out on top and remains the largest parliamentary force in parliament, BUT lost its absolute majority
2. This leaves us with unprecedented degree of fragmentation and division in the National Assembly, with both the left wing coalition and the far right largely over-performing and squeezing the centre.

Parliamentary power is back! #Elections2022
Read 12 tweets
Alberto Alemanno Profile picture
Jun 17
‼️ The EU Commission paves the way for #Ukraine to gain (conditional) candidate status in record time‼️

Yet that recognition of candidate status may be more symbolic than structural: it may never lead to full membership.

Here’s why 🧵 Image
Today is a moment of truth one for Ukraine, which has invested so much of its political future on a closer relationship with Europe.

There’s political momentum to have #EUCO uniting behind the recognition of candidate status
Despite the lack of a fast track procedure, the EU Commission delivered in record time a positive opinion on 🇺🇦 swift submission to candidate status, in unprecedented conditions (candidate country is at war)
Read 6 tweets
Alberto Alemanno Profile picture
May 10
Did the Conference on the Future of Europe succeed?

It depends very much on how you measure success.

For me it worked beyond expectations.

Here’s why 🧵 #CoFoE #FutureOfEurope
1 If you belong to those who expected #CoFoE to magically deliver a re-opening of the Treaty, you may be disappointed. No majority exists to endorse EP’s demand. That might never materialize. Wait for June #EUCO but it might not be the point project-syndicate.org/commentary/con…
2 If instead you valued #CoFoE as an open-ended (not outcome-bound) process, you may be satisfied. Not only a permanent mechanism of citizen deliberation in EU decision-making is foreseen, but that can be done without treaty change. But there’s more.

euronews.com/2022/01/20/fra…
Read 12 tweets
Alberto Alemanno Profile picture
Apr 29
As the Conference on the Future of Europe comes to an end, what can we reasonably expect?

(Spoiler: a fight over whether, how, and on what to re-open the Treaties NOW)

🧵 #CoFoE
2 Originally promised by @vonderleyen in the aftermath of her rocambolesque appointment, the Conference is the first attempt at institutional reform since 2007.

It didn’t look promising in its early days, but the context has changed.

theguardian.com/commentisfree/… #CoFoE
3 Amid lack of clear majority among Member States & disagreements among EU institutions, #CoFoE was postponed to May 9, 2021 by invoking the pandemic as the official excuse for the delay
This turned out to be a bless as led to redesigning it from scratch
socialeurope.eu/releasing-euro…
Read 12 tweets
Alberto Alemanno Profile picture
Apr 29
No, the vast majority of the recommendations put forward by the Conference on the Future of Europe don’t require Treaty change.

Only 21 out 178, with <120 feasible under existing Treaties #CoFoE

cc: @suzannelynch1 @HankeVela
2. We’ve browsed all 178, and classified them into 4 categories:

1. Recs not requiring new action (23)
2. Recs entailing new action by MS (21)
3. Recs entailing new action by EU (113)
4. Recs entailing Treaty change (21) #cofoe
3. Among the 21 recs requiring Treaty Change, they call for transfer of new competences in:

1.Welfare (7)
2.Education (5)
3.Institutional reforms (4)
4.Health care (2)
5.Taxation (2)
6.Energy (1)
Read 6 tweets
Alberto Alemanno Profile picture
Apr 1
🧵 Over the last 6 months, 800 randomly-selected EU citizens came up with 178 recommendations addressed to EU leaders

How many of them require Treaty change to become a reality?

(Spoiler: just a few)

A 🧵based on empirical work done @VillaVigoni
Credits to students #CoFoE
1. As the end of #CoFoE approaches (May 9), the question arises as to whether/how the EU will/should respond.

What form that response should take?

As we expect that response to be conditioned by the nature of recs proposed, here's a preliminary break out of the 178 recs.
2. We’ve browsed all 178 recs from the 4 Citizens' Panels, and classified them into 4 categories:

1. Recs not requiring new action (23)
2. Recs entailing new action by MS (21)
3. Recs entailing new action by EU (113)
4. Recs entailing Treaty change (21)

#CoFoE
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(