1. Mugshots have the opposite effect of what you say your intent was. There was a reason Willie Horton's mugshot was used in the now infamous George Bush campaign ad & it wasn't to convey that he was a "real human being."
Maybe law enforcement would still have had access to them, but they have now been broadcast to a national audience of people who never would have seen them.
You don't ordinarily use mugshots the way tabloids do. And some tabloids won't use them now, in police blotter type stories.
It feels like you came up with a very cool graphics idea & now it's a post-facto justification.