Thread by @JoeAgneya

You are a very presumptuous, arrogant noob yourself. Not only have you failed to show any valid argument, you have insulted countless apolitical scholars who support OIT. And you have BLOCKED me even BEFORE I posted a response. I will show you no courtesy.

https://twitter.com/schandillia/status/1234102742496366593

Politics is the last resort of scoundrels

This happens when all you read is the unethical, cowardly likes of Witzel-Farmer-Romila-Irfan. How easy to demonize your opponents, ignore their inconvenient scholarship, run away and pretend you are the winner.

https://twitter.com/Schandillia/status/1234102744484462593?s=20

Oh boo-hoo
There were MANY Indian bronze age cultures that were contemporary to ALL phases of Saraswathy-Sindhu Civilization.
Ahar Banas, Rajasthan (3000-1500 BCE)
OCP culture(4th-2nd mBCE)
Corded ware etc

The cultural importance of OCP is EQUAL to SSC.

https://twitter.com/Schandillia/status/1234102754236190722?s=20

There is great variation within SSC itself! Our bronze age is FAR MORE complicated than Steppes. Together, these cultures had~a 3rd of world population! Without even understanding their interrelations, you want to talk of the Caspian sea?

There is a word for you
Colonized mind

Vedic people came from Andronovo?!

Name A SINGLE relevant sample from Andronovo which gave an India specific Z93 clade?

What new Andronovan pottery style entered India?
What new metallurgy, technology or new species of flora/fauna?

In Demoule's words-

https://twitter.com/Schandillia/status/1234102756215885824?s=20

Archaeologists unanimously reject any entry of any people anywhere in South Asia anytime in the 2nd mBCE. As Danino explains, they have been distorting archaeological evidence, fabricating non existing archeo-evidence and ignoring EVERY contrary fact.
academia.edu/39599444/Fabri…

To claim bronze age India didn't have horses and chariots is possible only for someone with an impressive deficiency of GK. Anyone, henceforth, who makes such a statement is unfit for debate. Here is a sum up of the EXTENSIVE evidences of spoked wheels by Krishnendu Das

This pic demonstrates a very important fact. Of all branches of Indo-Europeans, ONLY the Indo-Iranians possess IE words for ALL parts of the wheeled vehicle. Is it a coincidence that the oldest evidence for spokes as well as chariots comes form the Sindhu-Saraswathy civilization?

I intended to expose his nonsense tweet by tweet, but I was blocked even before I posted my thread! I have never seen cowardice of such abysmal magnitude. I am stopping here, leaving aside the foolish things about 'PIE' and 'genetics' he said. I dont even have screenshots.

Linguistics is not physics. The spread of tribes and languages obey no 'Gravity', only Geography. The deserts, mountains, rivers, pastures etc decide how languages spread. OIT is linguistically easy to disprove only when you say 'Sanskrit is PIE'. Even Hans H. Hock admits this-

OIT is supported by strong evidences-

1. Presence of a "European-like" Centum language in Uttarkhand called 'Bangani' [absolutely AIT-incompatible]

2. Location of Centum Tocharian(Uttarakuru)

3. PIE-Austronesian contact- They could have met ONLY in South Asia!

etc

Anyone who blindly accepts the authority and methodology of Harvard geneticists should read this article. They have done great contribution to the science, but when it comes to the question of Indo-Europeans, they have a colonial era legacy to preserve.
nytimes.com/2019/01/17/mag…

Here are clinching facts from Indo-Iranian texts. No AIT proponent will DARE acknowledge it.

-Rig Veda makes it explicitly clear that Proto-Iranian groups were living in the Sapta Sindhu.

-The Avesta also declares beyond doubt that Hapta-Hendu & Haraivati are their homelands

@Schandillia, if you believe you can demonstrate the soundness of AIT/AMT/Aryan osmosis, dispute these facts.

Read as much as your want & show if ANY of the 100s of~2000 BCE Andronovo/Sintashta skeletal samples gave an India specific lineage. Or it is NOT ancestral to Indians.