1/10 THREAD Biden’s call to Putin and the new round of sanctions against Russia were planned at the same time.
2/10 During their phone call, Biden heard nothing from Putin that could put the sanctions on hold: nothing suggesting Russia would change its behavior. That, of course, was never going to happen.
3/10 The new sanctions, coming hot on the heels of the phone call, are a necessary framework to dialogue with Putin for the new U.S. administration. They will dispel even the slightest suspicion of a rapprochement, avoiding disappointment among U.S. allies.
4/10 Within this framework, it’s unlikely that Putin will accept the U.S. proposal to meet, since the proposal comes from a position of strength.
5/10 Even if he accepts it, the summit could descend into a war of words like that already seen between US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and his Chinese counterpart. And there’s not much point in a summit like that.
6/10 The summit will likely take place, only at a later date, when things are less tense. America cannot avoid a dialogue with Russia.
7/10 Sanctions won’t change Russia’s behavior, because the list of demands is too long and vague-from Donbas & Crimea to election interference, cyber attacks & disinformation. With such a long list of demands, there’s little prospect of the new sanctions ever being lifted.
8/10 The U.S. move along the path of sanctions could mean that Russia will tread more carefully along the path of escalation. It could decide against some future tough actions.
9/10 But for now, Russia will make no notable overtures of peace. Accordingly, the escalation over the Donbas may continue.
10/10 The US will be able to chalk up the lack of a major war to the success of its sanctions policy.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/7 In 2017 #Trump answering a similar question did not reject outright the questioner’s assertion that #Putin was a killer, but managed to dilute his answer. My current piece about «Putin is a killer» from president #Biden interview to @abcnewscarnegie.ru/commentary/841…
2/7 Biden’s blunt assessment was meant to show the rest of the world that the US is returning to world leadership based on high moral standards. This should be met with particular approval by U.S. allies who are under pressure from Russia bit.ly/3tPfU2K
3/7 As Biden was one of the architects of the “reset” with Russia during Barack Obama’s first presidential term, it’s important for him to make it clear that no amount of common interest or work on specific policy areas means a new reset is in the offing bit.ly/3tPfU2K
1/4 On #Armenia: the post-Soviet space has seen everything from wars, revolutions and palace coups to dictatorships, hybrid regimes and the hereditary handover of power. Everything—except a classic military coup.
2/4If the army ousts Armenian Prime Minister Nikol #Pashinyan and appoints a new government—provisional or otherwise—to maintain order until new elections, it will be the first genuine military coup in the post-Soviet space.
3/4 #Armenia would join the ranks of an exclusive club of countries in the Middle East and Asia in which the army performs the role of a political moderator and overseer.
2/7 The idea of dignity as a trigger for political protest in Russia is complicated in #Navalny case by the fact that for so many Russians, dignity has long been expressed in the form of resistance to the West. carnegie.ru/commentary/838…
3/7 There is huge inertia within Russian society. Most people sense that the regime is not, in fact, on the verge of collapse, and that mass street protests are unlikely to accelerate the end of the #Putin era carnegie.ru/commentary/838…
1/4 I had mistakenly thought that with the three and a half year sentence #Navalny would be in prison during the Russian presidential elections in 2024.
2/4 But since the previously served year of home arrest counts toward the sentence, he should be released just before the elections in March 2024. Could it be a sign that Putin plans to leave by 2024 and organize snap elections, transferring power to a successor?
3/4 Unfortunately, there will always be the possibility of adding to Navalny's sentence at a later date. At the same time, it is unclear what would complicate the transfer of power more – Navalny imprisoned or free.
THREAD 1/7 Saturday’s protests were also noticeable for the lack of humorous slogans and placards in comparison with previous Russian protests . The protesters were very serious, even gloomy. From my current piece carnegie.ru/commentary/837…
2/7 The slogans lacked the usual appeals to the law, democracy, and the constitution. This protest was not about calling on the authorities to follow the law, count votes fairly, allow candidates to run. It was a march against those in power bit.ly/36d6zIm
3/7 Unlike the protests that followed the murder of the opposition politician Boris Nemtsov in 2015, Saturday’s Moscow rally was not dominated by representatives of the capital’s liberal intelligentsia bit.ly/36d6zIm
1/7 The new round of sanctions introduced by the EU against Russia over the poisoning of opposition politician Alexei Navalny have three key aspects. My take here carnegie.ru/commentary/829…
2/7They target individual people and organizations, rather than entire sectors of the economy; they don’t follow the suggestion of targeting the subjects of Navalny’s investigations; and they don’t distinguish between the siloviki (security services) hawks and in-system liberals
3/7 The list does not mention the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, although judging by multiple public statements made on the issue, canceling the pipeline project is seen as the most effective punishment bit.ly/3dF8t7m